Link native_main statically

[dshynkev]

Currently, native_main is dynamically linked with libc. This is almost never an issue, except for musl users like me. Now, of course, I could just shut up and build my own executables, but, fortunately, static linkage is easy enough to propose universally:

--- nim.cfg.a   2021-06-26 19:41:28.268492678 -0400
+++ nim.cfg.b   2021-06-26 19:41:36.734493221 -0400
@@ -1 +1,2 @@
 d:debug
+l:"-static"

This increases the size of the binary slightly: 484K -> 523K. It should also help with reproducibility (though I doubt there are currently issues with that).

My main reservation with proposing this is that I don't know what this does on systems that aren't Linux, e.g. macOS, where static linking is unsupported. I assume that Nim does not statically link in such cases instead of building a fragile executable.

[bovine3dom]

The CI we use makes it pretty easy to add flags per OS - so we can just do static linkage for the Linux builds.

See

native_messenger/.github/workflows/compile.yml

Line 53 in 9adba18

- run: |

and

native_messenger/.github/workflows/release.yml

Line 75 in 9adba18

- run: nimble build -d:danger -d:release --opt:speed -Y --verbose

(one day I'd like to work out how to merge these files; the duplication is silly).

A PR would be welcome - otherwise it'll just go on my (very long) todo list :)

[klardotsh]

Huge +1 to either fixing this with static linking, or providing Musl builds that are detected in the install script. I ran the install script and was trying to figure out why on earth :native still failed - then I remembered, oh right, I'm on Void Musl. nimble build and copying the resulting executable over top of ~/.local/share/tridactyl/native_main, and otherwise making no changes after what all the installer script did, worked fine.

[bovine3dom]

I think it's just a single line to change in the build scripts. I have never got round to doing it is all

with luck the blocks next release label will make it harder for me to forget about it. If you want it quicker than that, a PR would be welcome :)

[bovine3dom]

@klardotsh I finally got around to looking at this but it doesn't seem to work, the build is exactly the same size and it's saying that it's dynamically linked https://github.com/tridactyl/native_messenger/actions/runs/11202765381

Do you know what I'm doing wrong? Should I be building it statically using musl for everyone?

$ file native_main
native_main: ELF 64-bit LSB pie executable, x86-64, version 1 (SYSV), dynamically linked, interpreter /lib64/ld-linux-x86-64.so.2, BuildID[sha1]=3b7db7b0a9b8c18f8f535bb8317df090c9da8fe2, for GNU/Linux 3.2.0, not stripped