Full OSD support on Wayland

[LynXDTS]

Please, if possible, implement the feature present in https://github.com/git-developer/sc-controller - fork of original package from kozec.

Feature in question - possibility to summon OSD in wayland.

[LynXDTS]

As I see - both of the projects utilize python3 instead of original's python2

[C0rn3j]

There's no OSD differences as far as I see.

Do you have the gtk-layer-shell dependency installed? It won't work without it.
I just marked it and the rest of the deps as hard deps, as not having it just bit me on my own system, at least in the readme. Let's have a unified experience.
It might be a good idea that the deps are verified in the code too.

Just summoning and closing the OSD menu makes the daemon sad with an error - which probably should be marked as debug instead:

D SCCDaemon     STICK locked by <scc.sccdaemon.Client object at 0x7fc92d7697c0>
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.A locked by <scc.sccdaemon.Client object at 0x7fc92d7697c0>
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.B locked by <scc.sccdaemon.Client object at 0x7fc92d7697c0>
E OSD osd.menu      Sucessfully locked input
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.B unlocked
D SCCDaemon     STICK unlocked
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.A unlocked

The bigger problem is that attempting to use the "Display Keyboard" option crashes the scc-osd-daemon:

[247347.701772] input: SCC OSD Keyboard as /devices/virtual/input/input58
[247347.702020] input: SCC OSD Mouse as /devices/virtual/input/input59
[247347.702745] python[1822375]: segfault at 200000041 ip 00007ec6634c5045 sp 00007ffc42bedca0 error 6 in libX11.so.6.4.0[a3045,7ec663439000+94000] likely on CPU 10 (core 4, socket 0)
[247347.702752] Code: 15 f0 92 09 00 49 89 c5 48 85 c0 0f 84 61 fd ff ff 49 89 87 20 0a 00 00 49 8b 47 08 48 8d 0d 92 df fe ff 48 8d 3d 4a 95 00 00 <48> 89 48 40 41 83 4d 04 12 ff 15 cc 88 09 00 48 85 c0 0f 84 11 02

I don't think we should be using X11 there at all?

D SCCDaemon     STICK unlocked
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.A unlocked
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.B unlocked
D OSD osd.keyboard  Using font DejaVu Sans
I OSD profile       Converted button(Keys.KEY_LEFTSHIFT) to trigger(50, button(Keys.KEY_LEFTSHIFT))
I OSD profile       Converted button(Keys.KEY_LEFTCTRL) to trigger(50, button(Keys.KEY_LEFTCTRL))
D OSD Mapper        Creating virtual devices
D OSD Mapper        Keyboard: <scc.uinput.Keyboard object at 0x775af0624590>
D OSD Mapper        Mouse:    <scc.uinput.Mouse object at 0x775af06b7da0>
D OSD Mapper        Gamepad:  <scc.uinput.Dummy object at 0x775af06b57f0>
D SCCDaemon     LEFT locked by <scc.sccdaemon.Client object at 0x7fc92d7697c0>
D SCCDaemon     RIGHT locked by <scc.sccdaemon.Client object at 0x7fc92d7697c0>
D SCCDaemon     STICK locked by <scc.sccdaemon.Client object at 0x7fc92d7697c0>
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.STICKPRESS locked by <scc.sccdaemon.Client object at 0x7fc92d7697c0>
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.RPADTOUCH locked by <scc.sccdaemon.Client object at 0x7fc92d7697c0>
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.LPADTOUCH locked by <scc.sccdaemon.Client object at 0x7fc92d7697c0>
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.RPAD locked by <scc.sccdaemon.Client object at 0x7fc92d7697c0>
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.LPAD locked by <scc.sccdaemon.Client object at 0x7fc92d7697c0>
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.RGRIP locked by <scc.sccdaemon.Client object at 0x7fc92d7697c0>
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.LGRIP locked by <scc.sccdaemon.Client object at 0x7fc92d7697c0>
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.START locked by <scc.sccdaemon.Client object at 0x7fc92d7697c0>
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.C locked by <scc.sccdaemon.Client object at 0x7fc92d7697c0>
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.BACK locked by <scc.sccdaemon.Client object at 0x7fc92d7697c0>
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.A locked by <scc.sccdaemon.Client object at 0x7fc92d7697c0>
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.X locked by <scc.sccdaemon.Client object at 0x7fc92d7697c0>
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.B locked by <scc.sccdaemon.Client object at 0x7fc92d7697c0>
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.Y locked by <scc.sccdaemon.Client object at 0x7fc92d7697c0>
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.LB locked by <scc.sccdaemon.Client object at 0x7fc92d7697c0>
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.RB locked by <scc.sccdaemon.Client object at 0x7fc92d7697c0>
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.LT locked by <scc.sccdaemon.Client object at 0x7fc92d7697c0>
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.RT locked by <scc.sccdaemon.Client object at 0x7fc92d7697c0>
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.CPADTOUCH locked by <scc.sccdaemon.Client object at 0x7fc92d7697c0>
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.CPADPRESS locked by <scc.sccdaemon.Client object at 0x7fc92d7697c0>
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.STICKPRESS locked by <scc.sccdaemon.Client object at 0x7fc92d7697c0>
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.RSTICKPRESS locked by <scc.sccdaemon.Client object at 0x7fc92d7697c0>
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.DOTS locked by <scc.sccdaemon.Client object at 0x7fc92d7697c0>
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.RGRIP2 locked by <scc.sccdaemon.Client object at 0x7fc92d7697c0>
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.LGRIP2 locked by <scc.sccdaemon.Client object at 0x7fc92d7697c0>
W Actions       Action KeyboardAction can't handle button release event
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.CPADPRESS unlocked
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.STICKPRESS unlocked
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.RSTICKPRESS unlocked
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.DOTS unlocked
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.RGRIP2 unlocked
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.LGRIP2 unlocked
D SCCDaemon     LEFT unlocked
D SCCDaemon     RIGHT unlocked
D SCCDaemon     STICK unlocked
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.STICKPRESS unlocked
W SCCDaemon     scc-osd-daemon died; restarting after 5s
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.RPADTOUCH unlocked
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.LPADTOUCH unlocked
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.RPAD unlocked
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.LPAD unlocked
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.RGRIP unlocked
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.LGRIP unlocked
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.C unlocked
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.START unlocked
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.BACK unlocked
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.A unlocked
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.X unlocked
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.B unlocked
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.Y unlocked
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.LB unlocked
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.RB unlocked
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.LT unlocked
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.RT unlocked
D SCCDaemon     SCButtons.CPADTOUCH unlocked
I SCCDaemon     scc-osd-daemon lost
D OSD DaemonCtrl    Connected to daemon, version 0.4.8.20
D OSD DaemonCtrl    Daemon reported profile change for sc1: /usr/share/scc/default_profiles/XBox Controller with High Precision Camera.sccprofile
D OSD DaemonCtrl    Daemon is ready.
I SCCDaemon     Registered scc-osd-daemon
I OSD osd.daemon    Sucessfully registered as scc-osd-daemon

Tested on a Plasma Wayland session (so kwin).
I might dig into this a bit deeper later.

[LynXDTS]

Just spun up a fresh Arch VM, as I do not remember all of the configuration on main system.

Installed Yay, got sc-controller-git from AUR, installed gtk-layer-shell explicitly after that and passed my controller through - still no OSD upon pressing the "Steam button", otherwise app is functional. Tried to just launch sc-controller from terminal - no relevant errors it seems, do not know how do debug deeper than that, sorry.

[C0rn3j]

kill sc-controller, kill scc-daemon, launch scc-daemon debug in one terminal and sc-controller in another.

I am also on Arch.
What compositor did you try?

I've fixed the git AUR package just now, forgot about it.

[LynXDTS]

Upon reboot magically fixed itself it seems, idk what could have been a problem.

Answering the question - KWin+Wayland as well.

[C0rn3j]

If you updated the package you might have pulled python-setuptools on top of it, it was missing in the -git package, but it should only have been a dependency for a fully functional About menu.

Glad it works now.
Leaving the issue open because the OSD is still partially broken on Wayland anyway.

[C0rn3j]

https://gitlab.gnome.org/GNOME/gnome-shell/-/issues/1141

https://gitlab.gnome.org/GNOME/mutter/-/issues/973

Apparently GNOME's mutter refuses to support Layer Shell, so it just won't work™ there I suppose, unless someone puts in the necessary work to figure out a solution.