You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
Hi, I am opening this issue here to get maintainer feedback before I put in the work to create a pull request.
There are only a few different crossing types in the UK and there’s a desire in the UK community for more specific presets. Mappers take issue with the generic “marked crosswalk” preset which sets crossing:markings=yes. If I type in “zebra crossing” then I should be shown a zebra crossing preset, and that should populate all the right tags.
Now as far as I understand, there used to be a zebra crossing preset that would add crossing=zebra but the US version of iD called it “marked crosswalk”, and the US has all sorts of crossing markings, so this led to the crossing=zebra tag being used, confusingly, for all sorts of marked crossings, whether they had zebra markings or not. I would want to avoid repeating this. It seems the solution is region- or country-specific presets.
I brought up the idea in the UK community subform, here and here, and it generally got positive feedback.
If you think this idea is worth pursuing (& has a chance of being merged), then I could start working on a bunch of UK-specific presets that would look a bit like this, but I’d discuss the specific tags with the community. The generic marked crossing preset could even be disabled in the UK.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
Hi, I am opening this issue here to get maintainer feedback before I put in the work to create a pull request.
There are only a few different crossing types in the UK and there’s a desire in the UK community for more specific presets. Mappers take issue with the generic “marked crosswalk” preset which sets
crossing:markings=yes
. If I type in “zebra crossing” then I should be shown a zebra crossing preset, and that should populate all the right tags.Now as far as I understand, there used to be a zebra crossing preset that would add
crossing=zebra
but the US version of iD called it “marked crosswalk”, and the US has all sorts of crossing markings, so this led to thecrossing=zebra
tag being used, confusingly, for all sorts of marked crossings, whether they had zebra markings or not. I would want to avoid repeating this. It seems the solution is region- or country-specific presets.I brought up the idea in the UK community subform, here and here, and it generally got positive feedback.
If you think this idea is worth pursuing (& has a chance of being merged), then I could start working on a bunch of UK-specific presets that would look a bit like this, but I’d discuss the specific tags with the community. The generic marked crossing preset could even be disabled in the UK.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: