diff --git a/draft-ietf-uta-tls13-iot-profile.md b/draft-ietf-uta-tls13-iot-profile.md index 1e651a8..3398bf4 100644 --- a/draft-ietf-uta-tls13-iot-profile.md +++ b/draft-ietf-uta-tls13-iot-profile.md @@ -46,6 +46,14 @@ author: organization: "Sandelman Software Works" email: mcr+ietf@sandelman.ca +contributor: + - + ins: J. Sosinowicz + name: Juliusz Sosinowicz + - + ins: A. Kraus + name: Achim Kraus + normative: DTLS13: RFC9147 TLS13: RFC8446 @@ -200,11 +208,27 @@ negotiated independently. The discussion in Section 10 of {{!RFC7925}} is applicable. -# Timeouts +# Timers and ACKs + +Compared to DTLS 1.2 timeout-based whole flight retransmission, DTLS 1.3 ACKs sensibly decrease the risk of congestion collapse which was the basis for the very conservative recommendations given in Section 11 of {{!RFC7925}}. + +In general, the recommendations in {{Section 7.3 of DTLS13}} regarding ACKs apply. +In particular, "[w]hen DTLS 1.3 is used in deployments with lossy networks, such as low-power, long-range radio networks as well as low-power mesh networks, the use of ACKs is recommended" to signal any sign of disruption or lack of progress. +This allows for selective or early retransmission, which leads to more efficient use of bandwidth and memory resources. + +Due to the vast range of network technologies used in IoT deployments, from wired LAN to GSM-SMS, it's not possible to provide a universal recommendation for an initial timeout. +Therefore, it is RECOMMENDED that DTLS 1.3 implementations provide a way for their users to explicitly set the initial timer value. +Users SHOULD set the initial timeout to be twice the expected RTT but no less than 1000 ms. +A sub-second initial timeout MAY be set for specific application/network combinations +If no RTT estimates are available, 1 second is a good recommendation for the general internet. + +Therefore, it is RECOMMENDED that DTLS 1.3 implementations allow users to explicitly set the initial timer value. +Users SHOULD set the initial timeout to be twice the expected round-trip time (RTT), but no less than 1000ms. +For specific application/network combinations, a sub-second initial timeout MAY be set. +In cases where no RTT estimates are available, a 1 second initial timeout is suitable for the general Internet. -The recommendation in Section 11 of {{!RFC7925}} is applicable. In particular -this document RECOMMENDED to use an initial timer value of 9 seconds with -exponential back off up to no less then 60 seconds. +For RRC, the recommendations in {{Section 7.5 of !I-D.ietf-tls-dtls-rrc}} apply. +Just like the handshake initial timers, it is RECOMMENDED that DTLS 1.2 and 1.3 implementations offer an option for their users to explicitly set the RRC timer. # Random Number Generation @@ -750,4 +774,8 @@ This document makes no requests to IANA. # Acknowledgments {:unnumbered} -We would like to thank Ben Kaduk, Hendrik Brockhaus, John Mattsson and Michael Richardson. +We would like to thank +Ben Kaduk, +Hendrik Brockhaus, +and +John Mattsson.