I believe we need to be able to get the torques from ign-physics first, see gazebosim/gz-physics#124.

@chapulina Thanks for the fast reply! The issue seems a little inactive for some time. Is there anyway we can help this happen?

I believe the same reply applies here 😅 gazebosim/gz-sensors#25 (comment)

If you're willing to get this rolling before we get to it, you could try prototyping Gazebo classic's approach into Ignition Physics. It's not that many lines of code. We're just busy with other priorities right now.

That's reasonable thanks!

I believe this is still an issue. I have a joint with a JointController in velocity mode and this is what I get from the JointStatePublisher:

joint {
  name: "joint"
  id: 4
  parent: "first_link"
  child: "second_link"
  pose {
    position {
    }
    orientation {
      w: 1
    }
  }
  axis1 {
    xyz {
      y: 1
    }
    limit_lower: -3.14
    limit_upper: 3.14
    position: 1.216194800124363e-08
    velocity: 5.1744987370740463e-10
  }
}

I'd expect to see effort here as well or am I wrong? Changing the mode of the controller to force does not change things.

I believe this is still an issue. I have a joint with a JointController in velocity mode and this is what I get from the JointStatePublisher:

joint {
  name: "joint"
  id: 4
  parent: "first_link"
  child: "second_link"
  pose {
    position {
    }
    orientation {
      w: 1
    }
  }
  axis1 {
    xyz {
      y: 1
    }
    limit_lower: -3.14
    limit_upper: 3.14
    position: 1.216194800124363e-08
    velocity: 5.1744987370740463e-10
  }
}

I'd expect to see effort here as well or am I wrong? Changing the mode of the controller to force does not change things.

I see code in JointStatePublisher that copies data from any existing JointForce components into the msgs::Joint before publishing. Nothing about efforts will appear when echoing the topic if the values are precisely zero since this version of protobuf only shows non-zero values.

I think the underlying issue is that I don't see any system in gz-sim that writes data to a JointForce component.

I think the underlying issue is that I don't see any system in gz-sim that writes data to a JointForce component.

Not sure if it is relevant, but putting a JointForceTorque sensor does show the expected forces/torques on a joint, but that's different from the effort the joint is exerting itself.

Hallo, I have met the same problem. Is here any solution?

I have read the discussion in gazebosim/gz-physics#143 and #952.
Any updates on this topic?
I have actually modified the file Physics.cc in order to update the components::JointForce but still I am unable to obtain the data regarding the efforts. Is this related to the physics engine that is used (i.e. Dart, Bullet, Bullet-featherstone)?