Zaps using ligess not working

[mutatrum]

When trying to add the NWC string from my ligess instance, it is not accepted and [invalid NWC URI] is logged.

The format is:

nostrwalletconnect://9d0cfc1006bf7b712cbb9ccc730000cdf3b1fcf622a541fadf7a432a1609b73b?relay=wss://relay.hodl.camp&secret=######

This URL works in Amethyst, but it's not clear why it's not accepter by nostter.

[SnowCait]

NWC protocol is nostr+walletconnect://, not nostrwalletconnect://.

[mutatrum]

Fixed the URL, which is now accepted by nostter. However, if I zap a note, nothing is coming in to my zapper relay.

After this the logging stops. I tried zapping the same note on Amethyst, and I see the invoice being sent to the zapper relay to be paid.

I renamed the issue to track general compatibility issues.

Awesome client btw to be able to handle 2500 follows.

[SnowCait]

wss://relay.hodl.camp seems to refuse the connection due to AUTH.
Is this behavior intended?

[mutatrum]

[edit] changed a bit, had to re-read stuff as I implemented it ages ago.

Yes, that is intended, as it's a relay only used for zaps so it want to AUTH the user. I can disable it to test it, but I think it's prudent to have the relay shielded off a bit more.

It used to be mentioned in NIP-57 IIRC, but in the current version of the NIP it's not mentioned anymore, not sure why?

[SnowCait]

Okay, I'll support AUTH on NWC.

[SnowCait]

Done. Could you please check?

[mutatrum]

I've added logging on my side, it looks like it connects to the relay and sends the encrypted invoice but no NIP-42 AUTH response yet. I cleared my browser cache to make sure I have the latest version.

Sep 04 10:29:57 hostname ligess[719002]: {"level":30,"time":1725438597077,"pid":719002,"hostname":"hostname","reqId":"req-2","req":{"method":"GET","url":"/relay/","hostname":"relay.hodl.camp","remoteAddress":"127.0.0.1","remotePort":39516},"msg":"incoming request"}
Sep 04 10:29:57 hostname ligess[719002]: {"level":30,"time":1725438597078,"pid":719002,"hostname":"hostname","reqId":"req-2","msg":"Sending AUTH request"}
Sep 04 10:29:57 hostname ligess[719002]: {"level":30,"time":1725438597086,"pid":719002,"hostname":"hostname","reqId":"req-2","msg":"Message received","message":["EVENT",{"kind":23194,"created_at":1725438597,"content":"L19DkAAZ7RP8Pg9Whs7zwfC8V9c30Rr28mU9JRXrwkxShZs1WDswepavJwPgyPPTmcgMWQ0p5Q3yrY7qe5oihnoz5NAj2m6k1LEzs4g9xMT7xYKw1cQ+6mQ10FOLHQ8jpgRpzc32f/PwFm/hCr+pG7N26YNKyPiBbMcK+Ka7P/gRxEKkXr5AwmReCCwbsFAaXy3NMesC3dfeRIeYXOClACzko/PCj3tB7lMMVmVIdUwh+nqVduW3rgwrQeMOBWP30u4uVGgyBogPccxzmuNRBUjjUL+tqCL8DC5nKPZdfnsem9HzY2eypISpyp1QeMweih/NJ4bWmoL3tTZKsaO6ABMvB4DwhMzsGHzIvC0Kk3KvOlBo8SAf/WrTS45vjp//1eSgaLkDlJGJilYQ4AIW3NR64fvs/xVkpDgvE9LuAcTD+M5P2naibYDL84zB20pNZ+MfKDo4pcLjo4JfSaFdpdHp9hE4PsjJGXrezn3nRso=?iv=HRQ2or0Jnb4y7reSRJmH+Q==","tags":[["p","9d0cfc1006bf7b712cbb9ccc730000cdf3b1fcf622a541fadf7a432a1609b73b"]],"pubkey":"9d0cfc1006bf7b712cbb9ccc730000cdf3b1fcf622a541fadf7a432a1609b73b","id":"f00fced49d096c268f6ad8b53be036d4c1746755bacd9289de7852932f11a141","sig":"c4d4056512beec0ef23d30607c2bde51d33f23841d71a2d6eda9cb7de118e659421ae3d422cecba67d769a17010ec75dbfce4b35ca5209f6927a30385803d8ac"}]}
Sep 04 10:29:57 hostname ligess[719002]: {"level":30,"time":1725438597086,"pid":719002,"hostname":"hostname","reqId":"req-2","msg":"Message received","message":["REQ","696756:0",{"kinds":[23195],"authors":["9d0cfc1006bf7b712cbb9ccc730000cdf3b1fcf622a541fadf7a432a1609b73b"],"#e":["f00fced49d096c268f6ad8b53be036d4c1746755bacd9289de7852932f11a141"]}]}
Sep 04 10:30:07 hostname ligess[719002]: {"level":30,"time":1725438607080,"pid":719002,"hostname":"hostname","reqId":"req-2","msg":"Closing idle connection"}
Sep 04 10:30:07 hostname ligess[719002]: {"level":30,"time":1725438607087,"pid":719002,"hostname":"hostname","reqId":"req-2","msg":"Connection closed","code":1005,"reason":{"type":"Buffer","data":[]}}

It holds off on processing the invoice until the AUTH response is received, and the connection is closed after 10 seconds if this doesn't happen.

[SnowCait]

Hmm... I'll check it out.

[SnowCait]

Sorry, I had the wrong option, could you please check again?

[mutatrum]

It works 🥇 Only thing is that the zap dialog stays open. On refresh the zap is shown on the notifications of the note.

Sep 04 13:28:07 hostname ligess[719002]: {"level":30,"time":1725449287657,"pid":719002,"hostname":"hostname","reqId":"req-22","req":{"method":"GET","url":"/relay/","hostname":"relay.hodl.camp","remoteAddress":"127.0.0.1","remotePort":34628},"msg":"incoming request"}
Sep 04 13:28:07 hostname ligess[719002]: {"level":30,"time":1725449287658,"pid":719002,"hostname":"hostname","reqId":"req-22","msg":"Sending AUTH request"}
Sep 04 13:28:07 hostname ligess[719002]: {"level":30,"time":1725449287665,"pid":719002,"hostname":"hostname","reqId":"req-22","msg":"Message received","message":["EVENT",{"kind":23194,"created_at":1725449288,"content":"047sZ0dvhq2NHaeV/Itnclyo5L/EtXbXULNY4uQY1jBS+kwNcTp9Ip9W/l9P/OH0ZcGbdR9Djiwe2fmpnAfPQM/6GG7+2Mf/0LD6imn9hl5laNc+tNGv4FtzKw+oloDvtI2oGygl/Neyq/u2ywvfnm9pEk/5Gj4P+GDs5+WTa9awpKn322Wmq1tZWCRUa2RZlmbKITC4S+dx1rYuYl3MuBoiN9qCjHGXnXMBxU9jKVE2AIWKgYXiaEaVBE9dOOBM8QGHG0y/l6Vs2T0YSNBfRq//JVpbUz6rqvo+AgoJfPxISvH6PHWKeBG5mqgZsz7FmLeW+6crIExz56hNpG2eDzSkk0IAC9dEyIisLre5VrgRO51CHN/67yEJUWFtL6IGadiKPavNzpnGockkQ3UmikKSDRwhKGfWOh40fPoGWhs6gDRcV9MRTF4kuTGny2H4LlPuNK8gFbHmy7biouH7Tjygyp029aqfyi+c0wsJdyM=?iv=Z3GQmOu1gDDEq+p7z//2lw==","tags":[["p","9d0cfc1006bf7b712cbb9ccc730000cdf3b1fcf622a541fadf7a432a1609b73b"]],"pubkey":"9d0cfc1006bf7b712cbb9ccc730000cdf3b1fcf622a541fadf7a432a1609b73b","id":"cb2cf7ce1a55aab8ff88168e805c6807443b2d9598a66c73c2cebf0a773efe9d","sig":"fdfedbee88f4e069fbf2a64c0da644d8533bb8c97c71a1b7e532aba9fc133cd21b20a16b749be5fadefededa3fac63737a338f92f76a8b9bcc37d81937649c50"}]}
Sep 04 13:28:07 hostname ligess[719002]: {"level":30,"time":1725449287665,"pid":719002,"hostname":"hostname","reqId":"req-22","msg":"Message received","message":["REQ","726754:0",{"kinds":[23195],"authors":["9d0cfc1006bf7b712cbb9ccc730000cdf3b1fcf622a541fadf7a432a1609b73b"],"#e":["cb2cf7ce1a55aab8ff88168e805c6807443b2d9598a66c73c2cebf0a773efe9d"]}]}
Sep 04 13:28:07 hostname ligess[719002]: {"level":30,"time":1725449287673,"pid":719002,"hostname":"hostname","reqId":"req-22","msg":"Message received","message":["AUTH",{"kind":22242,"content":"","tags":[["relay","wss://relay.hodl.camp"],["challenge","54c8b141290c97c8a5bdfc9d2849be49c52aa80f"]],"pubkey":"9d0cfc1006bf7b712cbb9ccc730000cdf3b1fcf622a541fadf7a432a1609b73b","created_at":1725449287,"id":"673261045313b5af7d136d84a4a8975e249ccb6594394f0366cc8ac24a9700d9","sig":"d7d88fdbc922d1b1fb2b0f88e4b59ace042b3c4122e083bb1b57e1bde4c7b3b4b9efd13566faf41a82191a7f0729070ccdc9f69c7db613135e4d301f875b6f0d"}]}
Sep 04 13:28:07 hostname ligess[719002]: {"level":30,"time":1725449287682,"pid":719002,"hostname":"hostname","reqId":"req-22","msg":"Connection is authenticated: npub1n5x0cyqxhaahzt9mnnx8xqqqehemrl8ky2j5r7kl0fpj59sfkuasxasqwz"}
Sep 04 13:28:07 hostname ligess[719002]: {"level":30,"time":1725449287689,"pid":719002,"hostname":"hostname","reqId":"req-22","msg":"Pay request","content":{"method":"pay_invoice","params":{"invoice":"lnbc50u1pnds3z8pp5t9xvnl3xqkggppj387kpal3jz9nen2h9qddl97lxchpffmwp9j0qhp5ytplu4c9grgl7qm29l94wvnywtun699harm6guxz5nry9nrdhmkscqzzsxqyz5vqsp57al6lud94sxvrkmc7xwe5z8dqekexqaajtqk8xlxk7x9ltq6e05s9qxpqysgq8803ahlp4xe76wet8xdqpxcmf3grw70jk5wcktnvn79jnq7cksmhgv7y7kewcgs4tcuy0y7uayy6r97m6yf8cadx6487jvegy8a9zscpyg9nl0"}}}
Sep 04 13:28:07 hostname ligess[719002]: {"level":30,"time":1725449287693,"pid":719002,"hostname":"hostname","reqId":"req-22","msg":"Invoice","invoice":{"complete":true,"millisatoshis":"5000000","network":{"bech32":"bc","pubKeyHash":0,"scriptHash":5,"validWitnessVersions":[0,1]},"payeeNodeKey":"035e4ff418fc8b5554c5d9eea66396c227bd429a3251c8cbc711002ba215bfc226","paymentRequest":"lnbc50u1pnds3z8pp5t9xvnl3xqkggppj387kpal3jz9nen2h9qddl97lxchpffmwp9j0qhp5ytplu4c9grgl7qm29l94wvnywtun699harm6guxz5nry9nrdhmkscqzzsxqyz5vqsp57al6lud94sxvrkmc7xwe5z8dqekexqaajtqk8xlxk7x9ltq6e05s9qxpqysgq8803ahlp4xe76wet8xdqpxcmf3grw70jk5wcktnvn79jnq7cksmhgv7y7kewcgs4tcuy0y7uayy6r97m6yf8cadx6487jvegy8a9zscpyg9nl0","prefix":"lnbc50u","recoveryFlag":1,"satoshis":5000,"signature":"39df1edfe1a9b3ed3b2b399a009b1b4c503779f2b51d8b2e6c9f8b2983d8b4377433c4f5b2ec22155e384793dce909a197dbd1127c75a6d54fe9332821fa5143","tags":[{"tagName":"payment_hash","data":"594cc9fe2605908086513fac1efe32116799aae5035bf2fbe6c5c294edc12c9e"},{"tagName":"purpose_commit_hash","data":"22c3fe570540d1ff036a2fcb57326472f93d14b7e8f7a470c2a4c642cc6dbeed"},{"tagName":"min_final_cltv_expiry","data":80},{"tagName":"expire_time","data":86400},{"tagName":"payment_secret","data":"f77faff1a5ac0cc1db78f19d9a08ed066d9303bd92c1639be6b78c5fac1acbe9"},{"tagName":"feature_bits","data":{"word_length":6,"option_data_loss_protect":{"required":false,"supported":false},"initial_routing_sync":{"required":false,"supported":false},"option_upfront_shutdown_script":{"required":false,"supported":false},"gossip_queries":{"required":false,"supported":false},"var_onion_optin":{"required":true,"supported":false},"gossip_queries_ex":{"required":false,"supported":false},"option_static_remotekey":{"required":false,"supported":false},"payment_secret":{"required":true,"supported":false},"basic_mpp":{"required":false,"supported":true},"option_support_large_channel":{"required":false,"supported":false},"extra_bits":{"start_bit":20,"bits":[false,false,false,false,false,true,false,false,false,false],"has_required":false}}}],"timeExpireDate":1725535687,"timeExpireDateString":"2024-09-05T11:28:07.000Z","timestamp":1725449287,"timestampString":"2024-09-04T11:28:07.000Z","wordsTemp":"temp1pnds3z8pp5t9xvnl3xqkggppj387kpal3jz9nen2h9qddl97lxchpffmwp9j0qhp5ytplu4c9grgl7qm29l94wvnywtun699harm6guxz5nry9nrdhmkscqzzsxqyz5vqsp57al6lud94sxvrkmc7xwe5z8dqekexqaajtqk8xlxk7x9ltq6e05s9qxpqysgq8803ahlp4xe76wet8xdqpxcmf3grw70jk5wcktnvn79jnq7cksmhgv7y7kewcgs4tcuy0y7uayy6r97m6yf8cadx6487jvegy8a9zscpsajy9h"}}
Sep 04 13:28:07 hostname ligess[719002]: {"level":30,"time":1725449287693,"pid":719002,"hostname":"hostname","reqId":"req-22","msg":"Total","hour":0,"day":21}
Sep 04 13:28:08 hostname ligess[719002]: {"level":30,"time":1725449288115,"pid":719002,"hostname":"hostname","reqId":"req-22","msg":"Invoice paid","result":{"paymentPreimage":"40231a49b60e310e6f5bff6b890ab5978e406937e578cff76806f8c4d5bb6dfc","feesAmount":"2","feesAmountMsats":"2830"}}
Sep 04 13:29:07 hostname ligess[719002]: {"level":30,"time":1725449347657,"pid":719002,"hostname":"hostname","reqId":"req-22","msg":"Connection closed","code":1006,"reason":{"type":"Buffer","data":[]}}

The last log in the console is [zap invoice], not sure if there should be anything after that.

[SnowCait]

The Zap dialog is closed when kind 23195 EVENT comes back from the relay.
I'm not sure why it cannot be received, I will check the code.

If received:

nostter/web/src/lib/Zap.ts

Lines 34 to 35 in 89eb1be

	console.log('[NWC success]', packet);
	resolve(packet.event);

[mutatrum]

Thank you for the investigation. I added some extra logging on my end and noticed the 23195 event wasn't actually sent back. I fixed that, but it still doesn't seem to arrive, I don't see a [NWC success] log in the console.

Logging from my end shows the event is now being sent, but I have to look into it to see if it's actually correct. It was missing a created_at field but adding that doesn't seem to fix it.

Sep 05 10:57:17 hostname ligess[811189]: {"level":30,"time":1725526637062,"pid":811189,"hostname":"hostname","reqId":"req-1","req":{"method":"GET","url":"/relay/","hostname":"relay.hodl.camp","remoteAddress":"127.0.0.1","remotePort":39310},"msg":"incoming request"}
Sep 05 10:57:17 hostname ligess[811189]: {"level":30,"time":1725526637065,"pid":811189,"hostname":"hostname","reqId":"req-1","msg":"Message sent","message":["AUTH","b6463d20d3b754261f99a6520412aff876d1b48d"]}
Sep 05 10:57:17 hostname ligess[811189]: {"level":30,"time":1725526637071,"pid":811189,"hostname":"hostname","reqId":"req-1","msg":"Message received","message":["EVENT",{"kind":23194,"created_at":1725526637,"content":"yAt8AhGjFoi3m9rL2EqWKGFXxsM94ILXWQ5pDTDXXUqgmajEF3YkaC/eUGZH9V+BqLo3FiD4BAYFNkNZ2W1/sjR5sgFOUgJQXotlmR2vbDAZJGjHAFLYwancjPTNyMkwgsmIyOYWoeNP5UoJrDoqPeE8X/ZgwW/O2YTfOos8PTLe5L6tGPM4ElNIoQLGP1QA2DuFccXsjkO6UrNBV20tnWIprtSU0CxqRr0HMc9+yNu+cJflLpTJJlm6X/ZdQRhupWd5g9qm8zhMLhh99VE1B+uXt+pE3ROauPFHeB2IY44K9DWfNJkH3w+/B0P3ODqZAFX8/lFhCJVbe0yavVgAnFJYV0+T4Xq0Kfje92ASFresJtXho29oSy8AGg0kcLiT0HoHQ1yxL+pEoa00PR+k3YA6azZqK1DbsbEYf2DlO2xLvOD0qzT4AkBsGxwmtlBM1lFgWVRT6DD1uqT7rjRFxQzCAdqxQqEervvRKvO8rjU=?iv=1bUUXjRd21tfYG4ks5oMFg==","tags":[["p","9d0cfc1006bf7b712cbb9ccc730000cdf3b1fcf622a541fadf7a432a1609b73b"]],"pubkey":"9d0cfc1006bf7b712cbb9ccc730000cdf3b1fcf622a541fadf7a432a1609b73b","id":"9c30f03438d8592917d8696d37072ecdcd1e4d939ff123cce00d92cfb93f6684","sig":"cd3f616f161028ea3ad1fb425f315c048caa416778717e12e0e49cd3c2c1553f1b0b837b6d0e7bd4e4469bc925022614f07bb99afbc1fc0c8d48bc0ec4cf8da7"}]}
Sep 05 10:57:17 hostname ligess[811189]: {"level":30,"time":1725526637081,"pid":811189,"hostname":"hostname","reqId":"req-1","msg":"Message received","message":["AUTH",{"kind":22242,"content":"","tags":[["relay","wss://relay.hodl.camp"],["challenge","b6463d20d3b754261f99a6520412aff876d1b48d"]],"pubkey":"9d0cfc1006bf7b712cbb9ccc730000cdf3b1fcf622a541fadf7a432a1609b73b","created_at":1725526637,"id":"c0dfebf0e059438c6f300192e23922b5360bcdf29a70a0437476ee9cf5ec44d5","sig":"37556af415bf878c281f11fce7c301d65fabd11d7cb4611eea9f9d63d92ec81878bb0843e1d6eb5b1d89d09001b3095f0903ec97489bd54adfa198a574c59607"}]}
Sep 05 10:57:17 hostname ligess[811189]: {"level":30,"time":1725526637081,"pid":811189,"hostname":"hostname","reqId":"req-1","msg":"Message received","message":["REQ","659575:0",{"kinds":[23195],"authors":["9d0cfc1006bf7b712cbb9ccc730000cdf3b1fcf622a541fadf7a432a1609b73b"],"#e":["9c30f03438d8592917d8696d37072ecdcd1e4d939ff123cce00d92cfb93f6684"]}]}
Sep 05 10:57:17 hostname ligess[811189]: {"level":30,"time":1725526637081,"pid":811189,"hostname":"hostname","reqId":"req-1","msg":"Message sent","message":["EOSE","659575:0"]}
Sep 05 10:57:17 hostname ligess[811189]: {"level":30,"time":1725526637091,"pid":811189,"hostname":"hostname","reqId":"req-1","msg":"Connection is authenticated: npub1n5x0cyqxhaahzt9mnnx8xqqqehemrl8ky2j5r7kl0fpj59sfkuasxasqwz"}
Sep 05 10:57:17 hostname ligess[811189]: {"level":30,"time":1725526637099,"pid":811189,"hostname":"hostname","reqId":"req-1","msg":"Pay request","content":{"method":"pay_invoice","params":{"invoice":"lnbc210n1pndjunvpp52gy42m2xhuvrh52p2rq8jp36dm0hwedza6phkgd4vnntmlht66kqhp5zw06edggkks0l9lvkn4lksaw68nv4ww743cm3a2x5pmlh2xxq8mqcqzzsxqyz5vqsp5peudds3wenh8jrqpnym29eys5fdscpyl6ga358tkvyfccrgk88vq9qxpqysgqj4p2krjj8hjvm745ckc72z5w0dpjxxeexghnjfj65taq2w0p0kjzzxk2deh87qqgfvv6xtm325uw2nuv94yd84ms9j9fvaegckvpqjqpawu0pq"}}}
Sep 05 10:57:17 hostname ligess[811189]: {"level":30,"time":1725526637103,"pid":811189,"hostname":"hostname","reqId":"req-1","msg":"Invoice","invoice":{"complete":true,"millisatoshis":"21000","network":{"bech32":"bc","pubKeyHash":0,"scriptHash":5,"validWitnessVersions":[0,1]},"payeeNodeKey":"035e4ff418fc8b5554c5d9eea66396c227bd429a3251c8cbc711002ba215bfc226","paymentRequest":"lnbc210n1pndjunvpp52gy42m2xhuvrh52p2rq8jp36dm0hwedza6phkgd4vnntmlht66kqhp5zw06edggkks0l9lvkn4lksaw68nv4ww743cm3a2x5pmlh2xxq8mqcqzzsxqyz5vqsp5peudds3wenh8jrqpnym29eys5fdscpyl6ga358tkvyfccrgk88vq9qxpqysgqj4p2krjj8hjvm745ckc72z5w0dpjxxeexghnjfj65taq2w0p0kjzzxk2deh87qqgfvv6xtm325uw2nuv94yd84ms9j9fvaegckvpqjqpawu0pq","prefix":"lnbc210n","recoveryFlag":1,"satoshis":21,"signature":"9542ab0e523de4cdfab4c5b1e50a8e7b43231b39322f39265aa2fa0539e17da4211aca6e6e7f00084b19a32f715538e54f8c2d48d3d7702c8a967728c5981048","tags":[{"tagName":"payment_hash","data":"5209556d46bf183bd14150c079063a6edf7765a2ee837b21b564e6bdfeebd6ac"},{"tagName":"purpose_commit_hash","data":"139facb508b5a0ff97ecb4ebfb43aed1e6cab9deac71b8f546a077fba8c601f6"},{"tagName":"min_final_cltv_expiry","data":80},{"tagName":"expire_time","data":86400},{"tagName":"payment_secret","data":"0e78d6c22eccee790c019936a2e490a25b0c049fd23b1a1d7661138c0d1639d8"},{"tagName":"feature_bits","data":{"word_length":6,"option_data_loss_protect":{"required":false,"supported":false},"initial_routing_sync":{"required":false,"supported":false},"option_upfront_shutdown_script":{"required":false,"supported":false},"gossip_queries":{"required":false,"supported":false},"var_onion_optin":{"required":true,"supported":false},"gossip_queries_ex":{"required":false,"supported":false},"option_static_remotekey":{"required":false,"supported":false},"payment_secret":{"required":true,"supported":false},"basic_mpp":{"required":false,"supported":true},"option_support_large_channel":{"required":false,"supported":false},"extra_bits":{"start_bit":20,"bits":[false,false,false,false,false,true,false,false,false,false],"has_required":false}}}],"timeExpireDate":1725613036,"timeExpireDateString":"2024-09-06T08:57:16.000Z","timestamp":1725526636,"timestampString":"2024-09-05T08:57:16.000Z","wordsTemp":"temp1pndjunvpp52gy42m2xhuvrh52p2rq8jp36dm0hwedza6phkgd4vnntmlht66kqhp5zw06edggkks0l9lvkn4lksaw68nv4ww743cm3a2x5pmlh2xxq8mqcqzzsxqyz5vqsp5peudds3wenh8jrqpnym29eys5fdscpyl6ga358tkvyfccrgk88vq9qxpqysgqj4p2krjj8hjvm745ckc72z5w0dpjxxeexghnjfj65taq2w0p0kjzzxk2deh87qqgfvv6xtm325uw2nuv94yd84ms9j9fvaegckvpqjqpmjmzm2"}}
Sep 05 10:57:17 hostname ligess[811189]: {"level":30,"time":1725526637103,"pid":811189,"hostname":"hostname","reqId":"req-1","msg":"Total","hour":105,"day":15126}
Sep 05 10:57:17 hostname ligess[811189]: {"level":30,"time":1725526637425,"pid":811189,"hostname":"hostname","reqId":"req-1","msg":"Invoice paid","result":{"paymentPreimage":"7e03219ae0941d2d879e390123a1599705a551d4568732bbfd6c64293ea4d6e2","feesAmount":"0","feesAmountMsats":"0"}}
Sep 05 10:57:17 hostname ligess[811189]: {"level":30,"time":1725526637435,"pid":811189,"hostname":"hostname","reqId":"req-1","msg":"Message sent","message":["EVENT",{"kind":23195,"pubkey":"9d0cfc1006bf7b712cbb9ccc730000cdf3b1fcf622a541fadf7a432a1609b73b","created_at":1725526637,"tags":[["e","9c30f03438d8592917d8696d37072ecdcd1e4d939ff123cce00d92cfb93f6684"]],"content":"7e03219ae0941d2d879e390123a1599705a551d4568732bbfd6c64293ea4d6e2","id":"253f3f51f4fdd3bae7768677c6ce5ca5c79738bb40ca51322dc0291bb6177c2c","sig":"05276b3be9f12b412e825dfa7eaa4e4414a6f36fcf96df0369bb66785baf36ff13f29cebf83c5febce4e45ff1df2b00c1486b9cc82db7d180b0aaa761e06d29f"}]}

What I noticed when testing a zap with Amethyst is that it also doesn't seem to close the zap process, I guess it's also waiting for this event. So the remaining issue is probably on my end.

[SnowCait]

Thanks. The message seems not to contain subscription id 659575:0.

[mutatrum]

Just saw that, added that. Getting closer:

Task failed succesfully? 😆

I'll check the event more, I think it should be encrypted and I'm not sure that's done.

[mutatrum]

Ah, this is all new stuff, added to NIP-47 after I wrote ligess. I guess Amethyst doesn't care or has fallback mechanism to the old style, but nostter is way more strict, which is good.

I think this issue can be closed now, I hope you don't mind if I continue zapping you for testing 😆 Thank you for your patience and once again thanks for your work on this awesome client!

[mutatrum]

One more comment: I think I fixed the response. If I zap a note, it closes the dialog so that's good.

It looks like it's decoded properly, with the correct result object containing the preimage. 👍

The only thing that I don't see is that the zap notification is shown under the note (in thread view). It does shows up after a page reload.

[SnowCait]

Congratulations🎉
I will think about how it will be shown after the Zap. (Failure UI too. #1223)