diff --git a/recipes/groupme/package.json b/recipes/groupme/package.json
index f282c9af0..06c02b178 100644
--- a/recipes/groupme/package.json
+++ b/recipes/groupme/package.json
@@ -1,7 +1,7 @@
 {
   "id": "groupme",
   "name": "GroupMe",
-  "version": "1.3.0",
+  "version": "1.3.1",
   "license": "MIT",
   "config": {
     "serviceURL": "https://web.groupme.com",
diff --git a/recipes/groupme/webview.js b/recipes/groupme/webview.js
index 0f0d3a6ba..680f12e3c 100644
--- a/recipes/groupme/webview.js
+++ b/recipes/groupme/webview.js
@@ -7,20 +7,18 @@ const _path = _interopRequireDefault(require('path'));
 module.exports = Ferdium => {
   const getMessages = () => {
     // array-ify the list of conversations
-    const allConversations = [
-      ...document.querySelectorAll('#tray .tray-list .list-item'),
+    const unreadConversations = [
+      ...document.querySelectorAll('#tray .tray-list .list-item.unread'),
     ];
     // for each conversation on the list...
-    const filteredConversations = allConversations.filter(e => {
-      // keep it on the list if [1] it has unread messages (not .ng-hide), and [2] it isn't muted (not .overlay)
-      return (
-        !e.innerHTML.includes('ng-hide') && !e.innerHTML.includes('overlay')
-      );
+    const filteredConversations = unreadConversations.filter(e => {
+      // keep it on the list if it isn't muted (not .muted)
+      return !e.innerHTML.includes('muted');
     });
-    const unreadConversations = filteredConversations.length;
+    const unreadUnmutedConversations = filteredConversations.length;
 
     // set Ferdium badge
-    Ferdium.setBadge(unreadConversations);
+    Ferdium.setBadge(unreadUnmutedConversations);
   };
 
   Ferdium.loop(getMessages);