Not clear if you should use a Device or an Entity as a target [new user observation 6 of 7] #17231
Replies: 1 comment
-
i can confirm the uncertainty as quite a new user of HA. I got this comment here in a thread "never use devices to automate off of, always the entities instead" With mention I mean a little "info" mark or a deep link to doc (which i didnt find right away right now) For devices: For entities I didnt really found a explaination but how I understand it, they are concepts/properties/attributes from devices that can be read/written. This would help to improve the learnability. WHen it comes to automations and using on or the other: most dialogues allow one or the other and not both at the same time right? |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
I observed a new user creating simple light automations for three hours this weekend.
Observation 6 of 7:
Problem 6: Not clear if you should use a Device or an Entity as a target
Proposal 6: Hide one or the other
(Low-priority: the new user just always used entity, but did not know why.)
It is not clear why you should choose a device or an entity when applying a service call. Both are available and most things are listed in both. If one is preferred, it should be shown and the other hidden.
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
All reactions