Place in OSM not found in Pelias after importing

[mihaicosareanu-bolt]

Hi,

I'm trying to import the OSM data for the city of Ganja, Azerbaijan into pelias.

It seems that there are some places that exist in .pbf (I used pbf2json to find them), but they are not present in the elasticsearch index, or I can't seem to find them.

Here is an example of a place: https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/6600732186#map=19/40.68178/46.35879

Even when trying on the following link, I can't seem to find the place: https://geocode.earth/

If you encountered this type of issue before, any advice in how to debug and figure out why it doesn't work would be greatly appreciated :).

[missinglink]

We have that restaurant in our production build:
https://pelias.github.io/compare/#/v1/place%3Fids=openstreetmap:address:node/6600732186

Can you please try the path /v1/place?ids=openstreetmap:address:node/6600732186 against your server to double-check that the document isn't in your index?

[missinglink]

It might be that they are present but you aren't able to find them for one reason or another, if that's the case please share some of your queries.

[missinglink]

Agh I know what it is actually, the name "Osmanli Doner" has been tagged name:en when Pelias expects the name to be in the form of another tag, usually name (but we also support others).

Could you please check if this is a common theme among your failures?

[mihaicosareanu-bolt]

Hmm, I have that entry with the same output. However, the name is missing from the record. Here is the output of pbf2json:

{"id":6600732186,"type":"node","lat":40.681784,"lon":46.3587859,"tags":{"addr:housenumber":"247","addr:street":"Mustafa Kemal Ataturk","amenity":"restaurant","name:en":"Osmanli Doner","opening_hours":"24/7","phone":"+994502071884","website":"https://www.facebook.com/osmanliganja"}}

[missinglink]

re: https://github.com/pelias/openstreetmap/blob/master/schema/name_osm.js

[mihaicosareanu-bolt]

I think I understand. The place in OSM doesn't seem to have a default name, as others do. Would it be a good solution to make it fallback to the "name:en" if for some reason "name" doesn't exist?. What do you think?

[missinglink]

Yes, it's an easy fix so I opened #498 to resolve it

[missinglink]

If you're using the pelias/docker workflow then you can test this dev branch by editing your docker-compose.yml file so that the image points to pelias/openstreetmap:name_fallback instead of pelias/openstreetmap:master.

You can then rerun the opeenstreetmap import and please let me know if it solves your issue.
Please remember to revert that change to use pelias/openstreetmap:master once this PR is merged to master

[mihaicosareanu-bolt]

I tested exactly as you mentioned and it works. That was an absolutely amazing response time! Thank you @missinglink, you are totally awesome :).

Proof:

"features": [
        {
            "type": "Feature",
            "geometry": {
                "type": "Point",
                "coordinates": [
                    46.358786,
                    40.681784
                ]
            },
            "properties": {
                "id": "node/6600732186",
                "gid": "openstreetmap:venue:node/6600732186",
                "layer": "venue",
                "source": "openstreetmap",
                "source_id": "node/6600732186",
                "name": "Osmanli Doner",
                "housenumber": "247",
                "street": "Mustafa Kemal Ataturk",
                "distance": 2525.261,
                "accuracy": "point",
                "label": "Osmanli Doner"
            }
        }
    ],

[missinglink]

why is there no kebab emoji? 🤷‍♂

[missinglink]

This functionality is now available in master via GitHub and the via docker tag 'master'.
It was introduced to master in docker tag master-2019-08-14-f897b8391e801b4e024b31ae9ff4d1868c1310d6.