Use OffscreenCanvas instead of --proxy-to-worker

[janpaul123]

I was trying to figure out how to get WORKERFS to work so I can read from File objects directly, and for that I needed my SDL application to run in a web worker. In order to do that I came across --proxy-to-worker, but ran into its limitations (e.g. it crashes on createVertexArray because getExtension('OES_vertex_array_object') is not implemented).

I was then wondering if --proxy-to-worker should be deprecated altogether, since we can now render to a WebGL OffscreenCanvas in a WebWorker directly. I'm still trying to figure out how to do this exactly, so maybe it's implemented already (-s PROXY_TO_PTHREAD?). In that case it might be good to update the documentation accordingly (and perhaps add a note to --proxy-to-worker that you shouldn't use it, and what the alternative is?). Thanks!!

[sbc100]

I think --proxy-to-worker (AKA PROXY_TO_WORKER) has largely been replaced by PROXY_TO_PTHREAD these days.

We do still have support for it though and there is still some testing. The last time this came up I think perhaps @juj still had some valid use cases for it?

[janpaul123]

Yeah, I spent some more time trying to figure out PROXY_TO_PTHREAD, and it looks like it hasn't been fully implemented for SDL yet, see e.g. emscripten-ports/SDL2#127 which is still open. So I don't think we can tell people to switch over from --proxy-to-worker quite yet.

It still might be worth adding a note in the docs at --proxy-to-worker, that PROXY_TO_PTHREAD might be preferable whenever possible, even if --proxy-to-worker doesn't get outright deprecated (if that's the direction things are going in). I'd be happy to make a little PR if people think this is a good idea.

[juj]

The last time this came up I think perhaps @juj still had some valid use cases for it?

I have actually never used --proxy-to-worker for anything. When I authored --proxy-to-pthread, I thought that would obsolete --proxy-to-worker, and on several occassions I have proposed for --proxy-to-worker to be removed, though @kripken has held on to it iiuc as he has dealt with users that have used --proxy-to-worker.

[kripken]

proxy-to-worker also does not require pthreads. It just proxies with postMessage basically, and it can proxy a single-threaded app, which can be useful.

(Perhaps when pthreads support on the web is ubiquitous that will not matter though.)

[stale]

This issue has been automatically marked as stale because there has been no activity in the past year. It will be closed automatically if no further activity occurs in the next 30 days. Feel free to re-open at any time if this issue is still relevant.