Light doesn't respect manual change #123

haasn · 2024-10-27T22:41:47Z

When I try changing the bulb manually, either in the Hue app or with a dimmer switch, nothing happens and Kelvin immediately overrides the bulb state.

Log

Oct 27 23:36:44 tina kelvin[1178143]: time="2024/27/10 23:36:44" level=info msg="🤖 Kelvin development starting up... 🚀"
Oct 27 23:36:44 tina kelvin[1178143]: time="2024/27/10 23:36:44" level=info msg="⚙ Configuration /opt/kelvin/config.json loaded"
Oct 27 23:36:44 tina kelvin[1178143]: time="2024/27/10 23:36:44" level=info msg="🤖 Initializing bridge connection..."
Oct 27 23:36:44 tina kelvin[1178143]: time="2024/27/10 23:36:44" level=info msg="⌘ Connection to bridge established"
Oct 27 23:36:44 tina kelvin[1178143]: time="2024/27/10 23:36:44" level=info msg="🌍 Working with location <REDACTED> from configuration"
Oct 27 23:36:44 tina kelvin[1178143]: time="2024/27/10 23:36:44" level=info msg="🤖 Devices found on current bridge:"
Oct 27 23:36:44 tina kelvin[1178143]: time="2024/27/10 23:36:44" level=info msg="| Name                             |  ID | On    | Dimmable | Temperature | Color | Temperature range |"
Oct 27 23:36:44 tina kelvin[1178143]: time="2024/27/10 23:36:44" level=info msg="| Hallway Main                     |   5 | false | true     | true        | false |     2200K - 6500K |"
Oct 27 23:36:44 tina kelvin[1178143]: time="2024/27/10 23:36:44" level=info msg="| Entrance                         |   6 | false | true     | true        | false |     2200K - 6500K |"
Oct 27 23:36:44 tina kelvin[1178143]: time="2024/27/10 23:36:44" level=info msg="| Bedroom Main                     |   7 | true  | true     | true        | false |     2200K - 6500K |"
Oct 27 23:36:44 tina kelvin[1178143]: time="2024/27/10 23:36:44" level=info msg="💡 Light Hallway Main - Activating schedule for Oct 27 2024 (Sunrise: 07:43, Sunset: 16:23)"
Oct 27 23:36:44 tina kelvin[1178143]: time="2024/27/10 23:36:44" level=info msg="💡 Light Hallway Main - Activating interval 22:00 - 23:59"
Oct 27 23:36:44 tina kelvin[1178143]: time="2024/27/10 23:36:44" level=info msg="💡 Light Entrance - Activating schedule for Oct 27 2024 (Sunrise: 07:43, Sunset: 16:23)"
Oct 27 23:36:44 tina kelvin[1178143]: time="2024/27/10 23:36:44" level=info msg="💡 Light Entrance - Activating interval 22:00 - 23:59"
Oct 27 23:36:44 tina kelvin[1178143]: time="2024/27/10 23:36:44" level=info msg="💡 Light Bedroom Main - Activating schedule for Oct 27 2024 (Sunrise: 07:43, Sunset: 16:23)"
Oct 27 23:36:44 tina kelvin[1178143]: time="2024/27/10 23:36:44" level=info msg="💡 Light Bedroom Main - Activating interval 22:00 - 23:59"
Oct 27 23:36:46 tina kelvin[1178143]: time="2024/27/10 23:36:46" level=info msg="💡 Light Bedroom Main - Light just appeared."
Oct 27 23:36:46 tina kelvin[1178143]: time="2024/27/10 23:36:46" level=info msg="💡 Light Bedroom Main - Initializing state to 1557K at 19% brightness."

If I attempt manually changing the bulb brightness now, I don't see anything in the logs. Nor do I see anything when I attempt manually changing the scene to something other than "Natural (Kelvin)", such as "Night Light".

Here is what happens if I power cycle the light now:

Oct 27 23:41:23 tina kelvin[1178143]: time="2024/27/10 23:41:23" level=info msg="💡 Light Bedroom Main - Light is no longer reachable. Clearing state..."
Oct 27 23:41:27 tina kelvin[1178143]: time="2024/27/10 23:41:27" level=info msg="💡 Light Bedroom Main - Light just appeared."
Oct 27 23:41:27 tina kelvin[1178143]: time="2024/27/10 23:41:27" level=info msg="💡 Light Bedroom Main - Initializing state to 1546K at 19% brightness

Config

{
  "version": 1,
  "bridge": {
    "ip": "<REDACTED>",
    "username": "<REDACTED>"
  },
  "location": {
    "latitude": <REDACTED>,
    "longitude": <REDACTED>
  },
  "webinterface": {
    "enabled": false,
    "port": 8080
  },
  "schedules": [
    {
      "name": "Natural",
      "associatedDeviceIDs": [
        5,
        6,
        7
      ],
      "enableWhenLightsAppear": true,
      "defaultColorTemperature": 4350,
      "defaultBrightness": 100,
      "beforeSunrise": [
        {
          "time": "0:00",
          "colorTemperature": 1300,
          "brightness": 15
        },
        {
          "time": "2:00",
          "colorTemperature": 1000,
          "brightness": 5
        },
        {
          "time": "5:00",
          "colorTemperature": 1500,
          "brightness": 10
        },
        {
          "time": "7:00",
          "colorTemperature": 6400,
          "brightness": 100
        },
        {
          "time": "10:00",
          "colorTemperature": 4350,
          "brightness": 100
        }
      ],
      "afterSunset": [
        {
          "time": "17:00",
          "colorTemperature": 2900,
          "brightness": 100
        },
        {
          "time": "20:00",
          "colorTemperature": 2250,
          "brightness": 56
        },
        {
          "time": "22:00",
          "colorTemperature": 1800,
          "brightness": 35
        },
        {
          "time": "23:59",
          "colorTemperature": 1500,
          "brightness": 15
        }
      ]
    }
  ]
}

The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:

haasn · 2024-10-27T22:49:05Z

Well, if I set it to "enableWhenLightsAppear": false,, manual changes work and "stick" (until I re-activate the Natural Kelvin scene). However, it's my understanding that in this configuration, Kelvin will not automatically take over when I power on the light.

What I want is to have a configuration where:

Powering on a light automatically enables kelvin
If I manually change a light, my change should stick until I power the bulb off again or manually re-activate the Kelvin scene

Is this not possible?

haasn · 2024-10-27T23:04:11Z

Seems to be some sort of duplicate of #70 and #62. My debug log shows the light being stuck in initialization:

DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:11] ⚙ Configuration hasn't changed. Omitting write. 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:11] 💡 Light Hallway Main - Initialization complete. Identified as Color temperature light (ModelID: 929003099101, Version: 1.93.7) 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:11] 💡 Light Entrance - Initialization complete. Identified as Color temperature light (ModelID: 929003099201, Version: 1.93.7) 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:11] 💡 Light Bedroom Main - Initialization complete. Identified as Color temperature light (ModelID: 929003823401, Version: 1.82.10) 
INFO[2024/28/10 00:02:11] 🤖 Devices found on current bridge:           
INFO[2024/28/10 00:02:11] | Name                             |  ID | On    | Dimmable | Temperature | Color | Temperature range | 
INFO[2024/28/10 00:02:11] | Hallway Main                     |   5 | false | true     | true        | false |     2200K - 6500K | 
INFO[2024/28/10 00:02:11] | Entrance                         |   6 | false | true     | true        | false |     2200K - 6500K | 
INFO[2024/28/10 00:02:11] | Bedroom Main                     |   7 | true  | true     | true        | false |     2200K - 6500K | 
INFO[2024/28/10 00:02:11] 💡 Light Hallway Main - Activating schedule for Oct 28 2024 (Sunrise: 07:45, Sunset: 16:21) 
INFO[2024/28/10 00:02:11] 💡 Light Hallway Main - Activating interval 00:00 - 02:00 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:11] 💡 Light Hallway Main - Initialized target light state for the interval 00:00 - 02:00 to {ColorTemperature:1295 Brightness:15} 
INFO[2024/28/10 00:02:11] 💡 Light Entrance - Activating schedule for Oct 28 2024 (Sunrise: 07:45, Sunset: 16:21) 
INFO[2024/28/10 00:02:11] 💡 Light Entrance - Activating interval 00:00 - 02:00 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:11] 💡 Light Entrance - Initialized target light state for the interval 00:00 - 02:00 to {ColorTemperature:1295 Brightness:15} 
INFO[2024/28/10 00:02:11] 💡 Light Bedroom Main - Activating schedule for Oct 28 2024 (Sunrise: 07:45, Sunset: 16:21) 
INFO[2024/28/10 00:02:11] 💡 Light Bedroom Main - Activating interval 00:00 - 02:00 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:11] 💡 Light Bedroom Main - Initialized target light state for the interval 00:00 - 02:00 to {ColorTemperature:1295 Brightness:15} 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:11] 🎨 Updating scenes...                         
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:11] 🎨 Updating scene "Natural (Kelvin)" for schedule "Natural"... 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:12] 🎨 Successfully updated scene "Natural (Kelvin)" 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:12] 🎨 Updating scene "Natural (Kelvin)" for schedule "Natural"... 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:12] 🎨 Successfully updated scene "Natural (Kelvin)" 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:12] 🤖 Starting cyclic update...                  
INFO[2024/28/10 00:02:13] 💡 Light Bedroom Main - Light just appeared.  
INFO[2024/28/10 00:02:13] 💡 Light Bedroom Main - Initializing state to 1295K at 15% brightness. 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:13] 💡 Light Bedroom Main - Adjusted color temperature to light capability of 2200K 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:13] 💡 HueLight Bedroom Main - Setting light state to 2200K and 15% brightness (TargetColorTemperature: 454, CurrentColorTemperature: 438, TargetColor: [0.506 0.415], CurrentColor: [], TargetBrightness: 38, CurrentBrightness: 38, TransitionTime: 4) 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:13] 💡 HueLight Bedroom Main - Light was successfully updated (TargetColorTemperature: 454, CurrentColorTemperature: 438, TargetColor: [0.506 0.415], CurrentColor: [], TargetBrightness: 38, CurrentBrightness: 38, TransitionTime: 4) 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:13] 💡 Light Bedroom Main - Light was initialized to 1295K at 15% brightness 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:13] 🤖 Light Bedroom Main - Updated light state. Awaiting transition... 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:14] 💡 Light Bedroom Main - Light in initialization for 1.114598061s (TargetColorTemperature: 454, CurrentColorTemperature: 438, TargetColor: [0.506 0.415], CurrentColor: [], TargetBrightness: 38, CurrentBrightness: 38) 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:14] 💡 HueLight Bedroom Main - Color temperature has changed! CurrentColorTemperature: 438, TargetColorTemperatur: 454 (2200K) 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:14] 💡 Light Bedroom Main - Adjusted color temperature to light capability of 2200K 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:14] 💡 HueLight Bedroom Main - Setting light state to 2200K and 15% brightness (TargetColorTemperature: 454, CurrentColorTemperature: 438, TargetColor: [0.506 0.415], CurrentColor: [], TargetBrightness: 38, CurrentBrightness: 38, TransitionTime: 4) 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:14] 💡 HueLight Bedroom Main - Light was successfully updated (TargetColorTemperature: 454, CurrentColorTemperature: 438, TargetColor: [0.506 0.415], CurrentColor: [], TargetBrightness: 38, CurrentBrightness: 38, TransitionTime: 4) 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:14] 💡 Light Bedroom Main - Adjusting light state to 1295K at 15% brightness (Initialization) 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:14] 🤖 Light Bedroom Main - Updated light state. Awaiting transition... 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:15] 💡 Light Bedroom Main - Light in initialization for 2.237177451s (TargetColorTemperature: 454, CurrentColorTemperature: 438, TargetColor: [0.506 0.415], CurrentColor: [], TargetBrightness: 38, CurrentBrightness: 38) 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:15] 💡 HueLight Bedroom Main - Color temperature has changed! CurrentColorTemperature: 438, TargetColorTemperatur: 454 (2200K) 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:15] 💡 Light Bedroom Main - Adjusted color temperature to light capability of 2200K 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:15] 💡 HueLight Bedroom Main - Setting light state to 2200K and 15% brightness (TargetColorTemperature: 454, CurrentColorTemperature: 438, TargetColor: [0.506 0.415], CurrentColor: [], TargetBrightness: 38, CurrentBrightness: 38, TransitionTime: 4) 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:15] 💡 HueLight Bedroom Main - Light was successfully updated (TargetColorTemperature: 454, CurrentColorTemperature: 438, TargetColor: [0.506 0.415], CurrentColor: [], TargetBrightness: 38, CurrentBrightness: 38, TransitionTime: 4) 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:15] 💡 Light Bedroom Main - Adjusting light state to 1295K at 15% brightness (Initialization) 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:15] 🤖 Light Bedroom Main - Updated light state. Awaiting transition... 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:16] 💡 Light Bedroom Main - Light in initialization for 3.361475147s (TargetColorTemperature: 454, CurrentColorTemperature: 438, TargetColor: [0.506 0.415], CurrentColor: [], TargetBrightness: 38, CurrentBrightness: 38) 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:16] 💡 HueLight Bedroom Main - Color temperature has changed! CurrentColorTemperature: 438, TargetColorTemperatur: 454 (2200K) 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:16] 💡 Light Bedroom Main - Adjusted color temperature to light capability of 2200K 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:16] 💡 HueLight Bedroom Main - Setting light state to 2200K and 15% brightness (TargetColorTemperature: 454, CurrentColorTemperature: 438, TargetColor: [0.506 0.415], CurrentColor: [], TargetBrightness: 38, CurrentBrightness: 38, TransitionTime: 4) 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:16] 💡 HueLight Bedroom Main - Light was successfully updated (TargetColorTemperature: 454, CurrentColorTemperature: 438, TargetColor: [0.506 0.415], CurrentColor: [], TargetBrightness: 38, CurrentBrightness: 38, TransitionTime: 4) 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:16] 💡 Light Bedroom Main - Adjusting light state to 1295K at 15% brightness (Initialization) 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:16] 🤖 Light Bedroom Main - Updated light state. Awaiting transition... 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:17] 💡 Light Bedroom Main - Light in initialization for 4.485705916s (TargetColorTemperature: 454, CurrentColorTemperature: 438, TargetColor: [0.506 0.415], CurrentColor: [], TargetBrightness: 38, CurrentBrightness: 38) 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:17] 💡 HueLight Bedroom Main - Color temperature has changed! CurrentColorTemperature: 438, TargetColorTemperatur: 454 (2200K) 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:17] 💡 Light Bedroom Main - Adjusted color temperature to light capability of 2200K 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:17] 💡 HueLight Bedroom Main - Setting light state to 2200K and 15% brightness (TargetColorTemperature: 454, CurrentColorTemperature: 438, TargetColor: [0.506 0.415], CurrentColor: [], TargetBrightness: 38, CurrentBrightness: 38, TransitionTime: 4) 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:18] 💡 HueLight Bedroom Main - Light was successfully updated (TargetColorTemperature: 454, CurrentColorTemperature: 438, TargetColor: [0.506 0.415], CurrentColor: [], TargetBrightness: 38, CurrentBrightness: 38, TransitionTime: 4) 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:18] 💡 Light Bedroom Main - Adjusting light state to 1295K at 15% brightness (Initialization) 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:18] 🤖 Light Bedroom Main - Updated light state. Awaiting transition... 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:19] 💡 Light Bedroom Main - Light in initialization for 5.608923746s (TargetColorTemperature: 454, CurrentColorTemperature: 438, TargetColor: [0.506 0.415], CurrentColor: [], TargetBrightness: 38, CurrentBrightness: 38) 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:19] 💡 HueLight Bedroom Main - Color temperature has changed! CurrentColorTemperature: 438, TargetColorTemperatur: 454 (2200K) 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:19] 💡 Light Bedroom Main - Adjusted color temperature to light capability of 2200K 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:19] 💡 HueLight Bedroom Main - Setting light state to 2200K and 15% brightness (TargetColorTemperature: 454, CurrentColorTemperature: 438, TargetColor: [0.506 0.415], CurrentColor: [], TargetBrightness: 38, CurrentBrightness: 38, TransitionTime: 4) 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:19] 💡 HueLight Bedroom Main - Light was successfully updated (TargetColorTemperature: 454, CurrentColorTemperature: 438, TargetColor: [0.506 0.415], CurrentColor: [], TargetBrightness: 38, CurrentBrightness: 38, TransitionTime: 4) 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:19] 💡 Light Bedroom Main - Adjusting light state to 1295K at 15% brightness (Initialization) 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:19] 🤖 Light Bedroom Main - Updated light state. Awaiting transition... 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:20] 💡 Light Bedroom Main - Light in initialization for 6.823214951s (TargetColorTemperature: 454, CurrentColorTemperature: 438, TargetColor: [0.506 0.415], CurrentColor: [], TargetBrightness: 38, CurrentBrightness: 38) 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:20] 💡 HueLight Bedroom Main - Color temperature has changed! CurrentColorTemperature: 438, TargetColorTemperatur: 454 (2200K) 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:20] 💡 Light Bedroom Main - Adjusted color temperature to light capability of 2200K 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:02:20] 💡 HueLight Bedroom Main - Setting light state to 2200K and 15% brightness (TargetColorTemperature: 454, CurrentColorTemperature: 438, TargetColor: [0.506 0.415], CurrentColor: [], TargetBrightness: 38, CurrentBrightness: 38, TransitionTime: 4) 

... repeating indefinitely, regardless of what I do to the light

haasn · 2024-10-27T23:26:15Z

The issue appears to be when setting color temperature values lower than what the light "actually" supports.

If I change the CCT of the current time slot to something like 4200, it works fine:

DEBU[2024/28/10 00:20:42] 💡 Light Bedroom Main - Light in initialization for 1.151873877s (TargetColorTemperature: 238, CurrentColorTemperature: 238, TargetColor: [0.374 0.379], CurrentColor: [], TargetBrightness: 35, CurrentBrightness: 35) 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:20:43] 💡 Light Bedroom Main - Light in initialization for 2.167553719s (TargetColorTemperature: 238, CurrentColorTemperature: 238, TargetColor: [0.374 0.379], CurrentColor: [], TargetBrightness: 35, CurrentBrightness: 35) 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:20:44] 💡 Light Bedroom Main - Light in initialization for 3.183106289s (TargetColorTemperature: 238, CurrentColorTemperature: 238, TargetColor: [0.374 0.379], CurrentColor: [], TargetBrightness: 35, CurrentBrightness: 35) 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:20:44] 💡 Light Bedroom Main - Ending initialization phase after 3.183176031s

It would appear to me that this light is simply misbehaving / misreporting its actual Kelvin range. If I bump the lower kelvin numbers to 2280 (experimentally determined), initialization succeeds.

haasn · 2024-10-27T23:32:08Z

For what it's worth, I tried updating the software firmware version. It now reports:

DEBU[2024/28/10 00:30:44] 💡 Light Hallway Main - Initialization complete. Identified as Color temperature light (ModelID: 929003099101, Version: 1.122.2) 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:30:44] 💡 Light Entrance - Initialization complete. Identified as Color temperature light (ModelID: 929003099201, Version: 1.122.2) 
DEBU[2024/28/10 00:30:44] 💡 Light Bedroom Main - Initialization complete. Identified as Color temperature light (ModelID: 929003823401, Version: 1.93.7)

But the exact same issue persists. It seems that this is a Hue bug with the new Tento Ambient White panels.

haasn · 2024-10-27T23:39:55Z

Now everything works:

diff --git a/huelight.go b/huelight.go
index c20609a..d9be6e9 100644
--- a/huelight.go
+++ b/huelight.go
@@ -63,7 +63,9 @@ func (light *HueLight) initialize(attr hue.LightAttributes) {
        light.SupportsXYColor = containsString(lightsSupportingXYColor, attr.Type)
 
        // set minimum color temperature depending on type
-       if attr.Type == "Color temperature light" {
+        if attr.ModelId == "929003823401" {
+               light.MinimumColorTemperature = 2280
+       } else if attr.Type == "Color temperature light" {
                light.MinimumColorTemperature = 2200
        } else if light.SupportsXYColor {
                light.MinimumColorTemperature = 1000

I don't know what to do about this. Do I have a faulty light? Or are the new Tento panels just a pile of 💩 ?

Provide feedback

Saved searches

Use saved searches to filter your results more quickly

Light doesn't respect manual change #123

Light doesn't respect manual change #123

haasn commented Oct 27, 2024

haasn commented Oct 27, 2024

haasn commented Oct 27, 2024

haasn commented Oct 27, 2024

haasn commented Oct 27, 2024

haasn commented Oct 27, 2024

Light doesn't respect manual change #123

Light doesn't respect manual change #123

Comments

haasn commented Oct 27, 2024

Log

Config

haasn commented Oct 27, 2024

haasn commented Oct 27, 2024

haasn commented Oct 27, 2024

haasn commented Oct 27, 2024

haasn commented Oct 27, 2024