[REGRESSION]: FileTransform@2 task now returns SucceededWithIssues if there is nothing to transform

[nickperkins]

New issue checklist

• I searched for existing GitHub issues
• I read pipeline troubleshooting guide
• I checked how to collect logs

Task name

FileTransform@2

Breaking task version

2.249.1

Last working task version

2.246.1

Regression Description

In the previous version, if there was nothing to transform in the file, an error message would appear but the task would return Succeeded

Now if there is nothing to transform in the file, the error message appears but the task now returns SucceededWithIssues

Environment type (Please select at least one enviroment where you face this issue)

• Self-Hosted
• Microsoft Hosted
• VMSS Pool
• Container

Azure DevOps Server type

dev.azure.com (formerly visualstudio.com)

Azure DevOps Server Version (if applicable)

No response

Operation system

ubuntu-22.04

Relevant log output

<details>
  <summary>UNSUCCESSFUL RUN</summary>
  <pre> 2025-02-05T00:08:17.2161292Z ##[section]Starting: File transformation: appsettings.json
2025-02-05T00:08:17.2195145Z ==============================================================================
2025-02-05T00:08:17.2196642Z Task         : File transform
2025-02-05T00:08:17.2197981Z Description  : Replace tokens with variable values in XML or JSON configuration files
2025-02-05T00:08:17.2199358Z Version      : 2.249.1
2025-02-05T00:08:17.2203107Z Author       : Microsoft Corporation
2025-02-05T00:08:17.2204433Z Help         : https://docs.microsoft.com/azure/devops/pipelines/tasks/utility/file-transform
2025-02-05T00:08:17.2205729Z ==============================================================================
2025-02-05T00:08:19.3347067Z Applying JSON variable substitution for **/appsettings.json
2025-02-05T00:08:20.3314853Z Applying JSON variable substitution for /__w/1/s/removedi/appsettings.json
2025-02-05T00:08:20.3360350Z ##[error]Error: Failed to apply JSON variable substitution. Changes are already present in the package.
2025-02-05T00:08:20.3392675Z ##[section]Finishing: File transformation: appsettings.json ] </pre>
</details>

<details>
  <summary>SUCCESSFUL RUN</summary>
  <pre>2025-02-02T07:04:20.6114722Z ##[section]Starting: File transformation: appsettings.json
2025-02-02T07:04:20.6141914Z ==============================================================================
2025-02-02T07:04:20.6143251Z Task         : File transform
2025-02-02T07:04:20.6144135Z Description  : Replace tokens with variable values in XML or JSON configuration files
2025-02-02T07:04:20.6145163Z Version      : 2.246.1
2025-02-02T07:04:20.6146091Z Author       : Microsoft Corporation
2025-02-02T07:04:20.6147005Z Help         : https://docs.microsoft.com/azure/devops/pipelines/tasks/utility/file-transform
2025-02-02T07:04:20.6148049Z ==============================================================================
2025-02-02T07:04:22.3341889Z Applying JSON variable substitution for **/appsettings.json
2025-02-02T07:04:23.1457122Z Applying JSON variable substitution for /__w/1/s/removed/appsettings.json
2025-02-02T07:04:23.1489941Z ##[error]Failed to apply JSON variable substitution. Changes are already present in the package.
2025-02-02T07:04:23.1511458Z ##[section]Finishing: File transformation: appsettings.json</pre>
</details>

Full task logs with system.debug enabled

Repro steps

[woeterman94]

For me the taks (and build) fails entirely if there is nothing to transform. Version 2.249.1.

Behavior before (version 2.246.1)

[Devvox93]

It depends whether you have continueOnError on true, but the main issue is that the task returns an error now where it didn't used to do that. This is either unintended or should have been a major version increase (because it's a breaking change in behavior).

[ppi-kosipenko]

This is breaking logic in our pipelines. The error was annoying before, but now its a showstopper.

[ppi-kosipenko]

When will this be addressed?

[EshitaD]

Hi All, we have fixed the issue by overriding the task version to 2.246.1 and are currently working on code changes.

[wouter-vanderauwera-fluvius]

Hi All, we have fixed the issue by overriding the task version to 2.246.1 and are currently working on code changes.

How did you manage to do that?

[EshitaD]

@wouter-vanderauwera-fluvius We have a command to override the task version to the previously working version, and using that, we created a config change.

[dhungelarun]

this is breaking our release pipeline. There doesn't seem to be way for us to selective choose the working version in classic release. I know we can do that in YAML by using task@version number. Anyone has any ideas?

[PedroC88]

Can this change be rolled back until there's a fix?... It's unreasonable to leave this broken for something that impacts so many users in production environments....

[msoler8785]

2.246.1 seems to have a bug with the XML transform task which causes it to run on non-windows platforms even if it isn't selected.

2025-02-17T18:36:52.9629048Z ##[debug]Evaluating: succeeded()
2025-02-17T18:36:52.9629727Z ##[debug]Evaluating succeeded:
2025-02-17T18:36:52.9630718Z ##[debug]=> True
2025-02-17T18:36:52.9631510Z ##[debug]Result: True
2025-02-17T18:36:52.9632258Z ##[section]Starting: File Transform: 
2025-02-17T18:36:52.9643879Z ==============================================================================
2025-02-17T18:36:52.9644260Z Task         : File transform
2025-02-17T18:36:52.9644501Z Description  : Replace tokens with variable values in XML or JSON configuration files
2025-02-17T18:36:52.9644851Z Version      : 2.246.1
2025-02-17T18:36:52.9645081Z Author       : Microsoft Corporation
2025-02-17T18:36:52.9645327Z Help         : https://docs.microsoft.com/azure/devops/pipelines/tasks/utility/file-transform
2025-02-17T18:36:52.9645724Z ==============================================================================
...
2025-02-17T18:36:53.2982724Z ##[debug]xmlTransformationRules=-transform **\*.Release.config -xml **\*.config
2025-02-17T18:36:53.2986115Z ##[debug]xmlTargetFiles=undefined
2025-02-17T18:36:53.2987279Z ##[debug]jsonTargetFiles=appsettings.json
2025-02-17T18:36:53.3011429Z ##[debug]task result: Failed
2025-02-17T18:36:53.3051433Z ##[error]Error: Cannot perform XML transformations on a non-Windows platform.
2025-02-17T18:36:53.3062949Z ##[debug]Processed: ##vso[task.issue type=error;source=TaskInternal;correlationId=214b7a97-5a4e-4b97-958c-6eaa52fd79cf;]Error: Cannot perform XML transformations on a non-Windows platform.
2025-02-17T18:36:53.3066252Z ##[debug]Processed: ##vso[task.complete result=Failed;]Error: Cannot perform XML transformations on a non-Windows platform.
2025-02-17T18:36:53.3081944Z ##[section]Finishing: File Transform: 

[EshitaD]

we have merged the PR, and deployments will start on Monday or Tuesday. I will let you know once the deployments are completed.

[PedroC88]

Is there an ETA for this to be generally available?

[xianglitheonly]

Hello Team, may I know if the deployments are done? Thanks!

[EshitaD]

Hi All, We have made the necessary code changes and have already triggered task deployments, which are completed up to Ring 2. The changes are expected to be rolled out to all rings by this weekend. I will let you know once the deployment is completed.