You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
Description of the error
When running CenterOfMassesTrajectory analysis on a DFTB water trajectory (from MDANSE-Examples), the resulting trajectory contains only hydrogen atoms.
Describe the expected result
I would expect the following results:
If grouping="atom", the output trajectory should be identical to the input,
If grouping="molecule", the output trajectory should contain one object per molecule. I would expect it to be an artificial atom with the same mass at the mass of the original molecule.
Describe the actual result
Instead, I got the following:
With grouping="atom", from 200 H and 100 O atoms on input I got 300 H atoms in the output.
With grouping="molecule" I got 100 H atoms. The number of H atoms is the same as the number of water molecules.
The figure compares the mass density of original water, molecule-grouped COM water and atom-grouped COM water.
Suggested fix
Trajectory should have its own built-in atom database containing only the elements present in the system. This will make trajectories fully transferable and enable replacing molecules will artificial atoms that will conserve the mass of the system.
Additional details
Even though it is possible to do statistics on molecule positions using the current implementation of COM trajectory, it will also become impossible to distinguish different molecules if they all get replaced with hydrogen.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
Description of the error
When running CenterOfMassesTrajectory analysis on a DFTB water trajectory (from MDANSE-Examples), the resulting trajectory contains only hydrogen atoms.
Describe the expected result
I would expect the following results:
Describe the actual result
Instead, I got the following:
The figure compares the mass density of original water, molecule-grouped COM water and atom-grouped COM water.
Suggested fix
Trajectory should have its own built-in atom database containing only the elements present in the system. This will make trajectories fully transferable and enable replacing molecules will artificial atoms that will conserve the mass of the system.
Additional details
Even though it is possible to do statistics on molecule positions using the current implementation of COM trajectory, it will also become impossible to distinguish different molecules if they all get replaced with hydrogen.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: