-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 101
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
Add ZOMBIE test coin warning #589
Conversation
sync master
add alternative params source
sync master
sync master
sync beta
sync beta
sync beta
sync master
sync beta [0.7.2]
sync master [0.7.2]
[release] v0.8.0
src/komodo_utils.cpp
Outdated
@@ -1549,17 +1549,21 @@ void komodo_args(char *argv0) | |||
if ( !chainName.isKMD() ) | |||
{ | |||
BITCOIND_RPCPORT = GetArg("-rpcport", ASSETCHAINS_RPCPORT); | |||
IS_KOMODO_TESTNODE = GetArg("-testnode",0); |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
You should be able to remove this line entirely. It should already be set above this.
The IS_KOMODO_TESTNODE flag actually allows that you can mine blocks on an isolated node, without peers (so in that case you probably can't buy coins anyway) |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
I guess it's better to use &&
instead of alternate token and
:
else if ( chainName.isSymbol("ZOMBIE") && IS_KOMODO_TESTNODE )
instead of
else if ( chainName.isSymbol("ZOMBIE") and IS_KOMODO_TESTNODE )
And can someone explain to me the logic we are trying to implement here? If the chain is ZOMBIE
, we allowing the -ac_private
parameter as in PIRATE and display a warning? And what if someone launches ZOMBIE with -ac_name=ZOMBIE -ac_private=1
but without -testnode
?
May be we should implement this condition more clear, like (just an offer):
if (chainName.isSymbol("PIRATE") && ASSETCHAINS_HALVING[0] == 77777) {
ASSETCHAINS_HALVING[0] *= 5;
fprintf(stderr, "PIRATE halving changed to %d %.1f days ASSETCHAINS_LASTERA.%llu\n", (int32_t)ASSETCHAINS_HALVING[0], (double)ASSETCHAINS_HALVING[0] / 1440, (long long)ASSETCHAINS_LASTERA);
} else if (ASSETCHAINS_PRIVATE != 0) {
if (chainName.isSymbol("ZOMBIE") {
fprintf(stderr, "TEST COIN, DO NOT BUY\n");
} else {
fprintf(stderr, "-ac_private for a non-PIRATE chain is not supported. The only reason to have an -ac_private chain is for total privacy and that is best achieved with the largest anon set. PIRATE has that and it is recommended to just use PIRATE\n");
StartShutdown();
}
}
Or may be even like:
if (chainName.isSymbol("PIRATE") && ASSETCHAINS_HALVING[0] == 77777) {
ASSETCHAINS_HALVING[0] *= 5;
fprintf(stderr, "PIRATE halving changed to %d %.1f days ASSETCHAINS_LASTERA.%llu\n", (int32_t)ASSETCHAINS_HALVING[0], (double)ASSETCHAINS_HALVING[0] / 1440, (long long)ASSETCHAINS_LASTERA);
}
std::set<std::string> allowedPrivateOnly = {"PIRATE", "ZOMBIE"};
if (ASSETCHAINS_PRIVATE != 0 && allowedPrivateOnly.find(chainName.ToString()) == allowedPrivateOnly.end()) {
fprintf(stderr, "-ac_private for a non-PIRATE chain is not supported. The only reason to have an -ac_private chain is for total privacy and that is best achieved with the largest anon set. PIRATE has that and it is recommended to just use PIRATE\n");
StartShutdown();
}
[release] v0.8.1 [Falkor]
[release] v0.8.1 [Falkor]
The discussion seems to have come to a standstill, so I am closing it. Additionally, the changes made in this PR only introduce one new message that is printed in |
@DeckerSU I'm reopening this one, as it does one thing else beyond adding the log message - it avoids progressing into the next conditional which allows running ZOMBIE without needing a special branch, so that when testing z_* methods in other PRs we can use it instead of PIRATE. I'm happy to change the approach of how this is achieved - your second suggestion looks nice so I'll go with that. |
Could you please remind me of the specific arguments / command line parameters for the p.s. Never mind. I have submitted a new pull request with an improved solution. Once it is approved, this can be closed. |
Better solution for the issues mentioned in #589 .
Better solution for the issue(s) mentioned in KomodoPlatform/komodo#589 . - KomodoPlatform/komodo#615
Closed because #615 was accepted. |
The ZOMBIE electrum and lightwalletd services have been running on a komodod built from the https://github.com/KomodoPlatform/komodo/tree/ARRR-HTLC-debug branch. In consultation with Alright, it was determined that only the changes in this PR are needed to bring ZOMBIE back into alignment with the main/dev branch.