Tracking issue: MVP IBC Relayer infrastructure #465

hdevalence · 2022-03-02T20:42:01Z

zbuc · 2022-07-29T17:14:16Z

Acceptance criteria: Relayer can execute a full chain of IBC actions, relayer code merged upstream & Strangelove responsible for maintenance

redshiftzero · 2022-12-09T17:08:32Z

Next step here is to use the go buf build process

conorsch · 2023-01-20T17:13:41Z

@avahowell Could you provide an update here about where things stand on the Relayer work?

erwanor · 2023-03-23T20:07:51Z

Good progress made this sprint, need sync'ing with SL tomorrow.

hdevalence · 2023-03-25T04:31:55Z

Updating the current state of play:

The relayer PR has moved to Penumbra support v2 cosmos/relayer#1144 ;
The WIP relayer config scripts are in wip: relayer config generation #2166
Following the same workflow in Penumbra support cosmos/relayer#1124 (comment) , we now have to test testnet-preview against a local devnet (done with pd testnet generate). I edited my "testnet" JSON config file to point at the local instance, which was running pd with RUST_LOG=info,[CheckTx]=debug.

Depending on which chain is "first" in the path, there will be different sequences of messages sent to each chain. I noticed that the failures were happening on the remote testnet-preview chain, which wasn't printing logs in my terminal, so I used rly to make another path with the order reversed, and called it penumbra_path_rev.

The current status is this output:

`pd` log output

2023-03-25T04:15:08.495767Z DEBUG abci:CheckTx{kind=New txid="d22234fbef0d6d265a83c9b1fae86899366e42e4286291025f3cae909fab4878"}:check_stateful: key=b"sct/valid_anchors/29fba254df84ec4662435b6229f714a4b1211a3a359218460aaedf06b3a31212" key_hash=KeyHash("d71cd609df6d085c015be51083de4110f20a28fb7b063306cfd20178f6dd2cd1")
2023-03-25T04:15:08.495817Z DEBUG abci:CheckTx{kind=New txid="d22234fbef0d6d265a83c9b1fae86899366e42e4286291025f3cae909fab4878"}:check_stateful: anchor is valid anchor=Root(29fba254df84ec4662435b6229f714a4b1211a3a359218460aaedf06b3a31212) anchor_height=867
2023-03-25T04:15:08.495818Z DEBUG abci:CheckTx{kind=New txid="d22234fbef0d6d265a83c9b1fae86899366e42e4286291025f3cae909fab4878"}:check_stateless:valid_binding_signature: bvk=VerificationKey<Binding>("0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000") auth_hash=AuthHash("e34885efa7ceb636d89fb1bfe5109b7587cea0d2fdd777e5951246923139e42f")
2023-03-25T04:15:08.495828Z DEBUG abci:CheckTx{kind=New txid="d22234fbef0d6d265a83c9b1fae86899366e42e4286291025f3cae909fab4878"}:check_stateful: key=b"fmd_parameters/previous" key_hash=KeyHash("e6f6c68e4d4435835f1a61aee15200b2833f7688ff36de0cdeb88d5efdb881b5")
2023-03-25T04:15:08.495907Z DEBUG abci:CheckTx{kind=New txid="d22234fbef0d6d265a83c9b1fae86899366e42e4286291025f3cae909fab4878"}:check_stateful: key=b"fmd_parameters/current" key_hash=KeyHash("3a526e6eef60922309324f4621abf9d874aaf003981f8c7e6f7a27a367667379")
2023-03-25T04:15:08.495964Z DEBUG abci:CheckTx{kind=New txid="d22234fbef0d6d265a83c9b1fae86899366e42e4286291025f3cae909fab4878"}:check_stateful: key=b"block_height" key_hash=KeyHash("c4b4e25a8824650a238d3451f754dcda1551dec8bec1a96abe23d2ff8b454db8")
2023-03-25T04:15:08.496122Z DEBUG abci:CheckTx{kind=New txid="d22234fbef0d6d265a83c9b1fae86899366e42e4286291025f3cae909fab4878"}:execute:IbcAction{idx=0}:UpdateClient{client_id=07-tendermint-1}: key=b"clients/07-tendermint-1/consensusStates/0-1595" key_hash=KeyHash("387cad07110e7cb065665eb76581d2dbb05f8919312fc4663bb0b4655e2f86e1")
2023-03-25T04:15:08.496157Z DEBUG abci:CheckTx{kind=New txid="d22234fbef0d6d265a83c9b1fae86899366e42e4286291025f3cae909fab4878"}:execute:IbcAction{idx=0}:UpdateClient{client_id=07-tendermint-1}: msg=MsgUpdateClient { client_id: ClientId("07-tendermint-1"), header: Any { type_url: "/ibc.lightclients.tendermint.v1.Header", value: [10, 204, 5, 10, 166, 3, 10, 2, 8, 11, 18, 31, 112, 101, 110, 117, 109, 98, 114, 97, 45, 116, 101, 115, 116, 110, 101, 116, 45, 99, 97, 114, 109, 101, 45, 48, 97, 101, 48, 102, 52, 97, 101, 24, 187, 12, 34, 12, 8, 197, 234, 249, 160, 6, 16, 230, 133, 219, 153, 3, 42, 72, 10, 32, 54, 109, 167, 169, 205, 185, 20, 51, 176, 84, 137, 124, 210, 65, 106, 28, 86, 13, 104, 226, 103, 246, 8, 65, 64, 158, 224, 4, 89, 154, 248, 45, 18, 36, 8, 1, 18, 32, 232, 83, 111, 66, 237, 80, 94, 253, 109, 45, 100, 187, 35, 111, 79, 18, 8, 246, 161, 115, 95, 36, 170, 206, 185, 111, 35, 78, 159, 192, 193, 30, 50, 32, 190, 147, 119, 187, 242, 20, 28, 51, 83, 220, 238, 200, 31, 87, 103, 131, 100, 128, 73, 54, 240, 179, 232, 126, 46, 244, 113, 12, 95, 51, 242, 132, 58, 32, 227, 176, 196, 66, 152, 252, 28, 20, 154, 251, 244, 200, 153, 111, 185, 36, 39, 174, 65, 228, 100, 155, 147, 76, 164, 149, 153, 27, 120, 82, 184, 85, 66, 32, 251, 229, 226, 182, 102, 35, 62, 238, 201, 0, 21, 24, 75, 110, 59, 136, 40, 75, 57, 222, 12, 36, 142, 10, 129, 109, 111, 209, 135, 128, 189, 126, 74, 32, 251, 229, 226, 182, 102, 35, 62, 238, 201, 0, 21, 24, 75, 110, 59, 136, 40, 75, 57, 222, 12, 36, 142, 10, 129, 109, 111, 209, 135, 128, 189, 126, 82, 32, 4, 128, 145, 188, 125, 220, 40, 63, 119, 191, 191, 145, 215, 60, 68, 218, 88, 195, 223, 138, 156, 188, 134, 116, 5, 216, 183, 243, 218, 173, 162, 47, 90, 32, 117, 75, 195, 171, 57, 114, 219, 27, 207, 140, 107, 221, 191, 252, 229, 199, 127, 207, 208, 165, 90, 181, 25, 9, 15, 142, 35, 195, 9, 28, 95, 90, 98, 32, 110, 52, 11, 156, 255, 179, 122, 152, 156, 165, 68, 230, 187, 120, 10, 44, 120, 144, 29, 63, 179, 55, 56, 118, 133, 17, 163, 6, 23, 175, 160, 29, 106, 32, 227, 176, 196, 66, 152, 252, 28, 20, 154, 251, 244, 200, 153, 111, 185, 36, 39, 174, 65, 228, 100, 155, 147, 76, 164, 149, 153, 27, 120, 82, 184, 85, 114, 20, 94, 165, 15, 222, 112, 231, 162, 96, 125, 14, 215, 214, 216, 79, 184, 209, 31, 78, 224, 251, 18, 160, 2, 8, 187, 12, 26, 72, 10, 32, 238, 225, 58, 122, 106, 29, 19, 160, 145, 44, 231, 185, 174, 178, 166, 215, 144, 11, 89, 195, 23, 220, 226, 115, 191, 238, 117, 90, 197, 79, 190, 179, 18, 36, 8, 1, 18, 32, 45, 23, 13, 168, 125, 72, 151, 1, 201, 131, 31, 175, 42, 124, 130, 138, 48, 13, 196, 96, 11, 126, 1, 37, 28, 38, 177, 219, 177, 229, 111, 5, 34, 104, 8, 2, 18, 20, 94, 165, 15, 222, 112, 231, 162, 96, 125, 14, 215, 214, 216, 79, 184, 209, 31, 78, 224, 251, 26, 12, 8, 203, 234, 249, 160, 6, 16, 211, 138, 183, 130, 1, 34, 64, 133, 123, 10, 221, 185, 226, 52, 251, 56, 56, 207, 7, 165, 9, 133, 48, 144, 78, 144, 203, 75, 52, 153, 210, 160, 216, 176, 43, 138, 54, 194, 170, 28, 207, 157, 99, 196, 112, 105, 32, 122, 222, 179, 62, 37, 238, 122, 133, 103, 121, 59, 193, 29, 17, 95, 79, 190, 253, 247, 69, 198, 98, 110, 7, 34, 103, 8, 2, 18, 20, 192, 71, 131, 1, 237, 63, 35, 76, 179, 14, 128, 182, 152, 90, 175, 126, 212, 201, 74, 55, 26, 11, 8, 203, 234, 249, 160, 6, 16, 179, 172, 171, 85, 34, 64, 231, 163, 109, 145, 6, 196, 51, 200, 107, 151, 59, 236, 163, 168, 91, 123, 26, 69, 20, 248, 240, 149, 203, 179, 33, 129, 203, 63, 227, 70, 49, 71, 174, 125, 138, 69, 158, 234, 33, 68, 176, 63, 229, 245, 75, 91, 71, 107, 215, 143, 155, 9, 122, 238, 95, 111, 145, 139, 241, 74, 225, 7, 187, 12, 18, 233, 1, 10, 75, 10, 20, 94, 165, 15, 222, 112, 231, 162, 96, 125, 14, 215, 214, 216, 79, 184, 209, 31, 78, 224, 251, 18, 34, 10, 32, 187, 102, 112, 34, 122, 101, 62, 134, 38, 110, 162, 133, 72, 57, 4, 39, 103, 141, 93, 240, 113, 58, 118, 206, 44, 226, 108, 188, 246, 100, 153, 41, 24, 158, 170, 242, 144, 93, 32, 226, 213, 141, 239, 162, 255, 255, 255, 255, 1, 10, 70, 10, 20, 192, 71, 131, 1, 237, 63, 35, 76, 179, 14, 128, 182, 152, 90, 175, 126, 212, 201, 74, 55, 18, 34, 10, 32, 106, 193, 189, 196, 225, 14, 66, 10, 35, 10, 92, 58, 150, 95, 40, 14, 94, 112, 237, 86, 44, 38, 178, 22, 39, 142, 132, 195, 12, 87, 224, 37, 24, 158, 170, 242, 144, 93, 32, 158, 170, 242, 144, 93, 18, 75, 10, 20, 94, 165, 15, 222, 112, 231, 162, 96, 125, 14, 215, 214, 216, 79, 184, 209, 31, 78, 224, 251, 18, 34, 10, 32, 187, 102, 112, 34, 122, 101, 62, 134, 38, 110, 162, 133, 72, 57, 4, 39, 103, 141, 93, 240, 113, 58, 118, 206, 44, 226, 108, 188, 246, 100, 153, 41, 24, 158, 170, 242, 144, 93, 32, 226, 213, 141, 239, 162, 255, 255, 255, 255, 1, 24, 188, 212, 228, 161, 186, 1, 26, 3, 16, 183, 12, 34, 205, 1, 10, 64, 10, 20, 94, 165, 15, 222, 112, 231, 162, 96, 125, 14, 215, 214, 216, 79, 184, 209, 31, 78, 224, 251, 18, 34, 10, 32, 187, 102, 112, 34, 122, 101, 62, 134, 38, 110, 162, 133, 72, 57, 4, 39, 103, 141, 93, 240, 113, 58, 118, 206, 44, 226, 108, 188, 246, 100, 153, 41, 24, 158, 170, 242, 144, 93, 10, 64, 10, 20, 192, 71, 131, 1, 237, 63, 35, 76, 179, 14, 128, 182, 152, 90, 175, 126, 212, 201, 74, 55, 18, 34, 10, 32, 106, 193, 189, 196, 225, 14, 66, 10, 35, 10, 92, 58, 150, 95, 40, 14, 94, 112, 237, 86, 44, 38, 178, 22, 39, 142, 132, 195, 12, 87, 224, 37, 24, 158, 170, 242, 144, 93, 18, 64, 10, 20, 192, 71, 131, 1, 237, 63, 35, 76, 179, 14, 128, 182, 152, 90, 175, 126, 212, 201, 74, 55, 18, 34, 10, 32, 106, 193, 189, 196, 225, 14, 66, 10, 35, 10, 92, 58, 150, 95, 40, 14, 94, 112, 237, 86, 44, 38, 178, 22, 39, 142, 132, 195, 12, 87, 224, 37, 24, 158, 170, 242, 144, 93, 24, 188, 212, 228, 161, 186, 1] }, signer: Signer("penumbrav2t17pjav3wkeqh3r2y3yg4hzhewk3wm847k9pw3ct") }
2023-03-25T04:15:08.540326Z DEBUG abci:CheckTx{kind=New txid="d22234fbef0d6d265a83c9b1fae86899366e42e4286291025f3cae909fab4878"}:execute:IbcAction{idx=0}:UpdateClient{client_id=07-tendermint-1}: key=b"clients/07-tendermint-1/clientType" key_hash=KeyHash("50bd83110077195f5205c183fa2a2e307fda1dfc750823fb4da7b83c8233c351")
2023-03-25T04:15:08.540418Z DEBUG abci:CheckTx{kind=New txid="d22234fbef0d6d265a83c9b1fae86899366e42e4286291025f3cae909fab4878"}:execute:IbcAction{idx=0}:UpdateClient{client_id=07-tendermint-1}: key=b"clients/07-tendermint-1/clientState" key_hash=KeyHash("b6ec07936f3f3d401065bbd7be3fd6fcd8d15fc30615e59f14b233c3d412a0bc")
2023-03-25T04:15:08.540504Z DEBUG abci:CheckTx{kind=New txid="d22234fbef0d6d265a83c9b1fae86899366e42e4286291025f3cae909fab4878"}:execute:IbcAction{idx=0}:UpdateClient{client_id=07-tendermint-1}: key=b"clients/07-tendermint-1/consensusStates/0-1591" key_hash=KeyHash("1a5ccbdce7e392d131e233acd946715a57e1cc50c122054921feebee94f16ff7")
2023-03-25T04:15:08.540554Z DEBUG abci:CheckTx{kind=New txid="d22234fbef0d6d265a83c9b1fae86899366e42e4286291025f3cae909fab4878"}:execute:IbcAction{idx=0}:UpdateClient{client_id=07-tendermint-1}: key=b"block_timestamp" key_hash=KeyHash("b6059f1c6391dc3d8e1b7aa6f33664355dfaa06358f9833d320da31c859356fb")
2023-03-25T04:15:08.540660Z DEBUG abci:CheckTx{kind=New txid="d22234fbef0d6d265a83c9b1fae86899366e42e4286291025f3cae909fab4878"}:execute:IbcAction{idx=0}:UpdateClient{client_id=07-tendermint-1}: key=b"clients/07-tendermint-1/consensusStates/0-1591" key_hash=KeyHash("1a5ccbdce7e392d131e233acd946715a57e1cc50c122054921feebee94f16ff7")
2023-03-25T04:15:08.540702Z DEBUG abci:CheckTx{kind=New txid="d22234fbef0d6d265a83c9b1fae86899366e42e4286291025f3cae909fab4878"}:execute:IbcAction{idx=0}:UpdateClient{client_id=07-tendermint-1}: key=b"block_timestamp" key_hash=KeyHash("b6059f1c6391dc3d8e1b7aa6f33664355dfaa06358f9833d320da31c859356fb")
2023-03-25T04:15:08.541213Z DEBUG abci:CheckTx{kind=New txid="d22234fbef0d6d265a83c9b1fae86899366e42e4286291025f3cae909fab4878"}:execute:IbcAction{idx=0}:UpdateClient{client_id=07-tendermint-1}: key=b"clients/07-tendermint-1/clientState" key_hash=KeyHash("b6ec07936f3f3d401065bbd7be3fd6fcd8d15fc30615e59f14b233c3d412a0bc")
2023-03-25T04:15:08.541247Z DEBUG abci:CheckTx{kind=New txid="d22234fbef0d6d265a83c9b1fae86899366e42e4286291025f3cae909fab4878"}:execute:IbcAction{idx=0}:UpdateClient{client_id=07-tendermint-1}: key=b"clients/07-tendermint-1/consensusStates/0-1595" key_hash=KeyHash("387cad07110e7cb065665eb76581d2dbb05f8919312fc4663bb0b4655e2f86e1")
2023-03-25T04:15:08.541282Z DEBUG abci:CheckTx{kind=New txid="d22234fbef0d6d265a83c9b1fae86899366e42e4286291025f3cae909fab4878"}:execute:IbcAction{idx=0}:UpdateClient{client_id=07-tendermint-1}: key=b"penumbra_verified_heights/07-tendermint-1/verified_heights" key_hash=KeyHash("e61270196a89fc5ada5a796f5943f8b99580e90f3603ddd0eb96f8593c884401")
2023-03-25T04:15:08.541402Z DEBUG abci:CheckTx{kind=New txid="d22234fbef0d6d265a83c9b1fae86899366e42e4286291025f3cae909fab4878"}:execute:IbcAction{idx=0}:UpdateClient{client_id=07-tendermint-1}: key=b"penumbra_verified_heights/07-tendermint-1/verified_heights" key_hash=KeyHash("e61270196a89fc5ada5a796f5943f8b99580e90f3603ddd0eb96f8593c884401")
2023-03-25T04:15:08.541428Z DEBUG abci:CheckTx{kind=New txid="d22234fbef0d6d265a83c9b1fae86899366e42e4286291025f3cae909fab4878"}:execute:IbcAction{idx=0}:UpdateClient{client_id=07-tendermint-1}: key=b"clients/07-tendermint-1/consensusStates/0-73" key_hash=KeyHash("36cb4ddeec754f4ba3da903fb41491dc99bd971ef0ee72df7590cb69e9a803e5")
2023-03-25T04:15:08.541639Z DEBUG abci:CheckTx{kind=New txid="d22234fbef0d6d265a83c9b1fae86899366e42e4286291025f3cae909fab4878"}:execute:IbcAction{idx=0}:UpdateClient{client_id=07-tendermint-1}: key=b"block_height" key_hash=KeyHash("c4b4e25a8824650a238d3451f754dcda1551dec8bec1a96abe23d2ff8b454db8")
2023-03-25T04:15:08.541675Z DEBUG abci:CheckTx{kind=New txid="d22234fbef0d6d265a83c9b1fae86899366e42e4286291025f3cae909fab4878"}:execute:IbcAction{idx=0}:UpdateClient{client_id=07-tendermint-1}: key=b"block_timestamp" key_hash=KeyHash("b6059f1c6391dc3d8e1b7aa6f33664355dfaa06358f9833d320da31c859356fb")
2023-03-25T04:15:08.541709Z DEBUG abci:CheckTx{kind=New txid="d22234fbef0d6d265a83c9b1fae86899366e42e4286291025f3cae909fab4878"}:execute:IbcAction{idx=0}:UpdateClient{client_id=07-tendermint-1}: key=b"penumbra_verified_heights/07-tendermint-1/verified_heights" key_hash=KeyHash("e61270196a89fc5ada5a796f5943f8b99580e90f3603ddd0eb96f8593c884401")
2023-03-25T04:15:08.541765Z DEBUG abci:CheckTx{kind=New txid="d22234fbef0d6d265a83c9b1fae86899366e42e4286291025f3cae909fab4878"}:execute:IbcAction{idx=1}:ConnectionOpenAck{connection_id=connection-16}: msg=MsgConnectionOpenAck { conn_id_on_a: ConnectionId("connection-16"), conn_id_on_b: ConnectionId("connection-15"), client_state_of_a_on_b: Any { type_url: "/ibc.lightclients.tendermint.v1.ClientState", value: [10, 37, 112, 101, 110, 117, 109, 98, 114, 97, 45, 116, 101, 115, 116, 110, 101, 116, 45, 99, 97, 114, 109, 101, 45, 108, 111, 99, 97, 108, 45, 57, 57, 50, 56, 102, 54, 55, 52, 18, 4, 8, 1, 16, 3, 26, 3, 8, 160, 56, 34, 3, 8, 192, 112, 42, 3, 8, 216, 4, 50, 0, 58, 3, 16, 182, 12, 66, 39, 10, 21, 8, 1, 16, 1, 24, 1, 42, 13, 74, 77, 84, 58, 58, 76, 101, 97, 102, 78, 111, 100, 101, 18, 12, 10, 2, 0, 1, 16, 32, 24, 16, 32, 48, 48, 1, 24, 64, 66, 16, 10, 2, 8, 1, 18, 8, 10, 2, 0, 1, 16, 32, 48, 1, 24, 1, 74, 7, 117, 112, 103, 114, 97, 100, 101, 74, 16, 117, 112, 103, 114, 97, 100, 101, 100, 73, 66, 67, 83, 116, 97, 116, 101, 80, 1, 88, 1] }, proof_conn_end_on_b: CommitmentProof("0AE6060AE3060A19636F6E6E656374696F6E732F636F6E6E656374696F6E2D3135126D0A0F30372D74656E6465726D696E742D3112230A0131120D4F524445525F4F524445524544120F4F524445525F554E4F524445524544180222330A0F30372D74656E6465726D696E742D31120D636F6E6E656374696F6E2D31361A110A0F50656E756D627261417070486173681A150801100118012A0D4A4D543A3A4C6561664E6F64652234080112304A4D543A3A496E74726E616C4E6F646531747AD4766C825F18098D8670E99CAADBD863EA8809E65A3A568E63DBD4C5D02234080112304A4D543A3A496E74726E616C4E6F6465A00DD164485858AC5C6D40E677EA82F855813867670D5821D9357A0222FE900A2234080112304A4D543A3A496E74726E616C4E6F6465853FB6671CAE49F5B7D1FC60B8503D1AF83A17E7377496B80587C6A8F5CE04D12234080112304A4D543A3A496E74726E616C4E6F6465F09770ADC02CBCBC063F4EAA75CE8230C06832DC763978FBC7E9137C34DB9C6D2234080112304A4D543A3A496E74726E616C4E6F64654C2C13C9737019298F5E408726DA4AB04835EA802ACB7790946983850023478A2236080112104A4D543A3A496E74726E616C4E6F64651A200E7404D38C8BA2DB53FF423E6DDB85BAB6409D46D5818D11AEB449B49AF9D4272234080112304A4D543A3A496E74726E616C4E6F6465FD4871DE2C250F3CCB89FEBA022F5CA8034F5C5DBE212570B0A96A1633621DA02234080112304A4D543A3A496E74726E616C4E6F646537192F91E044A40B85A358FBAEE3520D4C0CA0571E1F2DDF5439E094E0844F012234080112304A4D543A3A496E74726E616C4E6F6465C7EA181F29162ABBF32F9A8FA7D63C2C242647773CB00E1A0344BCB37B01F86F2234080112304A4D543A3A496E74726E616C4E6F64659FA8F0E1BDB716ACF08034544B220D9EE5C94998B282AE55520A9FDA1BBACAEC2236080112104A4D543A3A496E74726E616C4E6F64651A2040879CFBEE9BFA87F98293019A3A1371D0F9E8E699E42E099E1ADE8175E23BF92234080112304A4D543A3A496E74726E616C4E6F6465A78B901F5A4C59A684D2F4AA455894C05464E058D7CD8CE123651D475F63F60A2234080112304A4D543A3A496E74726E616C4E6F64655741C5CAAE8D7B60CA412A3B68A12A65B1CCF788E57D77B2FEFFE6B2CC9B975F0A390A370A0F50656E756D6272614170704861736812206C3D63E0633C828FA253EC2ADC69133524E804AA675D89F722F8D8D6827BD5D11A020801"), proof_client_state_of_a_on_b: CommitmentProof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proof_consensus_state_of_a_on_b: CommitmentProof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proofs_height_on_b: Height { revision: 0, height: 1595 }, consensus_height_of_a_on_b: Height { revision: 0, height: 1590 }, version: Version { identifier: "1", features: ["ORDER_ORDERED", "ORDER_UNORDERED"] }, signer: Signer("penumbrav2t17pjav3wkeqh3r2y3yg4hzhewk3wm847k9pw3ct") }
2023-03-25T04:15:08.542100Z DEBUG abci:CheckTx{kind=New txid="d22234fbef0d6d265a83c9b1fae86899366e42e4286291025f3cae909fab4878"}:execute:IbcAction{idx=1}:ConnectionOpenAck{connection_id=connection-16}: key=b"block_height" key_hash=KeyHash("c4b4e25a8824650a238d3451f754dcda1551dec8bec1a96abe23d2ff8b454db8")
2023-03-25T04:15:08.542129Z DEBUG abci:CheckTx{kind=New txid="d22234fbef0d6d265a83c9b1fae86899366e42e4286291025f3cae909fab4878"}:execute:IbcAction{idx=1}:ConnectionOpenAck{connection_id=connection-16}: key=b"block_height" key_hash=KeyHash("c4b4e25a8824650a238d3451f754dcda1551dec8bec1a96abe23d2ff8b454db8")
2023-03-25T04:15:08.542155Z DEBUG abci:CheckTx{kind=New txid="d22234fbef0d6d265a83c9b1fae86899366e42e4286291025f3cae909fab4878"}:execute:IbcAction{idx=1}:ConnectionOpenAck{connection_id=connection-16}: key=b"chain_params" key_hash=KeyHash("111493a3b144602d58199e6bc86ce9cd08f3bceebe0582f9c8d249c274480732")
2023-03-25T04:15:08.542203Z DEBUG abci:CheckTx{kind=New txid="d22234fbef0d6d265a83c9b1fae86899366e42e4286291025f3cae909fab4878"}:execute:IbcAction{idx=1}:ConnectionOpenAck{connection_id=connection-16}: key=b"connections/connection-15" key_hash=KeyHash("deff77df56953e383db9b1acef92dee425e8c07f6e026661cc5c14b01e5b9cb3")
2023-03-25T04:15:08.542242Z DEBUG abci:CheckTx{kind=New txid="d22234fbef0d6d265a83c9b1fae86899366e42e4286291025f3cae909fab4878"}:execute:IbcAction{idx=1}:ConnectionOpenAck{connection_id=connection-16}: trusted_client_state=ClientState { chain_id: ChainId { id: "penumbra-testnet-carme-0ae0f4ae", version: 0 }, trust_level: TrustThreshold { numerator: 1, denominator: 3 }, trusting_period: 7200s, unbonding_period: 14400s, max_clock_drift: 600s, latest_height: Height { revision: 0, height: 1595 }, proof_specs: ProofSpecs([ProofSpec(ProofSpec { leaf_spec: Some(LeafOp { hash: Sha256, prehash_key: Sha256, prehash_value: Sha256, length: NoPrefix, prefix: [74, 77, 84, 58, 58, 76, 101, 97, 102, 78, 111, 100, 101] }), inner_spec: Some(InnerSpec { child_order: [0, 1], child_size: 32, min_prefix_length: 16, max_prefix_length: 48, empty_child: [], hash: Sha256 }), max_depth: 64, min_depth: 0 }), ProofSpec(ProofSpec { leaf_spec: Some(LeafOp { hash: Sha256, prehash_key: NoHash, prehash_value: NoHash, length: NoPrefix, prefix: [] }), inner_spec: Some(InnerSpec { child_order: [0, 1], child_size: 32, min_prefix_length: 0, max_prefix_length: 0, empty_child: [], hash: Sha256 }), max_depth: 1, min_depth: 0 })]), upgrade_path: ["upgrade", "upgradedIBCState"], allow_update: AllowUpdate { after_expiry: true, after_misbehaviour: true }, frozen_height: None, verifier: PredicateVerifier { predicates: ProdPredicates, voting_power_calculator: ProvidedVotingPowerCalculator { _verifier: PhantomData<tendermint::crypto::default::signature::Verifier> }, commit_validator: ProdCommitValidator } }
2023-03-25T04:15:08.542270Z DEBUG abci:CheckTx{kind=New txid="d22234fbef0d6d265a83c9b1fae86899366e42e4286291025f3cae909fab4878"}:execute:IbcAction{idx=1}:ConnectionOpenAck{connection_id=connection-16}: msg.proofs_height_on_b=Height { revision: 0, height: 1595 }
2023-03-25T04:15:08.542299Z DEBUG abci:CheckTx{kind=New txid="d22234fbef0d6d265a83c9b1fae86899366e42e4286291025f3cae909fab4878"}:execute:IbcAction{idx=1}:ConnectionOpenAck{connection_id=connection-16}: counterparty_prefix=PenumbraAppHash
2023-03-25T04:15:08.542305Z DEBUG abci:CheckTx{kind=New txid="d22234fbef0d6d265a83c9b1fae86899366e42e4286291025f3cae909fab4878"}:execute:IbcAction{idx=1}:ConnectionOpenAck{connection_id=connection-16}: msg.proof_conn_end_on_b=CommitmentProof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
2023-03-25T04:15:08.542396Z DEBUG abci:CheckTx{kind=New txid="d22234fbef0d6d265a83c9b1fae86899366e42e4286291025f3cae909fab4878"}:execute:IbcAction{idx=1}:ConnectionOpenAck{connection_id=connection-16}: trusted_consensus_state_root=CommitmentRoot("754BC3AB3972DB1BCF8C6BDDBFFCE5C77FCFD0A55AB519090F8E23C3091C5F5A")
2023-03-25T04:15:08.542402Z DEBUG abci:CheckTx{kind=New txid="d22234fbef0d6d265a83c9b1fae86899366e42e4286291025f3cae909fab4878"}:execute:IbcAction{idx=1}:ConnectionOpenAck{connection_id=connection-16}: connection_path=ConnectionPath(ConnectionId("connection-15"))
2023-03-25T04:15:08.542453Z DEBUG abci:CheckTx{kind=New txid="d22234fbef0d6d265a83c9b1fae86899366e42e4286291025f3cae909fab4878"}:execute:IbcAction{idx=1}:ConnectionOpenAck{connection_id=connection-16}: expected_conn=ConnectionEnd { state: TryOpen, client_id: ClientId("07-tendermint-1"), counterparty: Counterparty { client_id: ClientId("07-tendermint-1"), connection_id: Some(ConnectionId("connection-16")), prefix: PenumbraAppHash }, versions: [Version { identifier: "1", features: ["ORDER_ORDERED", "ORDER_UNORDERED"] }], delay_period: 0ns }
2023-03-25T04:15:08.542915Z  INFO abci:CheckTx{kind=New txid="d22234fbef0d6d265a83c9b1fae86899366e42e4286291025f3cae909fab4878"}: tx rejected e=couldn't verify connection state

Caused by:
    0: ics23 verification failure error: `proof verification failed`
    1: proof verification failed elapsed=47.21525ms

@avahowell suspects that changes to the ICS23 proof spec may be to blame, but I'm not sure I understand why (wouldn't those block earlier parts of the handshake?).

The images pushed to `ghcr.io/penumbra-zone/penumbra` already include `pd` and `pcli`, but not `pclientd`. The latter will be necessary for integration in interchain test. Refs #465.

avahowell · 2023-03-29T08:01:37Z

We debugged this today and are now at the point where the relayer can successfully handshake between two chains. The previous issue was that we had a logic bug in both the connection and channel handshakes introduced after some underlying tendermint-rs changes.

The next step is to test the AcknowledgePacket, RecvPacket, and ICS-20 transfer parts of the state machine.

There's a simpler method for bulk-adding directories of JSON chain configs: `rly chain add-dir`, rather than `rly chain add`. This small change allows us to drop the intermediate webserver, which was always a hack. Encountered this while poring over docs in pursuit of #2284. As usual, refs #465.

Towards #465. Here we define a container image that wraps the upstream cosmos/relayer image with the custom scripting for bootstrapping clients on the Penumbra testnet and preview networks. No other chain configs are part of this container image as of yet. The container image will be publicly available as `ghcr.io/penumbra-zone/relayer`. It isn't yet deployed to the cluster: that'll come next.

Adds a new "relayer" helm chart for deploying the custom relayer container image for penumbra preview <-> testnet paths. In the process, reorganizes the helm charts for ci into a subdir. Towards #465.

conorsch · 2023-04-06T19:58:05Z

We now have a relayer deployment, updated on every merge into main. Its only path is between the preview and testnet environments, and that path is destroyed and rebuilt on every deploy.

The logs on the service show a considerable number of warnings:

ts=2023-04-06T19:40:37.597175Z lvl=warn msg="Error querying block data" chain_name=penumbra-testnet chain_id=penumbra-testnet-pasiphae error="RPC error -32603 - Internal error: could not find results for height #117950"
ts=2023-04-06T19:42:02.639811Z lvl=warn msg="Error querying block data" chain_name=penumbra-testnet chain_id=penumbra-testnet-pasiphae error="RPC error -32603 - Internal error: could not find results for height #117965"
ts=2023-04-06T19:43:31.688064Z lvl=warn msg="Error querying block data" chain_name=penumbra-testnet chain_id=penumbra-testnet-pasiphae error="RPC error -32603 - Internal error: could not find results for height #117980"
ts=2023-04-06T19:45:11.745602Z lvl=warn msg="Error querying block data" chain_name=penumbra-testnet chain_id=penumbra-testnet-pasiphae error="RPC error -32603 - Internal error: could not find results for height #117997"
ts=2023-04-06T19:45:51.750684Z lvl=warn msg="Error querying block data" chain_name=penumbra-preview chain_id=penumbra-testnet-pasiphae-0305d87e error="RPC error -32603 - Internal error: could not find results for height #1620"
ts=2023-04-06T19:46:13.801224Z lvl=warn msg="Error querying block data" chain_name=penumbra-testnet chain_id=penumbra-testnet-pasiphae error="RPC error -32603 - Internal error: could not find results for height #118008"
ts=2023-04-06T19:47:27.814513Z lvl=warn msg="Error querying block data" chain_name=penumbra-preview chain_id=penumbra-testnet-pasiphae-0305d87e error="RPC error -32603 - Internal error: could not find results for height #1638"
ts=2023-04-06T19:47:59.831588Z lvl=warn msg="Error querying block data" chain_name=penumbra-preview chain_id=penumbra-testnet-pasiphae-0305d87e error="RPC error -32603 - Internal error: could not find results for height #1644"
ts=2023-04-06T19:48:15.838806Z lvl=warn msg="Error querying block data" chain_name=penumbra-preview chain_id=penumbra-testnet-pasiphae-0305d87e error="error unmarshalling: invalid character '<' looking for beginning of value"
ts=2023-04-06T19:51:38.966342Z lvl=warn msg="Error querying block data" chain_name=penumbra-preview chain_id=penumbra-testnet-pasiphae-0305d87e error="RPC error -32603 - Internal error: could not find results for height #1685"

There's also a preponderance of errors of a specific type:

❯ kubectl logs relayer-preview-55f668f9bd-rvpdh | rg 'lvl=error msg="Failed to check for misbehaviour"'  | wc -l
828

but the relayer docs say:

The relayer currently cannot monitor and submit misbehavior for clients

So that's to be expected.

conorsch · 2023-04-07T17:18:41Z

Calling this done. There's still a bit more testing to do in #2284 separately, but the plumbing exists for the relayer now. Further IBC work is tracked in #454.

Adds some docs on maintenance tasks and common testing procedures. Links out to information elsewhere, just making it discoverable via the relayer README. Refs #465, #2252.

hdevalence added A-IBC Area: IBC integration with Penumbra E-medium Effort: Medium C-design Category: work on the design of Penumbra labels Mar 2, 2022

hdevalence mentioned this issue Mar 2, 2022

Tracking issue: IBC Implementation #454

Closed

32 tasks

hdevalence mentioned this issue Apr 4, 2022

Define initial ABCI query interface #22

Closed

4 tasks

avahowell self-assigned this Apr 25, 2022

redshiftzero modified the milestones: Testnet 22: Hegemone, Testnet 23: Arche Jul 15, 2022

zbuc modified the milestones: Testnet 23: Arche, Testnet #24: Dia Jul 29, 2022

hdevalence modified the milestones: Testnet #24: Dia, Testnet #25: Helike Aug 7, 2022

avahowell removed this from the Testnet #25: Helike milestone Aug 11, 2022

avahowell moved this to Future in Testnets Oct 7, 2022

avahowell added this to Testnets Oct 7, 2022

avahowell moved this from Future to In Progress in Testnets Oct 7, 2022

plaidfinch moved this from In Progress to Future in Testnets Oct 28, 2022

plaidfinch moved this from Future to In Progress in Testnets Oct 28, 2022

erwanor moved this from In Progress to Todo in Testnets Nov 11, 2022

aubrika moved this from Todo to Testnet 38: Kalyke in Testnets Dec 2, 2022

redshiftzero moved this from Testnet 38: Kalyke to Testnet 39: Praxidike in Testnets Dec 9, 2022

redshiftzero moved this from Testnet 39: Praxidike to Testnet 40: Themisto in Testnets Jan 6, 2023

redshiftzero moved this from Testnet 40: Themisto to Testnet 41 in Testnets Jan 13, 2023

zbuc moved this from Testnet 41: Callirrhoe to In Progress in Testnets Jan 20, 2023

conorsch mentioned this issue Mar 15, 2023

wip: relayer config generation #2166

Merged

erwanor moved this from Testnet 49: Pasiphae to In Progress in Testnets Mar 16, 2023

hdevalence moved this from In Progress to Testnet 50: Theb in Testnets Mar 25, 2023

This was referenced Mar 30, 2023

Test IBC relaying between Penumbra and any Cosmos testnet #2284

Closed

WIP: Penumbra Provider penumbra-zone/relayer#1

Closed

wip: penumbra relayer provider penumbra-zone/relayer#2

Closed

zbuc moved this from Testnet 50: Theb to Tracking Issues in Testnets Mar 31, 2023

zbuc changed the title ~~MVP IBC Relayer infrastructure~~ Tracking: MVP IBC Relayer infrastructure Mar 31, 2023

conorsch changed the title ~~Tracking: MVP IBC Relayer infrastructure~~ Tracking issue: MVP IBC Relayer infrastructure Mar 31, 2023

conorsch mentioned this issue Apr 4, 2023

ci: relayer container build #2298

Merged

conorsch mentioned this issue Apr 5, 2023

ci: add relayer deployment #2308

Merged

conorsch closed this as completed Apr 7, 2023

github-project-automation bot moved this from Tracking Issues to Testnet 50: Theb in Testnets Apr 7, 2023

conorsch added a commit that referenced this issue Apr 18, 2023

docs: how to run relayer via local devnet

b297b3e

Adds some docs on maintenance tasks and common testing procedures. Links out to information elsewhere, just making it discoverable via the relayer README. Refs #465, #2252.

conorsch mentioned this issue Apr 18, 2023

docs: how to run relayer via local devnet #2382

Merged

conorsch added a commit that referenced this issue Apr 18, 2023

docs: how to run relayer via local devnet

89fa953

Adds some docs on maintenance tasks and common testing procedures. Links out to information elsewhere, just making it discoverable via the relayer README. Refs #465, #2252.

Provide feedback

Saved searches

Use saved searches to filter your results more quickly

Tracking issue: MVP IBC Relayer infrastructure #465

Tracking issue: MVP IBC Relayer infrastructure #465

hdevalence commented Mar 2, 2022 •

edited by conorsch

Loading

zbuc commented Jul 29, 2022 •

edited

Loading

redshiftzero commented Dec 9, 2022

conorsch commented Jan 20, 2023

erwanor commented Mar 23, 2023

hdevalence commented Mar 25, 2023 •

edited by conorsch

Loading

avahowell commented Mar 29, 2023

conorsch commented Apr 6, 2023

conorsch commented Apr 7, 2023

Tracking issue: MVP IBC Relayer infrastructure #465

Tracking issue: MVP IBC Relayer infrastructure #465

Comments

hdevalence commented Mar 2, 2022 • edited by conorsch Loading

Overview

Next steps

zbuc commented Jul 29, 2022 • edited Loading

redshiftzero commented Dec 9, 2022

conorsch commented Jan 20, 2023

erwanor commented Mar 23, 2023

hdevalence commented Mar 25, 2023 • edited by conorsch Loading

avahowell commented Mar 29, 2023

conorsch commented Apr 6, 2023

conorsch commented Apr 7, 2023

hdevalence commented Mar 2, 2022 •

edited by conorsch

Loading

zbuc commented Jul 29, 2022 •

edited

Loading

hdevalence commented Mar 25, 2023 •

edited by conorsch

Loading