Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Feminizidmap by Paula Hierzi #4

Closed
rjeantet opened this issue Dec 20, 2023 · 7 comments
Closed

Feminizidmap by Paula Hierzi #4

rjeantet opened this issue Dec 20, 2023 · 7 comments
Assignees

Comments

@rjeantet
Copy link
Collaborator

What is your project's name?

Feminizidmap

What's the problem you are trying to solve?

So I want to support this Kollektiv in Analyzing their collected Data. But I don't have a go from them jet. And I am unsure how many people they need and from which tracks.

What is your idea for a solution to the given "problem"?

Ordering and sorting their data so it is easily callable (Panda?). Analyzing with the help of Matplotlip and making data visible. Helping them make it clear and easily accessible (UX Design) on their website(WebDev)

Which tracks do you think could be involved?

DL/DS, WD, UX

How do you imagine Deep Learning and/or Data Science could contribute to this project?

DataScience I can imagine. I am in the Data Science track and they need a Data Scientist not clear how many.

How do you imagine User Experience Design could contribute to this project?

Make the Data easily readable. On the website but also on presentations ...

How do you imagine Web Development could contribute to this project?

Update the website with all the information

What are the most important challenges & bottlenecks of your project?

Not sure yet

What are the most important success factors of your project?

Being able to use the data to make things visible

Share your resources here:

current website of the Kollektiv: https://feminizidmap.org/

Do you have any other remarks?

I would submit a presentation once I have a clear go of how many people they need and what their main needs are

@valiantone valiantone added the proposal A new idea/proposal has been made and is being reviewed label Dec 20, 2023
@rjeantet
Copy link
Collaborator Author

rjeantet commented Dec 22, 2023

Hi Paula @Rustingheart , happy to review and help you get going with this idea!

First, a personal opinion:

The goal of this project in particular is truly meaningful and vocational which in itself is already beautiful, but if/when it goes through to completion, having on their portfolio a live project being used by a non-profit is a strong advantage for all of the team members.

Now, here are a few pointers to clarify before your idea can be moved forward to scoping status:

1 - About the dataset:

The feasibility of this project is extremely dependent on whether the collective would share their data or not. Since you are in DS already, we suggest you to:

  • Search for alternative dataset to make sure the project can happen whether the collective shares their data or not.

2 - project ownership

All projects must have equal ownership between all team members: ideally, decisions are made collectively and with the help of mentors, but UX is ultimately the one making design decisions, same for WD, DS, DL...etc... for technological decisions. In this specific case, this means that the collective will not be able to validate wireframes or require specific technology stacks. What they would get is a project delivered that they are free to host and use in exchange for opening their DB to you. Also reference to the Techies that worked on the project should then be added to their contribution page.

  • You should confirm with the collective that this is something they would agree on before the project can be moved on to scoping.

3- WD & integration with their website

This is a bit redundant with the previous point, but the collective is using Hugo, a static website framework whereas the Techies will be using some different stack that they build from scratch. For this reason, the project can not be integrated directly into their website. There are other solutions like hosting independently and linking it, which can be discussed with the WD team and / or mentors.

  • Communicate to the collective that Techies will not be working on their existing website/technologies, but rather create a new project that the collective will be 100% host and use.

4 - team constitution

DL is not needed for the scope of this project, so our suggestion is:

  • 1 to 2 UX, 2 WD (frontend & backend), 1 to 2 DS**



Well done and thanks again for submitting your ideas. 🥇

@Rustingheart
Copy link

Rustingheart commented Dec 22, 2023

Thank you so much for the Feedback!
This is very helpfull!

@rjeantet rjeantet added scoping After initial review by track leads, project idea is awaiting required details from Techies and removed proposal A new idea/proposal has been made and is being reviewed labels Jan 8, 2024
@Rustingheart
Copy link

Rustingheart commented Jan 8, 2024

I sadly think I might have to cancel this one. Since I feel they need tooo much time to know exactly what they need. So I am afraid we can not do it in time. Not totally kicking it out. Just so people know!
But still very interested to do a similar topic so anyone who wants to go that direction please Contact me!

@rjeantet
Copy link
Collaborator Author

rjeantet commented Jan 9, 2024

Hey Paula!
Sorry to read this is not moving fast enough on their side, this is indeed the risk pointed out with projects involving third-parties. It is a shame as this project is so meaningful and would be very interesting to work on for all tracks involved.

If you or another DS Techie is keen on it, I would indeed suggest researching some similar alternative datasets and keeping going on this idea, independently from the collective decisions.

@Rustingheart
Copy link

Just as an update for everyone!
Whoever is interested.
I am thinking of another DataSet to Analyze right now.
We can also chat and decide together.

@Rustingheart
Copy link

Hi hi an update from my side!
So I am proposing two new DataSets here that are connected to Protest (1.Worldwide)(2. Europe).
https://dataverse.harvard.edu/dataverse/MMdata

https://poldem.eui.eu/data-overview/

My personal resaon to choose those DataSets:
As I have been researching in my last BA (Dance).
What Gestures can express when a large Group does the same Unisono (>MassProtests).
Which Gestures get World-Fame and why ?
T

@rjeantet
Copy link
Collaborator Author

Closing this since it is being replaced by Mass Protest Cross Countries
& @Rustingheart amazing job of pivoting your idea when facing difficulties !!

@rjeantet rjeantet removed the scoping After initial review by track leads, project idea is awaiting required details from Techies label Jan 14, 2024
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

3 participants