You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
Some times running the same sequence of commands in ScienceWorld leads to different outcome (here making steam or not).
Steps to reproduce:
Load a ScienceWorld game with taskName=task-1-boil, variationIdx=0, and simplificationStr='teleportAction'.
Enter the commands: teleport to kitchen, pour counter into sink, activate sink, use lighter on drawer, and look around
Expect to see "a sink, which is turned on. In the sink is: a bowl (containing a red apple, a banana, an orange, a potato, a substance called water), a burned drawer, a substance called steam."
Running that procedure 8 times in a given Python instance, I got
6/8 runs that are missing steam!
Doing it a second time, I got
4/8 runs that are missing steam!
0/8 runs was expected.
@aphedges I'd love to see your changes to fix non determinism in the Scala code.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
Hmm, given that EnvObject uses a Set() instead of an Array() for a storage class for objects (and most of the downstream functions in the e.g. object parser, etc., assume Sets() instead of ordered arrays), it would likely be a significant refactor to switch everything over to Arrays. I think the previous patch for determinism was limited to just showing the objects in the same order in the description text, which was solved with a call to sort the objects by name or object ID in the object description function.
@MarcCote, as @PeterAJansen stated, removing all non-determinism would be a large refactor, so I didn't attempt to fix most of it. I would have tried to fix a non-deterministic action if I were aware of it, but the only remaining non-determinism that I knew about was in gold path generation. For that, I only fixed a single task, and the fix interferes with our generation of training data, so I never tried to upstream my patch.
Some times running the same sequence of commands in ScienceWorld leads to different outcome (here making steam or not).
Steps to reproduce:
taskName=task-1-boil
,variationIdx=0
, andsimplificationStr='teleportAction'
.teleport to kitchen
,pour counter into sink
,activate sink
,use lighter on drawer
, andlook around
"a sink, which is turned on. In the sink is: a bowl (containing a red apple, a banana, an orange, a potato, a substance called water), a burned drawer, a substance called steam."
Running that procedure 8 times in a given Python instance, I got
Doing it a second time, I got
0/8 runs was expected.
@aphedges I'd love to see your changes to fix non determinism in the Scala code.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: