PR 763

src/preprint-changes.xsl

@@ -978,7 +978,7 @@
 
     <!-- Fixes mistagged preprints -->
      <xsl:template xml:id="find-and-tag-preprint-refs" mode="mixed-citation-round-4" match="mixed-citation">
-         <xsl:variable name="preprint-regex" select="'^(biorxiv|africarxiv|arxiv|cell\s+sneak\s+peak|chemrxiv|chinaxiv|eartharxiv|medrxiv|osf\s+preprints|paleorxiv|peerj\s+preprints|preprints|preprints\.org|psyarxiv|research\s+square|scielo\s+preprints|ssrn|vixra)$'"/>
+         <xsl:variable name="preprint-regex" select="'^(biorxiv|africarxiv|arxiv|cell\s+sneak\s+peak|chemrxiv|chinaxiv|eartharxiv|medrxiv|osf\s+preprints|paleorxiv|peerj\s+preprints|preprints|preprints\.org|psyarxiv|research\s+square|scielo\s+preprints|ssrn|vixra|ecoevorxiv)$'"/>
          <xsl:copy>
             <xsl:choose>
                 <xsl:when test="@publication-type!='preprint' and matches(lower-case(source[1]),$preprint-regex)">

src/rp-schematron-base.sch

@@ -184,6 +184,14 @@
        <report test="matches(lower-case($article-text),'biorend[eo]r')" 
         role="warning" 
         id="biorender-check">Article text contains a reference to bioRender. Any figures created with bioRender should include a sentence in the caption in the format: "Created with BioRender.com/{figure-code}".</report>
+
+        <assert test="sub-article[@article-type='editor-report']" 
+          role="error" 
+          id="no-assessment">A Reviewed Preprint must have an eLife Assessment, but this one does not.</assert>
+
+        <assert test="sub-article[@article-type='referee-report']" 
+          role="error" 
+          id="no-public-review">A Reviewed Preprint must have at least one Public Review, but this one does not.</assert>
 
         <report test="$is-revised-rp and not(sub-article[@article-type='author-comment'])" 
         role="warning" 
@@ -749,6 +757,12 @@
           role="warning" 
           id="mixed-citation-person-group-flag-2"><name/> in reference (id=<value-of select="ancestor::ref/@id"/>) does not have an author person-group. Is that correct?</assert>
      </rule>
+
+      <rule context="mixed-citation/*" id="mixed-citation-child-checks">
+        <report test="not(*) and (normalize-space(.)='')" 
+          role="error" 
+          id="mixed-citation-child-1"><name/> in reference (id=<value-of select="ancestor::ref/@id"/>) is empty, which cannot be correct.</report>
+      </rule>
     </pattern>
 
     <pattern id="back">

src/rp-schematron.sch

@@ -162,6 +162,10 @@
         <let name="rp-version" value="replace(descendant::article-meta[1]/article-id[@specific-use='version'][1],'^.*\.','')"/>
 
        <report test="matches(lower-case($article-text),'biorend[eo]r')" role="warning" id="biorender-check">[biorender-check] Article text contains a reference to bioRender. Any figures created with bioRender should include a sentence in the caption in the format: "Created with BioRender.com/{figure-code}".</report>
+
+        <assert test="sub-article[@article-type='editor-report']" role="error" id="no-assessment">[no-assessment] A Reviewed Preprint must have an eLife Assessment, but this one does not.</assert>
+
+        <assert test="sub-article[@article-type='referee-report']" role="error" id="no-public-review">[no-public-review] A Reviewed Preprint must have at least one Public Review, but this one does not.</assert>
 
         <report test="$is-revised-rp and not(sub-article[@article-type='author-comment'])" role="warning" id="no-author-response-1">[no-author-response-1] Revised Reviewed Preprint (version <value-of select="$rp-version"/>) does not have an author response, which is unusual. Is that correct?</report>
 
@@ -443,7 +447,9 @@
         <report test="*[name()=$name-elems]" role="error" id="mixed-citation-person-group-flag-1">[mixed-citation-person-group-flag-1] <name/> in reference (id=<value-of select="ancestor::ref/@id"/>) has child name elements (<value-of select="string-join(distinct-values(*[name()=$name-elems]/name()),'; ')"/>). These all need to be placed in a person-group element with the appropriate person-group-type attribute.</report>
 
         <assert test="person-group[@person-group-type='author']" role="warning" id="mixed-citation-person-group-flag-2">[mixed-citation-person-group-flag-2] <name/> in reference (id=<value-of select="ancestor::ref/@id"/>) does not have an author person-group. Is that correct?</assert>
-     </rule></pattern>
+     </rule></pattern><pattern id="mixed-citation-child-checks-pattern"><rule context="mixed-citation/*" id="mixed-citation-child-checks">
+        <report test="not(*) and (normalize-space(.)='')" role="error" id="mixed-citation-child-1">[mixed-citation-child-1] <name/> in reference (id=<value-of select="ancestor::ref/@id"/>) is empty, which cannot be correct.</report>
+      </rule></pattern>
 
     <pattern id="back-tests-pattern"><rule context="back" id="back-tests">