diff --git a/ban-cooking.lua b/ban-cooking.lua
index 2c309a829..fdb59fbe0 100644
--- a/ban-cooking.lua
+++ b/ban-cooking.lua
@@ -137,30 +137,29 @@ funcs.seeds = function()
         if p.material_defs.type.seed == -1 or p.material_defs.idx.seed == -1 or p.flags.TREE then goto continue end
         ban_cooking(p.name .. ' seeds', p.material_defs.type.seed, p.material_defs.idx.seed, df.item_type.SEEDS, -1)
         for _, m in ipairs(p.material) do
-            if m.id == "STRUCTURAL" and m.flags.EDIBLE_COOKED then
-                local has_drink = false
-                local has_seed = false
-                for _, s in ipairs(m.reaction_product.id) do
-                    has_seed = has_seed or s.value == "SEED_MAT"
-                    has_drink = has_drink or s.value == "DRINK_MAT"
-                end
-                if has_seed and has_drink then
-                    local matinfo = dfhack.matinfo.find(p.id, m.id)
-                    ban_cooking(p.name .. ' ' .. m.id, matinfo.type, matinfo.index, df.item_type.PLANT, -1)
+            if m.id == "STRUCTURAL" then
+                if m.flags.EDIBLE_COOKED then
+                    local has_seed = false
+                    for _, s in ipairs(m.reaction_product.id) do
+                        has_seed = has_seed or s.value == "SEED_MAT"
+                    end
+                    if has_seed then
+                        local matinfo = dfhack.matinfo.find(p.id, m.id)
+                        ban_cooking(p.name .. ' ' .. m.id, matinfo.type, matinfo.index, df.item_type.PLANT, -1)
+                    end
                 end
+                break
             end
         end
         for k, g in ipairs(p.growths) do
             local matinfo = dfhack.matinfo.decode(g)
             local m = matinfo.material
             if m.flags.EDIBLE_COOKED then
-                local has_drink = false
                 local has_seed = false
                 for _, s in ipairs(m.reaction_product.id) do
                     has_seed = has_seed or s.value == "SEED_MAT"
-                    has_drink = has_drink or s.value == "DRINK_MAT"
                 end
-                if has_seed and has_drink then
+                if has_seed then
                     ban_cooking(p.name .. ' ' .. m.id, matinfo.type, matinfo.index, df.item_type.PLANT_GROWTH, k)
                 end
             end
@@ -174,14 +173,18 @@ funcs.brew = function()
     for _, p in ipairs(df.global.world.raws.plants.all) do
         if p.material_defs.type.drink == -1 or p.material_defs.idx.drink == -1 then goto continue end
         for _, m in ipairs(p.material) do
-            if m.id == "STRUCTURAL" and m.flags.EDIBLE_COOKED then
-                for _, s in ipairs(m.reaction_product.id) do
-                    if s.value == "DRINK_MAT" then
-                        local matinfo = dfhack.matinfo.find(p.id, m.id)
-                        ban_cooking(p.name .. ' ' .. m.id, matinfo.type, matinfo.index, df.item_type.PLANT, -1)
-                        break
+            if m.id == "STRUCTURAL" then
+                if m.flags.EDIBLE_COOKED then
+                    for _, s in ipairs(m.reaction_product.id) do
+                        if s.value == "DRINK_MAT" then
+                            local matinfo = dfhack.matinfo.find(p.id, m.id)
+                            ban_cooking(p.name .. ' ' .. m.id, matinfo.type, matinfo.index, df.item_type.PLANT, -1)
+                            break
+                        end
                     end
                 end
+                -- Stop iterating materials since there is only one STRUCTURAL
+                break
             end
         end
         for k, g in ipairs(p.growths) do
@@ -205,9 +208,12 @@ funcs.mill = function()
     for _, p in ipairs(df.global.world.raws.plants.all) do
         if p.material_defs.idx.mill ~= -1 then
             for _, m in ipairs(p.material) do
-                if m.id == "STRUCTURAL" and m.flags.EDIBLE_COOKED then
-                    local matinfo = dfhack.matinfo.find(p.id, m.id)
-                    ban_cooking(p.name .. ' ' .. m.id, matinfo.type, matinfo.index, df.item_type.PLANT, -1)
+                if m.id == "STRUCTURAL" then
+                    if m.flags.EDIBLE_COOKED then
+                        local matinfo = dfhack.matinfo.find(p.id, m.id)
+                        ban_cooking(p.name .. ' ' .. m.id, matinfo.type, matinfo.index, df.item_type.PLANT, -1)
+                    end
+                    break
                 end
             end
         end
@@ -218,14 +224,17 @@ funcs.thread = function()
     for _, p in ipairs(df.global.world.raws.plants.all) do
         if p.material_defs.idx.thread == -1 then goto continue end
         for _, m in ipairs(p.material) do
-            if m.id == "STRUCTURAL" and m.flags.EDIBLE_COOKED then
-                for _, s in ipairs(m.reaction_product.id) do
-                    if s.value == "THREAD" then
-                        local matinfo = dfhack.matinfo.find(p.id, m.id)
-                        ban_cooking(p.name .. ' ' .. m.id, matinfo.type, matinfo.index, df.item_type.PLANT, -1)
-                        break
+            if m.id == "STRUCTURAL" then
+                if m.flags.EDIBLE_COOKED then
+                    for _, s in ipairs(m.reaction_product.id) do
+                        if s.value == "THREAD" then
+                            local matinfo = dfhack.matinfo.find(p.id, m.id)
+                            ban_cooking(p.name .. ' ' .. m.id, matinfo.type, matinfo.index, df.item_type.PLANT, -1)
+                            break
+                        end
                     end
                 end
+                break
             end
         end
         for k, g in ipairs(p.growths) do
diff --git a/changelog.txt b/changelog.txt
index 69d0c2889..720297b06 100644
--- a/changelog.txt
+++ b/changelog.txt
@@ -94,6 +94,7 @@ Template for new versions:
 - `clear-smoke`: properly tag smoke flows for garbage collection to avoid memory leak
 - `warn-stranded`: don't warn for babies carried by mothers who happen to be gathering fruit from trees
 - `prioritize`: also boost priority of already-claimed jobs when boosting priority of a job type so those jobs are not interrupted
+- `ban-cooking`: ban all seed producing items from being cooked when 'seeds' is chosen instead of just brewable seed producing items
 
 ## Misc Improvements
 - `item`: option for ignoring uncollected spider webs when you search for "silk"
diff --git a/docs/ban-cooking.rst b/docs/ban-cooking.rst
index 0c53799b9..38d2ba2b1 100644
--- a/docs/ban-cooking.rst
+++ b/docs/ban-cooking.rst
@@ -45,7 +45,7 @@ Valid types are:
 - ``milk``
 - ``mill`` (millable plants)
 - ``oil``
-- ``seeds`` (plantable seeds)
+- ``seeds`` (plantable seeds and items producing seeds)
 - ``tallow``
 - ``thread``