Proposals 9202-9210 (#188)

* Import distributions

Source (original): https://mailman.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/agora-official/2025-January/018236.html

Source (correction): https://mailman.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/agora-official/2025-January/018237.html

* Add voting strengths

Latest ADoP's report: https://mailman.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/agora-official/2025-January/018251.html

Latest Referee's report: https://mailman.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/agora-official/2025-January/018250.html

* Add voting block

* Initial votes by snail

Source: https://mailman.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/agora-business/2025-January/054017.html

Note: vote on 9208 fails because 9208 was not distributed at the time

* snail votes on revised P9208

Source: https://mailman.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/agora-business/2025-January/054021.html

* Initial votes by Mischief

Source: https://mailman.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/agora-business/2025-January/054022.html

Note: vote on P9208 fails because it attempts to vote on the original, failed distribution

* Initial votes by Kate

Source: https://mailman.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/agora-business/2025-January/054025.html

* Kate votes on P9208

Source: https://mailman.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/agora-business/2025-January/054026.html

* Mischief votes on P9208

Source: https://mailman.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/agora-business/2025-January/054027.html

* Initial votes by ais523

Source: https://mailman.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/agora-business/2025-January/054028.html

* Initial votes by Janet

Source: https://mailman.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/agora-business/2025-January/054029.html

* Janet votes on P9208

Source: https://mailman.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/agora-business/2025-January/054030.html

* Initial votes by sprock

Source: https://mailman.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/agora-business/2025-January/054032.html

* Initial votes by Murphy

Source: https://mailman.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/agora-business/2025-January/054034.html

* Initial votes by juan

Source: https://mailman.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/agora-business/2025-January/054036.html

* Initial votes by 4st

Source: https://mailman.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/agora-business/2025-January/054037.html

* Add url

src/main/kotlin/org/agoranomic/assessor/decisions/9202-9210.kt

@@ -0,0 +1,366 @@
+package org.agoranomic.assessor.decisions
+
+import org.agoranomic.assessor.dsl.assessment
+import org.agoranomic.assessor.dsl.receivers.ai
+import org.agoranomic.assessor.dsl.receivers.coauthors
+import org.agoranomic.assessor.dsl.receivers.quorum
+import org.agoranomic.assessor.dsl.receivers.url
+import org.agoranomic.assessor.dsl.votes.complexityBonuses
+import org.agoranomic.assessor.dsl.votes.endorse
+import org.agoranomic.assessor.dsl.votes.onOrdinaryProposals
+import org.agoranomic.assessor.lib.vote.InextricableResolvingVote
+import org.agoranomic.assessor.lib.vote.VoteKind.*
+
+@UseAssessment
+fun assessment9202to9210() = assessment {
+    name("9202-9210")
+    url("https://mailman.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/agora-official/2025-January/018259.html")
+    quorum(5)
+
+    strengths {
+        default(3)
+        min(0)
+        max(15)
+
+        onOrdinaryProposals {
+            complexityBonuses {
+                maxBonus(3)
+
+                "Absurdor"(1) heldBy juan
+                "ADoP"(2) heldBy Murphy
+                "Arbitor"(2) heldBy Kate
+                "Archivist"(1) heldBy Gaelan
+                "Assessor"(3) heldBy Janet
+                "Collector"(2) heldBy Mischief
+                "Distributor"(0) heldBy omd
+                "Geologist"(1) heldBy null
+                "Herald"(2) heldBy null
+                "Illuminator"(1) heldBy Mischief
+                "Notary"(2) heldBy null
+                "Prime Minister"(0) heldBy Mischief
+                "Promotor"(3) heldBy snail
+                "Referee"(2) heldBy ais523
+                "Registrar"(1) heldBy juan
+                "Rulekeepor"(3) heldBy Janet
+                "Speaker"(0) heldBy ais523
+                "Spendor"(1) heldBy null
+                "Tailor"(1) heldBy Murphy
+                "Webmastor"(1) heldBy null
+            }
+        }
+    }
+
+    proposals(v4) {
+        proposal(9202) {
+            title("Track Assets")
+            ai("1.0")
+            author(Murphy)
+            ordinary()
+
+            text(
+                """
+Amend Rule 2692 (Bang!) by replacing "Bangs are a fungible asset." with
+"Bangs are an untracked fungible asset."
+
+Retitle Rule 2603 (Switch Responsibility) to "Default Recordkeepors",
+and amend it by replacing "switch" with "switch or asset".
+
+[Unchanged from proto. Encourages assets intended to be untracked to be
+  explicitly labeled as such, otherwise materializes an officer, both in
+  the same fashion as switches.]"""
+            )
+        }
+
+        proposal(9203) {
+            title("A clarification")
+            ai("2.0")
+            author(Janet)
+            coauthors(ais523)
+            ordinary()
+
+            text(
+                """
+Amend Rule 991 ("Calls for Judgement") by appending the following to the
+first paragraph: "A case so initiated is an inquiry case."
+
+["inquiry case" is a historical term used for a CFJ on the truth of a
+statement. It has a few remaining uses in the rules. Defining it here
+removes any ambiguity and helps answer a question that has been asked
+multiple times by newer players. This is careful to not redefine "CFJ"
+itself, which might affect past CFJs.]"""
+            )
+        }
+
+        proposal(9204) {
+            title("Rare stamps, more differently")
+            ai("1.0")
+            author(Janet)
+            ordinary()
+
+            text(
+                """
+Amend Rule 2701 ("Stamp Scamp") to read, in whole:
+
+{
+
+A rare stamp is a stamp that is the only one of its type that exists.
+
+Stamp scamp is a singleton switch tracked by the Collector with possible
+values of each player and null (default). Upon a correct announcement
+that a specified player owns more rare stamps than any other player, the
+stamp scamp switch is flipped to that player.
+
+If no person has done so by this mechanism in this quarter, the value of
+the stamp scamp switch, if a player, CAN by announcement cause another
+specified player to gain one stamp of that player's type.
+
+}
+
+If exactly one player holds the patent title of Stamp Scamp, the stamp
+scamp switch is hereby flipped to that player.
+
+The patent title "Stamp Scamp" is hereby revoked from each player that
+holds it.
+
+[Switches are the standard way to track state like this. We shouldn't
+use a patent title for this. The current Herald is not actually
+reporting, so it will not actually be tracked; the Herald's report
+should be used for historical matters, not (new) ephemera; and it will
+hand out violet ribbons for very little reason.]"""
+            )
+        }
+
+        proposal(9205) {
+            title("Switch It Up")
+            ai("3.0")
+            author(Mischief)
+            coauthors(Janet)
+            democratic()
+
+            text(
+                """
+[This explicitly allow contracts to define switches. They maybe work
+okay anyway, but this puts things on a firmer foundation. The "secured"
+definition is deliberately left referencing Rules only, as a contract
+doesn't have power.
+
+I considered amending the third paragraph of rule 2698 (Recordkeepors),
+but contracts have plenty of flexibility to impose any desired reporting
+requirements for their switches (or to leave them untracked).]
+
+Amend rule 2162 (Switches) by making the following replacements, in order:
+
+1) Replace:
+
+       A type of switch is a property that the rules define as a switch,
+       and specify the following:
+
+    with:
+
+       A type of switch is a property that a rule or a contract defines
+       as a switch (with such rule or contract being its backing
+       document) and specifies the following:
+
+2) Replace:
+
+       If a type of switch is not explicitly designated as
+       possibly-indeterminate by the rule that defines it, and if an
+       action or set of actions would cause the value of an instance of
+       that type of switch to become indeterminate, that instance instead
+       takes on its last determinate and possible value, if any,
+       otherwise it takes on its default value.
+
+    with:
+
+       If a type of switch is not explicitly designated as
+       possibly-indeterminate by its backing document, and if an action
+       or set of actions would cause the value of an instance of that
+       type of switch to become indeterminate, that instance instead
+       takes on its last determinate and possible value, if any,
+       otherwise it takes on its default value."""
+            )
+        }
+
+        proposal(9206) {
+            title("Let Contracts Own Stamps")
+            ai("1.0")
+            author(Mischief)
+            ordinary()
+
+            text(
+                """
+Amend rule 2659 (Stamps) by replacing:
+
+       Stamps are a category of asset ownable by players.
+
+with:
+
+       Stamps are a category of asset ownable by players and contracts."""
+            )
+        }
+
+        proposal(9207) {
+            title("(n/a)")
+            ai("1.0")
+            author(Forest)
+            ordinary()
+
+            text(
+                """
+{Any report that contains this text contains no game actions, disclaimers
+and text to the contrary notwithstanding.}"""
+            )
+        }
+
+        proposal(9208) {
+            title("Destroy the Office")
+            ai("1.0")
+            author(Forest)
+            democratic()
+
+            text(
+                """
+Amend Crystals (Rule 2685) by replacing:
+"The Geologist is a sortitioned office that tracks crystals."
+with:
+"Crystals are untracked."
+and replacing:
+"Once a quarter, the Geologist CAN (and SHALL during its first
+      Eastman week) publish a Notice of Crystal Growth, upon which each
+      crystal whose identity is not equal to the ID of any rule in the
+      current ruleset has its size increased by 3."
+with:
+"At the beginning of each quarter, all crystals whose identity is not equal
+to the ID of any rule in the current ruleset has its size increased by 3."
+
+If this proposal is democratic, repeal Crystals (Rule 2685)."""
+            )
+        }
+
+        proposal(9209) {
+            title("Goblins?")
+            ai("1.0")
+            author(Forest)
+            ordinary()
+
+            text(
+                """
+Yes."""
+            )
+        }
+
+        proposal(9210) {
+            title("Gnomes?")
+            ai("1.0")
+            author(Forest)
+            ordinary()
+
+            text(
+                """
+Yes."""
+            )
+        }
+    }
+
+    voting {
+        votes(snail) {
+            FOR on 9202
+            FOR on 9203
+            FOR on 9204
+            FOR on 9205
+            PRESENT on 9206
+            AGAINST on 9207
+            AGAINST on 9208
+            AGAINST on 9209
+            AGAINST on 9210
+        }
+
+        votes(Mischief) {
+            FOR on 9202
+            FOR on 9203
+            FOR on 9204
+            FOR on 9205
+            FOR on 9206
+            AGAINST on 9207
+            FOR on 9208
+            FOR on 9209
+            FOR on 9210
+        }
+
+        votes(Kate) {
+            FOR on 9202
+            FOR on 9203
+            AGAINST on 9204
+            FOR on 9205
+            FOR on 9206
+            AGAINST on 9207
+            FOR on 9208
+            AGAINST on 9209
+            AGAINST on 9210
+        }
+
+        votes(ais523) {
+            FOR on 9202
+            FOR on 9203
+            AGAINST on 9204
+            PRESENT on 9205
+            FOR on 9206
+            AGAINST on 9207
+            FOR on 9208
+            AGAINST on 9209
+            AGAINST on 9210
+        }
+
+        votes(Janet) {
+            FOR on 9202
+            FOR on 9203
+            FOR on 9204
+            endorse(ais523) on 9205
+            AGAINST on 9206
+            AGAINST on 9207
+            FOR on 9208
+            AGAINST on 9209
+            AGAINST on 9210
+        }
+
+        votes(sprock) {
+            PRESENT on 9202
+            FOR on 9203
+            PRESENT on 9204
+            FOR on 9205
+            FOR on 9206
+            AGAINST on 9207
+            PRESENT on 9208
+            PRESENT on 9209
+            PRESENT on 9210
+        }
+
+        votes(Murphy) {
+            FOR on 9202
+            FOR on 9203
+            endorse(Mischief) on 9204 comment "${Mischief.name} is the Collector"
+            FOR on 9205
+            FOR on 9206
+            AGAINST on 9207
+            InextricableResolvingVote on 9208 comment "Geologist is vacant"
+            FOR on 9209
+            FOR on 9210
+        }
+
+        votes(juan) {
+            PRESENT on 9202
+            FOR on 9203
+            PRESENT on 9204
+            FOR on 9205
+            FOR on 9206
+            FOR on 9207
+            endorse(Forest) on 9208
+            FOR on 9209
+            FOR on 9210
+        }
+
+        votes(Forest) {
+            FOR on all
+        }
+    }
+}