Skip to content

Commit

Permalink
typos
Browse files Browse the repository at this point in the history
  • Loading branch information
forero committed Jul 17, 2017
1 parent ad656f1 commit 1d0749f
Showing 1 changed file with 12 additions and 12 deletions.
24 changes: 12 additions & 12 deletions paper/referee.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -2,18 +2,17 @@ We thank the referee for a detailed set of comments that allowed us to
greatly improve the quality of the paper.

In this new version the most important change is in the discussion of
our results (which remain unchanged). We now discard the possible
influence of a supermassive black hole and favor instead a picture
where Tololo1244-277 has similar structural characteristics as
observed dwarf ellipticals.
our results. We now discard the possible influence of a supermassive
black hole and favor instead a picture where Tololo1244-277 has similar
structural characteristics as observed dwarf ellipticals.

This opens up instead the puzzle as to why an isolated star-forming
compact dwarf galaxy could have similar structura characteristics as a
compact dwarf galaxy could have similar structural characteristics as a
quiescent red dwarf galaxy found only in galaxy clusters. This
potential evolutionary link still depends on observational
confirmation of the velocity dispersion in Tololo124-277.

A new test using random forets classifiers (as a new Appendix) allowed
A new test using random forest classifiers (as a new Appendix) allowed
us to improve our discussion about the limitations of our method.
We have also included an explicit plot on the integrated mass profile
for dark matter halos consistent with Tololo's constraints.
Expand Down Expand Up @@ -86,7 +85,7 @@ This helped us to realize that Tololo is closer to the sizes and
luminosities of dwarf ellipticals than UCDs'.
The velocity dispersions observed in DE match the results of our
multiphase model.
Furthermore, the dynamical modelling that has been already performed
Furthermore, the dynamical modeling that has been already performed
on DE's allows us to put improve our constrains on the dark matter
halo mass required to match the kinematics, discarding the need for a
supermassive black hole.
Expand Down Expand Up @@ -158,8 +157,8 @@ readers who like to have all the more relevant information "handy".

Reply. We have inlcuded a reference to the paper that presented the
detailed imaging results for Tololo. We have also included more
details on the intrumentation characteristics behind all the
observations we report.
details on the instrumentation characteristics behind the
lya spectral observations.

2) The introduction of the idealized multiphase model (first sentence
of Sec. 3.1) needs a reference. This model uses clumps with random
Expand Down Expand Up @@ -220,10 +219,11 @@ line is produced. For example, there could be more than one
kinematical component in the interstellar medium producing such a
feature. This needs to be better justified/explained.

Reply. We have included a comment on the physical intution that explains
Reply. We have included a comment on the physical intuition that explains
the results for the rotation model (Based on our previous published
results in Garavito-Camargo et al 2014). We also explain that our approach is not designed
to reject the existence of different models that reproduce the
observed features in Tololo-1214, but insted focuses on the existence
of two physically motivated models that are suceessful in providing a
observed features in Tololo-1214, but instead focuses on the existence
of two physically motivated models that are successful in providing a
solution for the first time in the literature.

0 comments on commit 1d0749f

Please sign in to comment.