Issues with ABO validation tests for1.1_Rev1.5-DRAFT

[d0rg0ld]

Here I collect issues I encounter while working with ABO mappings and the validator 1.1_Rev1.5-DRAFT

1. foaf:Organization not allowed as dc:subject --> plz fix
   [ERROR] INVALID_OBJECT_PROPERTY_RANGE http://data.dm2e.eu/data/agent/onb/authority_gnd/4029989-2

2. foaf:Person not allowed as dc:subject --> plz fix
   [ERROR] INVALID_OBJECT_PROPERTY_RANGE http://data.dm2e.eu/data/agent/onb/authority_gnd/118838989

3. bibo:Series not allowed as dc:type --> FATAL, plz fix
   [FATAL] INVALID_DC_TYPE http://purl.org/ontology/bibo/Series

4. edm:Place as dc:subject throws error, plz fix
   [ERROR] INVALID_OBJECT_PROPERTY_RANGE http://data.dm2e.eu/data/place/onb/authority_gnd/4074987-3

----> In the meantime I suspect that the ranges for dc:subject are generally flawed -> OWL file?

[kba]

The ranges of dc:subject are not flawed per se, they are a fixed list derived from the DM2E Model Specifications document. The OWL file is not complete, plus keeping a list of the subclasses actually allowed in the model is faster than doing even simple reasoning. We can do that at a later stage. For now I just add them by hand. There aren't that many anyway:

• edm:Agent
  • foaf:Person
  • foaf:Organization
    • dm2e:Archive
    • vivo:Library
    • vivo:Museum
    • vivo:University
• skos:Concept
  • dm2e:Work
  • fabio:Article
  • fabio:Chapter
  • dm2e:Paragraph
  • dm2e:Publication
  • bibo:Series
• edm:TimeSpan
• edm:Place

Am I missing something?

3. That shouldn't happen, please make sure you are using the the most recent version. To make it easier to spot, I've added a build date in the most recent version. Running the tool without any arguments should print out the time when it was last built on data.dm2e.eu.

[kba]

@d0rg0ld Please check this when ABO validation is finished and close if it's fixed.

[d0rg0ld]

On Basis of Validator Build Date: Tue Mar 4 18:12:13 CET 2014 / model version 1.1_Rev1.5

ERRORS not fixed :

<dc:subject rdf:resource="http://data.dm2e.eu/data/place/onb/authority_gnd/4043271-3"/>
throws [ERROR] INVALID_OBJECT_PROPERTY_RANGE http://data.dm2e.eu/data/place/onb/authority_gnd/4043271-3

[ERROR] NON_REPEATABLE http://onto.dm2e.eu/schemas/dm2e/publishedAt

[ERROR] SHOULD_BE_RESOURCE http://onto.dm2e.eu/schemas/dm2e/shelfmarkLocation

@edroege
--------- Missing in OWL file --------------

fabio:hasSequenceIdentifier

used in :

xml
<skos:Concept rdf:about="http://data.dm2e.eu/data/concept/onb/authority_gnd/4487110-7">
      <owl:sameAs>http://d-nb.info/gnd/4487110-7</owl:sameAs>
      <skos:prefLabel>Sermones</skos:prefLabel>
      <fabio:hasSequenceIdentifier>I.</fabio:hasSequenceIdentifier>
      <dc:creator rdf:resource="http://data.dm2e.eu/data/agent/onb/authority_gnd/Leo_I._Papst_-461"/>
   </skos:Concept>

fabio:hasSubtitle

used in:

xml
   <skos:Concept rdf:about="http://data.dm2e.eu/data/concept/onb/authority_gnd/4075942-8">
      <owl:sameAs>http://d-nb.info/gnd/4075942-8</owl:sameAs>
      <skos:prefLabel>Timotheusbrief</skos:prefLabel>
      <fabio:hasSubtitle>I. II.</fabio:hasSubtitle>
      <dc:creator rdf:resource="http://data.dm2e.eu/data/agent/onb/authority_gnd/Paulus_Apostel_ca._1._Jh."/>
   </skos:Concept>

[kba]

<dc:subject rdf:resource="http://data.dm2e.eu/data/place/onb/authority_gnd/4043271-3"/>
throws [ERROR] INVALID_OBJECT_PROPERTY_RANGE http://data.dm2e.eu/data/place/onb/authority_gnd/4043271-3

What type is http://data.dm2e.eu/data/place/onb/authority_gnd/4043271-3? Obviously I missed an allowed object range but to correct it, I must know which rdf:type this has.

[ERROR] NON_REPEATABLE http://onto.dm2e.eu/schemas/dm2e/publishedAt

This is correct behavior for 1.1_Rev1.5. Fixed in 1.1_Rev1.6.

[ERROR] SHOULD_BE_RESOURCE http://onto.dm2e.eu/schemas/dm2e/shelfmarkLocation

According to 1.1_Rev1.5, the range is edm:Place. Will be changed in 1.1_Rev1.6 according to #57 .

[d0rg0ld]

http://data.dm2e.eu/data/ ----> place <---- /onb/authority_gnd/4043271-3 :-)

[d0rg0ld]

thx!

[kba]

Yes, but is it actually an edm:Place?

[d0rg0ld]

yes, a sometimes even nice place :-)

   <edm:Place rdf:about="http://data.dm2e.eu/data/place/onb/authority_gnd/4043271-3">
      <owl:sameAs rdf:resource="http://d-nb.info/gnd/4043271-3"/>
      <skos:prefLabel>Österreich</skos:prefLabel>
   </edm:Place>

[kba]

Some beg to differ ;-)

Anyway, there was indeed a bug about edm:Place, I just fixed it and rebuilt the tool. Please re-download, fixed as of build 'Wed Mar 5 11:00:09 CET 2014'

[kba]

Since 1.1_Rev1.5 seems pretty stable now and the issues here are fixed, I'll close this. Please open a new issue for any new problems you might encounter.

[kba]

fabio:has* still missing