You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
In Bach/Fugues/bwv_846, the measure 16 looks like that:
According to the following two references (here and here), the colored note should be a G sharp, however, it is natural in ASAP (there isn't any sharps at the clef):
I can open a PR to fix that, but I came across that measure for another reason, the voicing in the MusicXML seems wrong:
You can see that the A in voice 1 (blue) in the middle of the bar is tied to the A in voice 3 (orange). In the two references above, the two chords in voice 1 at beats 2 and 2.5 are split into two voices. Should I fix the score and attribute the bottom note of those chords to the voice 3? That way, the voice 3 won't have any gaps, and the A's tie won't change voice (while none of those issues is really forbidden, I feel like those changes would clean up this measure).
By the way, I've spotted a couple more scores with cross-voice ties, that could easily be fixed by swapping two voices. Should I open a PR for those too? (I'll likely fix them anyway on my fork, but should I bring back those changes here?)
Thank you!
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
I won't be able to check this more in detail or to merge pull requests until the 5 of march unfortunately.
If it is urgent for you (also about the other pull requests you sent) send me a private email!
No problem for the slow merging process, I work mainly from my fork anyway. I bring back my modifications here as they could be useful for other people, but no problem if you consider some of them out of scope of ASAP, just drop them!
In Bach/Fugues/bwv_846, the measure 16 looks like that:

According to the following two references (here and here), the colored note should be a G sharp, however, it is natural in ASAP (there isn't any sharps at the clef):


I can open a PR to fix that, but I came across that measure for another reason, the voicing in the MusicXML seems wrong:

You can see that the A in voice 1 (blue) in the middle of the bar is tied to the A in voice 3 (orange). In the two references above, the two chords in voice 1 at beats 2 and 2.5 are split into two voices. Should I fix the score and attribute the bottom note of those chords to the voice 3? That way, the voice 3 won't have any gaps, and the A's tie won't change voice (while none of those issues is really forbidden, I feel like those changes would clean up this measure).
By the way, I've spotted a couple more scores with cross-voice ties, that could easily be fixed by swapping two voices. Should I open a PR for those too? (I'll likely fix them anyway on my fork, but should I bring back those changes here?)
Thank you!
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: