General issue: Three voices that do not align properly #42
Comments
bel28kent
added
the
vhv-viz-bug
|
You should highlight the text in question in the screen shots so it is easier for me to see what you are referring to. Also if it is a single note, you could click on it to make it red. |
|
I don't see the problem (I fixed areas that look wrong in the above image, but they were correct I think when I looked at them, but in any case I adjusted the spines by swapping 2 and 3 layers which may have fixed it as well). Here is the full markup of the score: 
Click to view Humdrum score for above example.!!!COM: Scriabin, Alexander
!!!OTL@@FR: Prélude en ré mineur
!!!OTL@EN: Prelude in D Minor
!!!OPR@@FR: 7 Préludes
!!!OPR@RU: Семь прелюдий
!!!OPR@EN: Seven Preludes
!!!OPR@DE: Sieben Präludien
!!!OPS: 17
!!!ONM: 1
!!!ODT: 1895-1896
!!!AGN: Prelude
**kern **kern **dynam
*staff2 *staff1 *staff1/2
*Ipiano *Ipiano *
*clefF4 *clefG2 *
*k[b-] *k[b-] *
*d: *d: *
!!!Xfilter: humbreak -m 6,11,16,21,26,31,36,41,46,51
!!LO:TX:omd:tempo:a:t=Allgretto [quarter] = 112
*M3/4 *M3/4 *
*MM112 *MM112 *
8A 8r .
=1 =1 =1
* *^ *
* * *^ *
4A (8fL 2f 4ryy p
. 8a . . .
4G#X 8b- . 4b-\ .
. 8dd . . .
4Gn 8ff: 4b-: 4d: 4ryy .
. 8eeJ . . .
* *v *v *v *
=2 =2 =2
!LO:N:vis=4 ! !
(16%3b- 8gL .
. 8dd .
!LO:N:vis=4 ! !
16%3d . .
. 8ee .
!LO:N:vis=4 ! !
16%3G 8gg <
. 8ccc .
!LO:N:vis=4 ! !
16%3E) . .
. 8bb-J .
=3 =3 =3
(20%3AA 8eeeL .
. 8gg#X [ >
20%3E . .
. 8bb- .
20%3c#X . .
. 8aa .
20%3A . .
. 8dd#X .
20%3g) . .
. 8eeJ ]]
=4 =4 =4
(8DL 8ffL .
8AJ 8ee .
!!LO:TX:a:i:t=rit.
4f) 8g#X .
. 8aJ .
8r 8dd) .
!!LO:TX:a:i:t=a tempo
8d 8r .
=5 =5 =5
* *^ *
* * *^ *
4d (8b-L 2b- 4ryy .
. 8dd . . .
4c#X 8ee-X . 4ee-\ .
. 8gg . . .
4cn 8bb- 4ee- 4g 4ryy .
. 8aaJ . . .
* *v *v *v *
*clefG2 * *
!!LO:LB:g=original
=6 =6 =6
!LO:TUP:b ! !
!LO:N:vis=4 ! !
(16%3ee-X 8ccL <
. 8gg .
!LO:N:vis=4 ! !
16%3g . .
. 8aa .
!LO:N:vis=4 ! !
16%3c 8ccc .
. 8fff .
!LO:N:vis=4 ! !
16%3A) . .
. 8eee-XJ [
*clefF4 * *
=7 =7 =7
(20%3D/ 8aaaL >
. 8ccc#X .
20%3cn . .
. 8eee-X .
20%3f#X . .
. 8ddd .
20%3c . .
. 8gg#X .
*clefG2 * *
20%3dd) . .
. 8aaJ .
*clefF4 * *
=8 =8 =8
(8E-XL 8cccL .
8cJ 8bb- ]
4g) 8bn .
. 8ccJ .
8r 8gg) .
8E- 8r .
=9 =9 =9
4En 8r .
. (8bn <
4B-X 4g 8ccL .
. 8bb-X .
8r 8cc .
8E 8cc#XJ .
=10 =10 =10
4F 8aaL .
. 8cc#X .
4B- 4f 8dd .
. 8gg .
(8dL 8b- 8ee .
8FJ) 8ffJ) .
!!LO:LB:g=original
=11 =11 =11
4F#X 8r <
. (8cc#X .
*clefG2 * *
4d 4ccn 8ddL .
. 8cccn .
8r 8dd .
*clefF4 * *
8F# 8ee-XJ .
=12 =12 =12
4G 8bb-L .
. 8ee-X .
*clefG2 * *
4d 4b- 8een .
. 8aa .
4e 4dd 8ff#X .
. 8ggJ) .
=13 =13 =13
*^ * *
! ! ! !LO:DY:t=%s rubato
4A 4rcyy (8gg#XL f
. . 8aa .
[2dd 4f 8fff .
. . 8ddd .
. 4gn 8ccc .
. . 8ggnJ .
=14 =14 =14 =14
4dd] 4e 8bb-L .
. . 8aa .
4raa 4rc 8gg .
. . 8ee .
4raa 4rc 8dd .
. . 8b-J) .
*clefF4 * * *
=15 =15 =15 =15
4AA 4rEEyy (8g#XL >
. . 8a .
(4f 2Gn 8b- .
. . 8dd .
4e) . 8cc#X .
. . 8gnJ .
!!LO:LB:g=original
=16 =16 =16 =16
* * *^ *
4AA 4rEEyy 8b-L 4rcyy .
. . 8f . .
(4dn 4G 8d#X 8rcyy .
. . 8e 4.e .
8c#X) 8r 8b- . .
8r 8A 8aJ) . .
*v *v * * *
=17 =17 =17 =17
* * *^ *
4A (8fL 2f 4ryy p
. 8a . . .
4G#X 8b- . 4b-\ .
. 8dd . . .
4Gn 8ff 4b- 4d 4ryy .
. 8eeJ . . .
* *v *v *v *
=18 =18 =18
!LO:N:vis=4 ! !
(16%3b- 8gL <
. 8dd .
!LO:N:vis=4 ! !
16%3d . .
. 8ee .
!LO:N:vis=4 ! !
16%3G 8gg .
. 8ccc .
!LO:N:vis=4 ! !
16%3E) . .
. 8bb-J [
=19 =19 =19
(20%3AA 8eeeL >
. 8gg#X .
20%3E . .
. 8bb- .
20%3c#X . .
. 8aa .
20%3A . .
. 8dd#X .
20%3g) . .
. 8eeJ .
=20 =20 =20
(8DL 8ffL .
8AJ 8ee .
4f) 8g#X .
. 8aJ ]
8r 8dd) .
8d 8r .
!!LO:LB:g=original
=21 =21 =21
* *^ *
* * *^ *
4d (8b-L 2b- 4ryy .
. 8dd . . .
4c#X 8ee-X . 4ee-\ .
. 8gg . . .
4cn 8bb- 4ee- 4g 4ryy .
. 8aaJ . . .
* *v *v *v *
*clefG2 * *
=22 =22 =22
!LO:TUP:b ! !
!LO:N:vis=4 ! !
(16%3ee-X 8ccL .
. 8gg .
!LO:N:vis=4 ! !
16%3g . .
. 8aa .
!LO:N:vis=4 ! !
16%3c 8ccc .
. 8fff .
!LO:N:vis=4 ! !
16%3A) . .
. 8eee-XJ .
*clefF4 * *
=23 =23 =23
(20%3D 8aaaL .
. 8ccc#X .
20%3cn . .
. 8eee-X .
20%3f#X . .
. 8ddd .
20%3c . .
. 8gg#X .
*clefG2 * *
20%3dd) . .
. 8aaJ .
*clefF4 * *
=24 =24 =24
(8E-XL 8cccL .
8cJ 8bb- .
4g) 8bn .
. 8ccJ .
8r 8gg) .
8E- 8r .
=25 =25 =25
4En 8r .
. (8bn .
4B-X 4g 8ccL .
. 8bb-X .
8r 8cc <
8E 8cc#XJ .
!!LO:LB:g=original
=26 =26 =26
4F 8aaL .
. 8cc#X .
4B- 4f 8dd .
. 8gg .
(8dL 8b- 8ee .
8FJ) 8ffJ) .
=27 =27 =27
4F#X 8r .
. (8cc#X .
*clefG2 * *
4d 4ccn 8ddL .
. 8cccn .
8r 8dd .
*clefF4 * *
8F# 8ee-XJ .
=28 =28 =28
4G 8bb-L .
. 8ee-X .
*clefG2 * *
4d 4b- 8een .
. 8aa .
4e 4dd 8ff#X .
. 8ggJ) .
=29 =29 =29
*^ * *
4A 4rcyy (8gg#XL .
. . 8aa .
[2dd 4f 8fff .
. . 8ddd .
. 4gn 8ccc .
. . 8ggnJ .
=30 =30 =30 =30
4dd] 4e 8bb-L .
. . 8aa .
4raa 4rc 8gg .
. . 8ee .
4raa 4rc 8dd .
. . 8b-J .
*clefF4 * * *
!!LO:LB:g=original
=31 =31 =31 =31
4AA 4rEEyy 8g#XL .
. . 8a .
[2d 4F 8ff .
. . 8dd .
. 4Gn 8cc .
. . 8gnJ .
=32 =32 =32 =32
4d] 4E 8b-L >
. . 8a .
4rc 4rEE 8g .
. . 8e .
4rc 4rEE 8d .
. . 8B-J) .
=33 =33 =33 =33
!!LO:TX:a:i:t=accel.
4AAA 4rEEyy (>8G#XL p
. . 8A .
(4F 2AA 8B- .
. . 8d .
4E) . 8c#X .
. . 8GnJ .
=34 =34 =34 =34
* * *^ *
4rc 4rEE 8B-L 4rcyy .
. . 8F . .
(4D 2AA 8E-X 8rcyy .
. . 8En 4.E .
4C#X) . 8B- . .
. . 8AJ . .
* * *v *v *
=35 =35 =35 =35
!!LO:TX:a:i:t=accel.
4rc 4rEE 8c#XL .
. . 8d .
(4B- 2AA 8e-X .
. . 8g .
4A) . 8f#X <
. . 8cnJ .
!!LO:LB:g=original
=36 =36 =36 =36
4rc 4rEE 8e-XL .
. . 8B- .
(4G 2AA 8A-X .
. . 8An .
4F#X) . 8d .
. . 8cJ) .
=37 =37 =37 =37
* * *^ *
(2.G [2.AA (>8B-L 4ryy .
. . [8d . .
. . 8g 2d] 2g .
. . 8a . .
. . 8cc . .
. . 8b-J) . .
=38 =38 =38 =38 =38
2.G#X 2.AA] (>8B-L 4ryy .
. . [8d . .
. . 8f 2d] 2f .
!!LO:TX:a:i:t=accel.
. . 8a . .
. . 8cc . .
. . 8b-J) . .
* * *v *v *
=39 =39 =39 =39
2.A 2.AA (8FL .
. . 8c#X .
. . 8d .
. . 8f .
. . 8b- .
. . 8aJ) .
=40 =40 =40 =40
! ! ! !LO:DY:rj
2.B- 2.AA (8FL p
!!LO:TX:a:i:t=accel.
. . 8c#X .
. . 8d .
. . 8f .
. . 8a .
. . 8g#XJ) .
!!LO:LB:g=original
=41 =41 =41 =41
! ! ! !LO:DY:rj
4.Bn 2.AA (8FL f
. . 8c#X .
. . 8d .
4.B-X . 8f .
. . 8a .
. . 8g#XJ) .
=42 =42 =42 =42
4.A 2.AA (8FL .
! ! !LO:TX:a:i:t=rit. !
. . 8d .
. . 8f .
4.G#X) . 8bn >
. . 8ee .
. . 8ddJ) .
=43 =43 =43 =43
[2.Gn [2.AA (8B-XL .
! ! !LO:TX:a:i:t=rit. !
. . 8d .
. . 8e .
. . 8g .
. . 8cc .
. . 8b-J) .
=44 =44 =44 =44
2.G] 2.AA] (8c#XL .
! ! !LO:TX:a:i:t=rit. !
. . 8g#X .
. . 8b- .
. . 8a .
. . 8ff .
. . 8eeJ) .
*v *v * *
=45 =45 =45
* *^ *
! ! !LO:TX:a:i:t=a tempo !
4DD (8b-L 4b- p
. 8dd . .
4c#X 8ee-X 4g .
. 8gg . .
4cn 8bb- 4f#X .
. 8aaJ . .
!!LO:LB:g=original
=46 =46 =46 =46
!LO:N:vis=4 ! ! !
(16%3B- 8gL 2.g .
. 8dd . .
!LO:N:vis=4 ! ! !
16%3E-X . . .
. 8ee-X . <
!LO:N:vis=4 ! ! !
16%3BB- 8gg . .
. 8ccc . .
!LO:N:vis=4 ! ! !
16%3DD) . . .
. 8bb-J . [
* *v *v *
=47 =47 =47
4DD 8ccc#XL >
. 8gg#X .
4AA 4Gn 4c#X 8bb- .
. 8aa .
4r 8ee-X .
. 8eenJ .
=48 =48 =48
4DD 8ffL .
. 8ee .
4AA 4F 4d 8.g#X .
. 16aJk ]
4r 4dd) .
=49 =49 =49
*^ *^ *
4r 2.DD 8AL 4A pp
. . 8d . .
4C#X . 8e-X 4G .
. . 8g . .
4Cn . 8b- 4F#X .
. . 8aJ . .
=50 =50 =50 =50 =50
2.BB- [2.DD 8GL 2.G .
. . 8d . .
. . 8e-X . <
. . 8g . .
. . 8cc . .
. . 8b-J . [[
* * *v *v *
!!LO:LB:g=original
=51 =51 =51 =51
4AA 4DD] (>8cc#XL >
. . 8g#X .
4AA 4Gn 4c#X 4rEEyy 8b- .
. . 8a .
4r 4r 8e-X .
. . 8enJ ]
*v *v * *
=52 =52 =52
[4DD 8fL .
. 8e .
4.DD] 4.AA 4.F 8G#X .
. 8AJ .
. 4d) .
[>8AA . .
=53 =53 =53
! !LO:TX:c:i:t=rubato !
4DD 4AA] (8cc#X~L .
. 8g#X~ .
4.AA 4.Gn 4.c#X 8b-~ .
. 8a~ .
. 8e-X .
[>8AA 8enJ .
=54 =54 =54
[4DD 4AA_ 8fL .
. 8eJ .
2DD_ 2AA_ [2F 4.G#X .
. 8A .
=55 =55 =55
2.DD_ 2.AA_ 2.F_ [2.d .
=56 =56 =56
2DD] 2AA] 2F] 2d]) .
4r 4r .
== == ==
*- *- *-
!!!system-decoration: {(*)}
!!!RDF**kern: > = above
!!!RDF**kern: < = below
!!!RDF**dynam: > = dim.
!!!title: @{OTL}, op. @{OPS}, no. @{ONM}
!!!ENC: Bryan Jacob Bell
!!!END: November 2021 to April 2022
!!!PED: Konstantin Igumnov and Yakov Milstein
!!!PTL: A.N. Skryabin: Polnoe sobranie sochinenii dlia fortepiano (Muzgiz)
!!!URL-pdf: https://vmirror.imslp.org/files/imglnks/usimg/e/e1/IMSLP67928-PMLP20236-Scriabin--Preludes-Op17--Ed-Muzgiz-Konemann.pdf#page=1 A.N. Skryabin: Polnoe sobranie sochinenii dlia fortepiano, Vol.2, Moscow: Muzgiz, 1948. Plate M. 18995 Г.
!!!URL-pdf: https://vmirror.imslp.org/files/imglnks/usimg/9/9d/IMSLP08377-Scriabin_-_Op.17_-_7_Preludes.pdf#page=1 A.N. Skryabin: Polnoe sobranie sochinenii dlia fortepiano, Vol.2, Moscow: Muzgiz, 1948. Plate M. 18995 Г., Reissue - Muzyka, 1973. Plate 7641
!!!URL-pdf: https://vmirror.imslp.org/files/imglnks/usimg/b/bb/IMSLP79146-PMLP20236-Scriabin--Prelude-Op17-No1--FE.pdf#page=1 First edition, Leipzig: M.P. Belaïeff, n.d. (ca.1897).Some notes: (1) For the quartuplets, I used (2) I added three 
(3) I cleaned up some of the 3-layer sections (flipping layers 2 and 3). (4) You could realize the rit. and accel. with (5) There are quarter note rests like this: 
I left them as is, since I am changing to more automatic rest vertical placement (using verovio placement), and such rests are now by default separated (previous default was to merge them). I will probably add |
|
My apologies; I was doing this quickly between classes. Here is an annotated version of the screenshot: 
Link to the kern on editing branch scriabin-op17_no01.krn. |
bel28kent
changed the title
|
Also in scriabin-op22_no02.krn. 
|
Also note clef change issue in m. 23 as documented in humdrum-tools/verovio-humdrum-viewer#861 |
|
I suspect that this is related to The general problem is that there is one way to split one spine into two: "*^". But for two spines, there are both of these seem to produce correct `flipper -a output: **a
A
*^
A1 A2
*^ *
A11 A12 A2
*v *v *v
*-flipper -ia -a**a
A
*^
A2 A1
* *^
A2 A12 A11
*v *v *v
*-And with the alternate spine splitting case: **a
A
*^
A1 A2
* *^
A1 A11 A12
*v *v *v
*-flipper -ia -a**a
A
*^
A2 A1
*^ *
A12 A11 A1
*v *v *v
*-In both case the 3-subspine data gets reversed as expected: Case 1: Case 2: |
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: