Please revise UBERON:0001850 lacrimal drainage system

[paola-scibite]

UBERON:0001850 lacrimal drainage system
has an editor note "TODO - resolve lacrimal canaliculus vs larcimal duct"
please see obophenotype/cell-ontology#1392 for implications/consequences in CL too. Thanks!

[paolaroncaglia]

Dear Uberon and CL editors,
No rush, but it'd be great if someone other than me could address this issue please, along with the related CL one. (I'll assign to myself for now so it doesn't get lost, but feel free to unassign!)
Note that UBERON:0001850 'lacrimal drainage system' is applicable (restricted) to Tetrapoda, so the related anatomical terms should accommodate some non-mammalian vertebrates too. Thanks.

[github-actions]

This issue has not seen any activity in the past 6 months; it will be closed automatically in one year from now if no action is taken.

[github-actions]

This issue has been closed automatically because it has not been updated in 18 months. Please re-open if you still need this to be addressed.

[anitacaron]

@bvarner-ebi, could you have a look into this, please? 😄

[ghost]

Below are some notes and proposed edits.
CC @cmungall who is a dbxref for the text definitions of some of the terms noted below.

Synonyms

• "lacrimal duct" is a related synonym of 'lacrimal drainage system'.
  Agree, no change.
  Of note, the definition of synonym dbxref FMA:61063 ‘Lacrimal duct’ seems to exclude excretory lacrimal ducts, which aligns with the definitions of ‘lacrimal canaliculus’ and ‘nasolacrimal duct’.

• Add "lacrimal duct" as a related synonym of 'lacrimal canaliculus';
  dbxrefs:
  ISBN:1587341026;
  https://www.bartleby.com/lit-hub/anatomy-of-the-human-body/fig-896/

• Add "lacrimal duct" as a related synonym of 'nasolacrimal duct';
  dbxref:
  PMID:30285382

Definitions

• CL:1000433 'epithelial cell of lacrimal canaliculus'
  
Equivalent to
 epithelial cell and part of some lacrimal canaliculus
  Agree, no change.

• CL:1000435 'epithelial cell of lacrimal duct'
  
Equivalent to 
non-branched duct epithelial cell and part of some lacrimal drainage system
  
Proposed changes:
  

  
- [x] Relabel 'epithelial cell of lacrimal duct' to 'epithelial cell of lacrimal drainage system'
  
- [x] Add "epithelial cell of lacrimal duct” (the current label) as a related synonym.
  
- [x] Change logical defintion to:
  
Equivalent to
 ‘duct epithelial cell’ and part of some 'lacrimal drainage system'
  
- [x] Update text def:
  
CURRENT: "An epithelial cell that is part of the lacrimal duct."
  
PROPOSED: "An epithelial cell that is part of the lacrimal drainage system."

Miscellaneous

• Remove editor note from 'lacrimal drainage system' and 'lacrimal canaliculus'

• Consider obsoleting the following and move current classes under 'duct epithelial cell':

‘branched duct epithelial cell’
‘non-branched duct epithelial cell’

• Consider adding new Uberon term 'excretory lacrimal duct'

[dosumis]

@paola-scibite - could you comment on @bvarner-ebi 's comment?

[dosumis]

CC @cmungall

[cmungall]

I agree with @bvarner-ebi's proposed changes

[paola-scibite]

Thank you @bvarner-ebi , @dosumis and @cmungall . The proposed changes sound good to me too. Best wishes!

[ghost]

Edits addressed in this issue:

• Add "lacrimal duct" as a related synonym of 'lacrimal canaliculus';
  dbxrefs:
  ISBN:1587341026;
  https://www.bartleby.com/lit-hub/anatomy-of-the-human-body/fig-896/

• Add "lacrimal duct" as a related synonym of 'nasolacrimal duct';
  dbxref:
  PMID:30285382

• Remove editor note from 'lacrimal drainage system' and 'lacrimal canaliculus'

• CL edits to be addressed in cell-ontology: Edit terms related to the lacrimal drainage system cell-ontology#2224