From efec8a887b8cfdae99040fbd423b7a18a9862a78 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Alyssa Coghlan Date: Mon, 23 Dec 2024 14:17:19 +1000 Subject: [PATCH] gh-126180: Remove getopt and optparse deprecation notices (GH-126227) * Remove getopt and optparse deprecation notices * Add new docs sections for command line app helper libraries * Add guidance on choosing a CLI parsing library to the optparse docs * Link to the new guidance from the argparse and getopt docs * Reword intro in docs section for superseded stdlib modules * Reframe the optparse->argparse guide as a migration guide rather than as an upgrade guide --------- (cherry picked from commit 831b6de6d725c697f2f61fd35c4448cd8a9354ff) Co-authored-by: Alyssa Coghlan Co-authored-by: Serhiy Storchaka --- Doc/howto/argparse-optparse.rst | 36 +++-- Doc/howto/argparse.rst | 15 +- Doc/library/allos.rst | 5 - Doc/library/argparse.rst | 12 ++ Doc/library/cmdlinelibs.rst | 21 +++ Doc/library/filesys.rst | 1 - Doc/library/getopt.rst | 54 +++++-- Doc/library/index.rst | 1 + Doc/library/optparse.rst | 139 ++++++++++++++++-- Doc/library/superseded.rst | 17 ++- Doc/whatsnew/3.13.rst | 24 ++- ...-10-31-14-31-36.gh-issue-126225.vTxGXm.rst | 6 + 12 files changed, 266 insertions(+), 65 deletions(-) create mode 100644 Doc/library/cmdlinelibs.rst create mode 100644 Misc/NEWS.d/next/Library/2024-10-31-14-31-36.gh-issue-126225.vTxGXm.rst diff --git a/Doc/howto/argparse-optparse.rst b/Doc/howto/argparse-optparse.rst index cef2d893b28a62..b684619885b4c7 100644 --- a/Doc/howto/argparse-optparse.rst +++ b/Doc/howto/argparse-optparse.rst @@ -1,20 +1,14 @@ .. currentmodule:: argparse .. _upgrading-optparse-code: +.. _migrating-optparse-code: -========================== -Upgrading optparse code -========================== +============================================ +Migrating ``optparse`` code to ``argparse`` +============================================ -Originally, the :mod:`argparse` module had attempted to maintain compatibility -with :mod:`optparse`. However, :mod:`optparse` was difficult to extend -transparently, particularly with the changes required to support -``nargs=`` specifiers and better usage messages. When most everything in -:mod:`optparse` had either been copy-pasted over or monkey-patched, it no -longer seemed practical to try to maintain the backwards compatibility. - -The :mod:`argparse` module improves on the :mod:`optparse` -module in a number of ways including: +The :mod:`argparse` module offers several higher level features not natively +provided by the :mod:`optparse` module, including: * Handling positional arguments. * Supporting subcommands. @@ -23,7 +17,23 @@ module in a number of ways including: * Producing more informative usage messages. * Providing a much simpler interface for custom ``type`` and ``action``. -A partial upgrade path from :mod:`optparse` to :mod:`argparse`: +Originally, the :mod:`argparse` module attempted to maintain compatibility +with :mod:`optparse`. However, the fundamental design differences between +supporting declarative command line option processing (while leaving positional +argument processing to application code), and supporting both named options +and positional arguments in the declarative interface mean that the +API has diverged from that of ``optparse`` over time. + +As described in :ref:`choosing-an-argument-parser`, applications that are +currently using :mod:`optparse` and are happy with the way it works can +just continue to use ``optparse``. + +Application developers that are considering migrating should also review +the list of intrinsic behavioural differences described in that section +before deciding whether or not migration is desirable. + +For applications that do choose to migrate from :mod:`optparse` to :mod:`argparse`, +the following suggestions should be helpful: * Replace all :meth:`optparse.OptionParser.add_option` calls with :meth:`ArgumentParser.add_argument` calls. diff --git a/Doc/howto/argparse.rst b/Doc/howto/argparse.rst index 1efbee64d60bb3..902c50de00803c 100644 --- a/Doc/howto/argparse.rst +++ b/Doc/howto/argparse.rst @@ -13,11 +13,16 @@ recommended command-line parsing module in the Python standard library. .. note:: - There are two other modules that fulfill the same task, namely - :mod:`getopt` (an equivalent for ``getopt()`` from the C - language) and the deprecated :mod:`optparse`. - Note also that :mod:`argparse` is based on :mod:`optparse`, - and therefore very similar in terms of usage. + The standard library includes two other libraries directly related + to command-line parameter processing: the lower level :mod:`optparse` + module (which may require more code to configure for a given application, + but also allows an application to request behaviors that ``argparse`` + doesn't support), and the very low level :mod:`getopt` (which specifically + serves as an equivalent to the :c:func:`!getopt` family of functions + available to C programmers). + While neither of those modules is covered directly in this guide, many of + the core concepts in ``argparse`` first originated in ``optparse``, so + some aspects of this tutorial will also be relevant to ``optparse`` users. Concepts diff --git a/Doc/library/allos.rst b/Doc/library/allos.rst index 0223c1054ea5d8..1aed340b2527ac 100644 --- a/Doc/library/allos.rst +++ b/Doc/library/allos.rst @@ -15,14 +15,9 @@ but they are available on most other systems as well. Here's an overview: os.rst io.rst time.rst - argparse.rst logging.rst logging.config.rst logging.handlers.rst - getpass.rst - curses.rst - curses.ascii.rst - curses.panel.rst platform.rst errno.rst ctypes.rst diff --git a/Doc/library/argparse.rst b/Doc/library/argparse.rst index e002212199e89b..d4adc164b1bc3d 100644 --- a/Doc/library/argparse.rst +++ b/Doc/library/argparse.rst @@ -11,6 +11,18 @@ **Source code:** :source:`Lib/argparse.py` +.. note:: + + While :mod:`argparse` is the default recommended standard library module + for implementing basic command line applications, authors with more + exacting requirements for exactly how their command line applications + behave may find it doesn't provide the necessary level of control. + Refer to :ref:`choosing-an-argument-parser` for alternatives to + consider when ``argparse`` doesn't support behaviors that the application + requires (such as entirely disabling support for interspersed options and + positional arguments, or accepting option parameter values that start + with ``-`` even when they correspond to another defined option). + -------------- .. sidebar:: Tutorial diff --git a/Doc/library/cmdlinelibs.rst b/Doc/library/cmdlinelibs.rst new file mode 100644 index 00000000000000..085d31af7bca1f --- /dev/null +++ b/Doc/library/cmdlinelibs.rst @@ -0,0 +1,21 @@ +.. _cmdlinelibs: + +******************************** +Command Line Interface Libraries +******************************** + +The modules described in this chapter assist with implementing +command line and terminal interfaces for applications. + +Here's an overview: + +.. toctree:: + :maxdepth: 1 + + argparse.rst + optparse.rst + getpass.rst + fileinput.rst + curses.rst + curses.ascii.rst + curses.panel.rst diff --git a/Doc/library/filesys.rst b/Doc/library/filesys.rst index 0ccf2b7bf59a0f..f1ea4761af7cb1 100644 --- a/Doc/library/filesys.rst +++ b/Doc/library/filesys.rst @@ -14,7 +14,6 @@ in this chapter is: pathlib.rst os.path.rst - fileinput.rst stat.rst filecmp.rst tempfile.rst diff --git a/Doc/library/getopt.rst b/Doc/library/getopt.rst index 3ab44b9fc56108..16ebb929f46002 100644 --- a/Doc/library/getopt.rst +++ b/Doc/library/getopt.rst @@ -7,18 +7,13 @@ **Source code:** :source:`Lib/getopt.py` -.. deprecated:: 3.13 - The :mod:`getopt` module is :term:`soft deprecated` and will not be - developed further; development will continue with the :mod:`argparse` - module. - .. note:: - The :mod:`getopt` module is a parser for command line options whose API is - designed to be familiar to users of the C :c:func:`!getopt` function. Users who - are unfamiliar with the C :c:func:`!getopt` function or who would like to write - less code and get better help and error messages should consider using the - :mod:`argparse` module instead. + This module is considered feature complete. A more declarative and + extensible alternative to this API is provided in the :mod:`optparse` + module. Further functional enhancements for command line parameter + processing are provided either as third party modules on PyPI, + or else as features in the :mod:`argparse` module. -------------- @@ -28,6 +23,13 @@ the special meanings of arguments of the form '``-``' and '``--``'). Long options similar to those supported by GNU software may be used as well via an optional third argument. +Users who are unfamiliar with the Unix :c:func:`!getopt` function should consider +using the :mod:`argparse` module instead. Users who are familiar with the Unix +:c:func:`!getopt` function, but would like to get equivalent behavior while +writing less code and getting better help and error messages should consider +using the :mod:`optparse` module. See :ref:`choosing-an-argument-parser` for +additional details. + This module provides two functions and an exception: @@ -150,13 +152,27 @@ In a script, typical usage is something like this: output = a else: assert False, "unhandled option" - # ... + process(args, output=output, verbose=verbose) if __name__ == "__main__": main() Note that an equivalent command line interface could be produced with less code -and more informative help and error messages by using the :mod:`argparse` module: +and more informative help and error messages by using the :mod:`optparse` module: + +.. testcode:: + + import optparse + + if __name__ == '__main__': + parser = optparse.OptionParser() + parser.add_option('-o', '--output') + parser.add_option('-v', dest='verbose', action='store_true') + opts, args = parser.parse_args() + process(args, output=opts.output, verbose=opts.verbose) + +A roughly equivalent command line interface for this case can also be +produced by using the :mod:`argparse` module: .. testcode:: @@ -166,12 +182,18 @@ and more informative help and error messages by using the :mod:`argparse` module parser = argparse.ArgumentParser() parser.add_argument('-o', '--output') parser.add_argument('-v', dest='verbose', action='store_true') + parser.add_argument('rest', nargs='*') args = parser.parse_args() - # ... do something with args.output ... - # ... do something with args.verbose .. + process(args.rest, output=args.output, verbose=args.verbose) + +See :ref:`choosing-an-argument-parser` for details on how the ``argparse`` +version of this code differs in behaviour from the ``optparse`` (and +``getopt``) version. .. seealso:: - Module :mod:`argparse` - Alternative command line option and argument parsing library. + Module :mod:`optparse` + Declarative command line option parsing. + Module :mod:`argparse` + More opinionated command line option and argument parsing library. diff --git a/Doc/library/index.rst b/Doc/library/index.rst index 951fbcf13fbb13..44b218948d07e1 100644 --- a/Doc/library/index.rst +++ b/Doc/library/index.rst @@ -55,6 +55,7 @@ the `Python Package Index `_. fileformats.rst crypto.rst allos.rst + cmdlinelibs.rst concurrency.rst ipc.rst netdata.rst diff --git a/Doc/library/optparse.rst b/Doc/library/optparse.rst index 74a49a8fb33666..ff327cf9162a8c 100644 --- a/Doc/library/optparse.rst +++ b/Doc/library/optparse.rst @@ -3,25 +3,135 @@ .. module:: optparse :synopsis: Command-line option parsing library. - :deprecated: .. moduleauthor:: Greg Ward .. sectionauthor:: Greg Ward **Source code:** :source:`Lib/optparse.py` -.. deprecated:: 3.2 - The :mod:`optparse` module is :term:`soft deprecated` and will not be - developed further; development will continue with the :mod:`argparse` - module. - -------------- +.. _choosing-an-argument-parser: + +Choosing an argument parsing library +------------------------------------ + +The standard library includes three argument parsing libraries: + +* :mod:`getopt`: a module that closely mirrors the procedural C ``getopt`` API. + Included in the standard library since before the initial Python 1.0 release. +* :mod:`optparse`: a declarative replacement for ``getopt`` that + provides equivalent functionality without requiring each application + to implement its own procedural option parsing logic. Included + in the standard library since the Python 2.3 release. +* :mod:`argparse`: a more opinionated alternative to ``optparse`` that + provides more functionality by default, at the expense of reduced application + flexibility in controlling exactly how arguments are processed. Included in + the standard library since the Python 2.7 and Python 3.2 releases. + +In the absence of more specific argument parsing design constraints, :mod:`argparse` +is the recommended choice for implementing command line applications, as it offers +the highest level of baseline functionality with the least application level code. + +:mod:`getopt` is retained almost entirely for backwards compatibility reasons. +However, it also serves a niche use case as a tool for prototyping and testing +command line argument handling in ``getopt``-based C applications. + +:mod:`optparse` should be considered as an alternative to :mod:`argparse` in the +following cases: + +* an application is already using :mod:`optparse` and doesn't want to risk the + subtle behavioural changes that may arise when migrating to :mod:`argparse` +* the application requires additional control over the way options and + positional parameters are interleaved on the command line (including + the ability to disable the interleaving feature completely) +* the application requires additional control over the incremental parsing + of command line elements (while ``argparse`` does support this, the + exact way it works in practice is undesirable for some use cases) +* the application requires additional control over the handling of options + which accept parameter values that may start with ``-`` (such as delegated + options to be passed to invoked subprocesses) +* the application requires some other command line parameter processing + behavior which ``argparse`` does not support, but which can be implemented + in terms of the lower level interface offered by ``optparse`` + +These considerations also mean that :mod:`optparse` is likely to provide a +better foundation for library authors writing third party command line +argument processing libraries. + +As a concrete example, consider the following two command line argument +parsing configurations, the first using ``optparse``, and the second +using ``argparse``: + +.. testcode:: + + import optparse + + if __name__ == '__main__': + parser = optparse.OptionParser() + parser.add_option('-o', '--output') + parser.add_option('-v', dest='verbose', action='store_true') + opts, args = parser.parse_args() + process(args, output=opts.output, verbose=opts.verbose) + +.. testcode:: + + import argparse + + if __name__ == '__main__': + parser = argparse.ArgumentParser() + parser.add_argument('-o', '--output') + parser.add_argument('-v', dest='verbose', action='store_true') + parser.add_argument('rest', nargs='*') + args = parser.parse_args() + process(args.rest, output=args.output, verbose=args.verbose) + +The most obvious difference is that in the ``optparse`` version, the non-option +arguments are processed separately by the application after the option processing +is complete. In the ``argparse`` version, positional arguments are declared and +processed in the same way as the named options. + +However, the ``argparse`` version will also handle some parameter combination +differently from the way the ``optparse`` version would handle them. +For example (amongst other differences): + +* supplying ``-o -v`` gives ``output="-v"`` and ``verbose=False`` + when using ``optparse``, but a usage error with ``argparse`` + (complaining that no value has been supplied for ``-o/--output``, + since ``-v`` is interpreted as meaning the verbosity flag) +* similarly, supplying ``-o --`` gives ``output="--"`` and ``args=()`` + when using ``optparse``, but a usage error with ``argparse`` + (also complaining that no value has been supplied for ``-o/--output``, + since ``--`` is interpreted as terminating the option processing + and treating all remaining values as positional arguments) +* supplying ``-o=foo`` gives ``output="=foo"`` when using ``optparse``, + but gives ``output="foo"`` with ``argparse`` (since ``=`` is special + cased as an alternative separator for option parameter values) + +Whether these differing behaviors in the ``argparse`` version are +considered desirable or a problem will depend on the specific command line +application use case. + +.. seealso:: + + :pypi:`click` is a third party argument processing library (originally + based on ``optparse``), which allows command line applications to be + developed as a set of decorated command implementation functions. + + Other third party libraries, such as :pypi:`typer` or :pypi:`msgspec-click`, + allow command line interfaces to be specified in ways that more effectively + integrate with static checking of Python type annotations. + + +Introduction +------------ + :mod:`optparse` is a more convenient, flexible, and powerful library for parsing -command-line options than the old :mod:`getopt` module. :mod:`optparse` uses a -more declarative style of command-line parsing: you create an instance of -:class:`OptionParser`, populate it with options, and parse the command -line. :mod:`optparse` allows users to specify options in the conventional +command-line options than the minimalist :mod:`getopt` module. +:mod:`optparse` uses a more declarative style of command-line parsing: +you create an instance of :class:`OptionParser`, +populate it with options, and parse the command line. +:mod:`optparse` allows users to specify options in the conventional GNU/POSIX syntax, and additionally generates usage and help messages for you. Here's an example of using :mod:`optparse` in a simple script:: @@ -82,10 +192,11 @@ Background ---------- :mod:`optparse` was explicitly designed to encourage the creation of programs -with straightforward, conventional command-line interfaces. To that end, it -supports only the most common command-line syntax and semantics conventionally -used under Unix. If you are unfamiliar with these conventions, read this -section to acquaint yourself with them. +with straightforward command-line interfaces that follow the conventions +established by the :c:func:`!getopt` family of functions available to C developers. +To that end, it supports only the most common command-line syntax and semantics +conventionally used under Unix. If you are unfamiliar with these conventions, +reading this section will allow you to acquaint yourself with them. .. _optparse-terminology: diff --git a/Doc/library/superseded.rst b/Doc/library/superseded.rst index 17bfa66f043302..d120c6acf621e3 100644 --- a/Doc/library/superseded.rst +++ b/Doc/library/superseded.rst @@ -4,12 +4,23 @@ Superseded Modules ****************** -The modules described in this chapter are deprecated or :term:`soft deprecated` and only kept for -backwards compatibility. They have been superseded by other modules. +The modules described in this chapter have been superseded by other modules +for most use cases, and are retained primarily to preserve backwards compatibility. +Modules may appear in this chapter because they only cover a limited subset of +a problem space, and a more generally applicable solution is available elsewhere +in the standard library (for example, :mod:`getopt` covers the very specific +task of "mimic the C :c:func:`!getopt` API in Python", rather than the broader +command line option parsing and argument parsing capabilities offered by +:mod:`optparse` and :mod:`argparse`). + +Alternatively, modules may appear in this chapter because they are deprecated +outright, and awaiting removal in a future release, or they are +:term:`soft deprecated` and their use is actively discouraged in new projects. +With the removal of various obsolete modules through :pep:`594`, there are +currently no modules in this latter category. .. toctree:: :maxdepth: 1 getopt.rst - optparse.rst diff --git a/Doc/whatsnew/3.13.rst b/Doc/whatsnew/3.13.rst index 237b1d5f642676..3246308efe8afa 100644 --- a/Doc/whatsnew/3.13.rst +++ b/Doc/whatsnew/3.13.rst @@ -1650,6 +1650,22 @@ opcode (Contributed by Irit Katriel in :gh:`105481`.) +optparse +-------- + +* This module is no longer considered :term:`soft deprecated`. + While :mod:`argparse` remains preferred for new projects that + aren't using a third party command line argument processing + library, there are aspects of the way ``argparse`` works that + mean the lower level ``optparse`` module may provide a better + foundation for *writing* argument processing libraries, and + for implementing command line applications which adhere more + strictly than ``argparse`` does to various Unix command line + processing conventions that originate in the behaviour of the + C :c:func:`!getopt` function . + (Contributed by Alyssa Coghlan and Serhiy Storchaka in :gh:`126180`.) + + pathlib ------- @@ -1789,14 +1805,6 @@ New Deprecations Check membership in :data:`~dis.hasarg` instead. (Contributed by Irit Katriel in :gh:`109319`.) -* :mod:`getopt` and :mod:`optparse`: - - * Both modules are now :term:`soft deprecated`, - with :mod:`argparse` preferred for new projects. - This is a new soft-deprecation for the :mod:`!getopt` module, - whereas the :mod:`!optparse` module was already *de facto* soft deprecated. - (Contributed by Victor Stinner in :gh:`106535`.) - * :mod:`gettext`: * Deprecate non-integer numbers as arguments to functions and methods diff --git a/Misc/NEWS.d/next/Library/2024-10-31-14-31-36.gh-issue-126225.vTxGXm.rst b/Misc/NEWS.d/next/Library/2024-10-31-14-31-36.gh-issue-126225.vTxGXm.rst new file mode 100644 index 00000000000000..13a1f213c7a58e --- /dev/null +++ b/Misc/NEWS.d/next/Library/2024-10-31-14-31-36.gh-issue-126225.vTxGXm.rst @@ -0,0 +1,6 @@ +:mod:`getopt` and :mod:`optparse` are no longer marked as deprecated. +There are legitimate reasons to use one of these modules in preference to +:mod:`argparse`, and none of these modules are at risk of being removed +from the standard library. Of the three, ``argparse`` remains the +recommended default choice, *unless* one of the concerns noted at the top of +the ``optparse`` module documentation applies.