tool for making decision in cumbersome cases - when you have a lot of uncertainties/emotions ( or/and a lot of people )
during this "mind storm" think about:
- risks
- opportunities
- what you want to achieve directly ( goals ), indirectly ?
- what you will obtain after the achievement ?
- who also will be affected ?
- ...
item item A item B item C item D item E item F item G item H item I item J item K item L
-
Create second list with all the items from previous step.
-
Sort them out from high probability ( on top ) to less probability ( on bottom ).
item item A item B item G item K item H item J item E item I item C item F item D item L -
Detect "waterline" for the probability - rid off items below it, what is not gonna happen from your point of view.
item item A item B item G item K item H -w--w--w- item J item E item I item C item F item D item L -
Set likelihood [0.25, 0.5, 0.75, 1] where 1 - will be for sure and 0.25 - low possibility.
item likelihood item A 1 item B 1 item G 0.5 item K 0.5 item H 0.25
-
Take list from previous step and sort them out from most influenced to less influenced items ( what will affect your decision ).
-
Detect equal item from influence on decision point of view.
item diff item B item A item G x item H x item K -
Next, just image that you have possibility to set between elements diff-value as [1,2,3]
item diff item B 3 item A 1 item G 2 item H 2 item K -
Try to detect elements, where 3 is not enough, mark all of them.
item diff item B 3 x item A 1 item G 2 item H 2 item K -
Read all marked elements again and try to evaluate one maximal biase between previous element and marked element.
item diff item B 5 item A 1 item G 2 item H 2 item K -
Set proper value for your maximal marked element and set corresponding values agains rest of marked elements.
-
For each item calculate importancy to summarize all previous values, start from 1
item diff influence item B 5 9 item A 1 4 item G 2 3 item H 2 3 item K 1
-
multiply influence on likelihood for all the elements
item factor item B 9*1 item A 4*1 item G 3*0.5 item H 3*0.5 item K 1*0.25 -
sort them out according to factor value
item factor item B 9 item A 4 item G 1.5 item H 1.5 item K 0.25
- for each of the item detect influence on the process
positive neutral negative + % - - and set for each item
item factor item B +9 item A -4 item G %1.5 item H %1.5 item K +0.25
evaluate each of your options with set of item from previous list and calculate factor YES: B, G, H, K = 6.25 ( winner ) NO: A, G, H = -4