-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 180
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
Burned coins vs. circulating supply #18
Comments
As you may have already deduced, the burned coins option under the For my own coin project, I figured it would be confusing to see a different supply value in the wallet vs the explorer so I chose to subtract the burned coins from the total supply in the blockchain itself. I'm not sure the best way to remedy that confusion if you were to subtract the burned coins from the supply in the explorer only, maybe by displaying 2 supply values? Real supply and Burned supply? I personally don't like it, but maybe there will be some better ideas. As far as getting the explorer to display the burned supply, I can think of a couple different ways to accomplish that:
Also, as far as burned coins being spent through some kind of hack, that would be quite the feat given that burn addresses should be provably unspendable using a special wallet address like the generic-unspendable script generates where the private key for the burn address is impossible to generate and therefore can never be spent. |
Please note that this request has been added to Exor's public task list and development will begin as soon as the funding goal has been met. View more details here: https://exor.io/task?id=4&tid=716efb051f527992b5994ed4a3801b35b35825f2 |
Bug report (of sorts???): When adding a burn address to settings.json, it does in fact create the "Burned Coins" category in the Wealth Distribution table as expected. It does not, however, remove the coins in that address from the quantity reported in the coin_supply_panel. I imagine this is by design, but would like to open a discussion at least to suggest that burned coins should be subtracted from circulating supply so long as they continue to be categorized as burned (i.e., COINBASE [in our case] minus "Burned Coins").
If somehow they get spent through hack or crack, they will wind up in some other address. And since the explorer depends on address to determine burn status, they will re-enter circulating supply automatically once a richlist-reindex is done, no? I just feel like while they are burnt, they should not count towards circulating supply. Thoughts?
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: