EIP Editing Office Hour Meeting 17

[poojaranjan]

Date & Time

Tuesday, May 16, 2023, at 15:00 UTC

Location

Zoom: TBA on EthCatHerders Discord #eip-editors
Recording: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL4cwHXAawZxqnDHxOyuwMpyt5s8F8gdmO

Agenda

• Visit EIPs

To Final

• Update EIP-6105: Move to Final ethereum/EIPs#6940
• Update EIP-6672: Move to Final ethereum/EIPs#7029
• Update EIP-5615: Move to Final ethereum/EIPs#7022
• Update EIP-5507: Move to Final ethereum/EIPs#7021
• Update EIP-6454: Move to Final ethereum/EIPs#6901
• Update EIP-4910: Move to Final ethereum/EIPs#6843

To Last Call

TBA

To Review

• Update EIP-6065: Move to Review ethereum/EIPs#6973
• Update EIP-1185: Move to Review ethereum/EIPs#6970

To Draft

New Proposals

Requested by authors

• Add EIP: Asset-bound Non-Fungible Tokens ethereum/EIPs#6956
• Add EIP: Math checking in EVM ethereum/EIPs#6888
• Add EIP: Semantic Soulbound Tokens ethereum/EIPs#6239
• Add EIP: ERC-721 Utilities Information Extension ethereum/EIPs#6785
• Add EIP: Registry for royalties payment for NFTs ethereum/EIPs#6786
• Add EIP: ERC-721 Holding Time Tracking ethereum/EIPs#6806
• Add EIP: Order Book DEX with Two Phase Withdrawal ethereum/EIPs#6787
• Add EIP: On-Chain EIP-712 Visualization ethereum/EIPs#6865
• Add EIP: Contract Secured Revenue on an EVM based L2 ethereum/EIPs#6969
• Add EIP: Efficient Default Lockable Tokens ethereum/EIPs#6982

From Stagnant

• Update EIP-3026: Move to Draft ethereum/EIPs#7006

Misc

TBA

Open Q&A

Other details

• Working Document: https://hackmd.io/@poojaranjan/EIPEditingOfficeHour
• Announcement Blogpost

(Add your Pull Request number to be added to the agenda.)

[RenanSouza2]

Hello, good evening, I'd like to discuss EIP-6888 if possible.

Thanks

[tbergmueller]

Would be great if we could review/discuss EIP-6956 (New draft, see PR 6956) please

[not entirely sure on the process here though, from my side it could also be merged w/o discussing in office hours if you prefer]

[poojaranjan]

@RenanSouza2 please add the link to PR.

[poojaranjan]

@tbergmueller probably it will be merged before the next meeting, but if it doesn't, we will include it on the agenda.

[RenanSouza2]

@RenanSouza2 please add the link to PR.
ethereum/EIPs#6888
THis is the PR

[JessicaChg]

Please consider merging ethereum/EIPs#6239, thanks.

[OT-kraftchain]

Hello, we would like to move things forward with these 2 PRs:
ethereum/EIPs#6785
ethereum/EIPs#6786
Is there anything else we need to provide in order to have these reviewed?

[saitama2009]

Hello, we would like to discuss EIP-6806. Thanks

[qizheng09]

@poojaranjan Hello, I'm author of EIP-6787 and want to discuss if possible.

Thank you very much!

[poojaranjan]

@qizheng09 please add the Pull Request number. Generally, PRs are reviewed async and editors will leave comments, if any.
In case the PR isn't reviewed or has an outstanding comment that you're looking for help to resolve, happy to add add to the agenda. You're welcome to join the meeting to discuss with EIP editor and push the proposal to the next status.

[poojaranjan]

@ot-kthd
Just make sure to address any comments by other editors before the call. In case, the PR isn't merged before the call and you have questions, feel free to join and share it with the Editor.

[a6-dou]

Please consider merging EIP-6865

Thanks!

[qizheng09]

@qizheng09 please add the Pull Request number. Generally, PRs are reviewed async and editors will leave comments, if any. In case the PR isn't reviewed or has an outstanding comment that you're looking for help to resolve, happy to add add to the agenda. You're welcome to join the meeting to discuss with EIP editor and push the proposal to the next status.

ethereum/EIPs#6787
This is the pr

[ArchieR7]

It would be great if EIP-6672 could be moved to final, ethereum/EIPs#7029

Thank you, @poojaranjan!

[zscole]

Hello, everyone! I would like to discuss EIP-6969. Thanks!

[5660-eth]

Hi, @poojaranjan , please consider merging ethereum/EIPs#6940, Thanks!

[SamWilsn]

I'd like to review 4910 offline.

[dfalloncyr]

Hi @poojaranjan looks like the youtube link is for the last call, was there a new link for today's session? Asking with regard to EIP-6065. We had addressed all of @SamWilsn's comments. Thanks!

[poojaranjan]

@dfalloncyr unfortunately we ran out of time and couldn't cover 'Review' proposals. However, Sam Wilson may review and merge async.
Recording of the meeting is available here.

[poojaranjan]

Closing in favor of #234