diff --git a/code/modules/admin/verbs/adminhelp.dm b/code/modules/admin/verbs/adminhelp.dm
index 3d50b50e414c..758fd2327e77 100644
--- a/code/modules/admin/verbs/adminhelp.dm
+++ b/code/modules/admin/verbs/adminhelp.dm
@@ -530,11 +530,11 @@ GLOBAL_DATUM_INIT(ahelp_tickets, /datum/admin_help_tickets, new)
 			return
 		to_chat(usr, SPAN_WARNING("This ticket has already been marked by [marked_admin]."))
 		var/unmark_option = tgui_alert(usr, "This message has been marked by [marked_admin]. Do you want to override?", "Marked Ticket", list("Overwrite Mark", "Unmark", "Cancel"))
-		if(unmark_option == "Cancel")
-			return
 		if(unmark_option == "Unmark")
 			unmark_ticket()
 			return
+		if(unmark_option != "Overwrite Mark")
+			return
 
 	var/key_name = key_name_admin(usr)
 	AddInteraction("Marked by [key_name].", player_message = "Ticket marked!")