collect the base fee instead of burning it #5

mycodecrafting · 2024-05-02T16:26:12Z

EIP-1559 burns the base fee. This doesn't make sense for rollups. The set fee recipient should collect it.

joroshiba

Approved assuming answer to my question is yes.

joroshiba · 2024-05-02T17:36:39Z

core/state_transition.go

@@ -458,6 +458,13 @@ func (st *StateTransition) TransitionDb() (*ExecutionResult, error) {
 		fee := new(big.Int).SetUint64(st.gasUsed())
 		fee.Mul(fee, effectiveTip)
 		st.state.AddBalance(st.evm.Context.Coinbase, fee)
+
+		// collect base fee instead of burn
+		if rules.IsLondon && st.evm.Context.Coinbase.Cmp(common.Address{}) != 0 {


Is the coinbase context set by the feeRecipient on payload params?

yeah it's set here: https://github.com/astriaorg/astria-geth/blob/main/miner/payload_building.go#L186
called by the miner here: https://github.com/astriaorg/astria-geth/blob/main/miner/miner.go#L244
and that's what the exec grpc server calls

This PR fixes all the failing tests in the astria-geth repo apart from the [`TestReimportMirroredState` ](https://github.com/astriaorg/astria-geth/blob/f5a95fe13d581ae1ec67caeaae6efe5338399a3e/consensus/clique/clique_test.go#L44) (More details at the end) The main reasons for the tests failing were: 1. #5 which transfers the basefee to the fee recipient rather than burning it. This caused all the tests which expect a certain state root to fail since they assume that the basefee would be burnt. It also failed tests which check for the balance of the fee recipient which fails because we also have to account for the base fee. To fix them, we replaced the tests with the expected state root and updated the tests with the expected balance of the fee recipient. 2. Picking txs from the `AstriaOrdered` rather than from the geth mempool. Lot of tests place the txs in the Geth mempool and they end up failing as we do not pick txx from their. To fix this, we had to add these txs to the `AstriaOrdered` mempool instead This PR also adds a github action to run the tests. `TestReimportMirroredState` is very tricky to fix since the fee recipient while building the block and while verifying the block before inserting onchain is different. This is because while verifying the block, we pick the fee recipient from the consensus engine's author which in this case is the signer of the block. It's tricker to fix it and we have commented it out for now.

* add buf config and generated grpc code * poc e2e grpc communication * comment out panicking code * logging help * now reads cli args. now stops grpc server on shutdown. * add mutex to GRPCServerHandler update readme containerize w/ github action to build and push to ghcr (#3) fix gh action syntax (#4) * containerize w/ github action to build and push to ghcr * fix gh action yml syntax * enable manual trigger * fix syntax build and push manually (#5) * containerize w/ github action to build and push to ghcr * fix gh action yml syntax * enable manual trigger * fix syntax * dont use github action, do it ourselves * push manually Feature/containerize (#6) * containerize w/ github action to build and push to ghcr * fix gh action yml syntax * enable manual trigger * fix syntax * dont use github action, do it ourselves * push manually * correct multi line update SubmitTransaction to send tx to metro ethclient: ensure returned subscription is nil on error (#26976) core/state, trie: remove Try prefix in Trie accessors (#26975) This change renames StateTrie methods to remove the Try* prefix. We added the Trie methods with prefix 'Try' a long time ago, working around the problem that most existing methods of Trie did not return the database error. This weird naming convention has persisted until now. Co-authored-by: Gary Rong <[email protected]> metrics/librato: ensure resp.body closed (#26969) This change ensures that we call Close on a http response body, in various places in the source code (mostly tests) core/vm: use atomic.Bool (#26951) Make use of new atomic types --------- Co-authored-by: Felix Lange <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Martin Holst Swende <[email protected]> core/bloombits: use atomic type (#26993) core/state: use atomic.Bool (#26992) graphql: fix data races (#26965) Fixes multiple data races caused by the fact that resolving fields are done concurrently by the graphql library. It also enforces caching at the stateobject level for account fields. eth/tracers/native: prevent panic for LOG edge-cases (#26848) This PR fixes OOM panic in the callTracer as well as panicing on opcode validation errors (e.g. stack underflow) in callTracer and prestateTracer. Co-authored-by: Martin Holst Swende <[email protected]> internal/debug: add log.logfmt flag to set logging to use logfmt (#26970) docs: update outdated DeriveSha docs comment (#26968) add localnet genesis update metro-transactions dep Adding features to mempool to support our pre-ordered txs (#2) * Adding features to mempool to support our pre-ordered txs * Add framing for gRPC to execute blocks * Remove public engine API call * Fix circular dependencies * Updated to use new Init, and fill out starting attributes * Add clear astriaordered, cleanup * readme fix * add bash and jq to final docker image * make txpool interface * no more panics, update DoBlock to also update state + store block * cleanup * set post-merge at genesis * cleanup * doc update * remove txpool interface changes * cleanup * cleanup * build and push images wih tags defined by git tags * build for multiple architectures. use docker-metadata action for semver * add push: true * only build arm for git tags/releases --------- Co-authored-by: Jesse Snyder <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: elizabeth <[email protected]> tag image with latest for builds from astria branch (#8) rename state_root to block_hash use FROM --platform=$BUILDPLATFORM to build arm images correctly (#9) use v4 of build and push action (#10) * use FROM --platform=$BUILDPLATFORM to build arm images correctly * use v4 of docker build and push fix arm builds. only build arm for tags and merges to default branch. (#12) * fix arm builds. only build arm for tags and merges to default branch. * fix gh action function syntax * more correct comment * build for semver tags Features and fixes needed for contract deployment test (#13) * add and remove tx from geth mempool so forge can deploy a contract * pass metro addr and port by flag * fixes from pr feedback * formatting implement FinalizeBlock gRPC call bump metro-transactions dep Update Protos (#16) * uses new protos * remove old protos update deps update deps no more unknown/unknown image (#19) * no more unknown/unknown image * hardcode condition Changing from prev_state_root to prev_block_hash remove metro integrate submission to sequencer log updates use env vars for chain id/tendermint endpoint rename to cometbft Make the environment variables actually work cleaner simple logging change removed sleep before getPayload by removing goroutine in buildPayload removed unneeded comment removed for loop from buildPayload Remove direct sequencer submission cleanup go.mod Migrate to the v1alpha1 API Missed pieces set genesis block as head/safe/final remove all mentions of metro Initial implementation of Execution v1alpha2 api Integrate updates remove need for consensus api Updates small updates Update grpc/execution/server.go Co-authored-by: noot <[email protected]> logging remove unused dependency Mark the chain 'finalized' on startup