Skip to content

Demonstration of dependency problems within the MS Graph and MSAL libraries

License

Notifications You must be signed in to change notification settings

liebichw/msgraph-dependency-problems-demo

Repository files navigation

Overview

This is a demonstration solution which shows the dependency problems you get as a plugin writer whose plugin uses MS Graph and Microsoft Authentification Library (MSAL).

The solution consists of 3 parts.

common

This is a DLL which contains common interfaces, and nothing else. The purpose of this project is to give both the executable and the plugin implementation a common type system.

The critical parts in this project are:

  • IPluginFactory is the interface for a component which is used to create a plugin instance.
  • IPlugin is the interface for the plugin itself. This interface covers some minimal parts of the features offered by MS Graph which are used by me "real life" plugin.
  • Some data holder structures with no further logic.

TestMSTeams

This is the executable which really loads the plugin dynamically during runtime and uses it afterwards. This project has no direct dependeny to MS Graph and to MSAL - it only uses the interfaces defined in the common project.

The Program is a WPF program with a rather simple UI. It is fully controlled by environment variables, and uses those variables to load the plugin. Following environment variables are used by this project:

  • TENANT_ID is a required variable containing the Azure Tenant ID.
  • CLIENT_ID is a required variable containing the clientID of the program accessing MS Graph - it is also created by Azure.
  • USE_PROXY is an optional boolean valued variable telling the program is a proxy should be used or not. This variable is per default false, and if a proxy is used, this environment variable must contain the string "true" (case sensitive).
  • REDIRECT_URL is an optional string variable containing the "redirect URL" registered for this application in Azure. The default value for this value is "http://localhost"
  • PLUGIN_PATH contains the full path name where the plugin DLL (and it's dependant DLLs) are copied into. I found out that it is best to just copy everything into 1 directory (executable and all DLLs from the project and the plugin) and use this path as the plugin path. WANRING: The plugin DLL filename must be the last part of this environment variable!
  • PLUGIN_FACTORY contains the full type name of the concrete factory class used. For this example, the value must be pluginimpl.PluginMsGraph5Factory.

Helper scripts

The script mk-setup.ps1 can be run after a full rebuild of the solution. It copies everything needed into the directory Setup. That's all it does - it sets up a usable directory structure.

The script run-program.ps1 can be run afterwards - it sets the needed environment variables, and runs the executable. Attention: Before using this run-program.ps1 script, you must first set the environment variables mentioned above to values which are valid for your setup!

Result of the test run

The executable will start fine, but trying to log in to teams will show an exception, because of missing DLLs - and a closer look will show that the "missing DLL" is in fact there, but with another version than expected by some other DLL. And because the DLL is dynamically loaded, Visual Studio does not generate a correct application config file - and even if it would do that, it would not help us much, because we need to get by without having to modify the original app config file due to administrative reasons.

About

Demonstration of dependency problems within the MS Graph and MSAL libraries

Resources

License

Stars

Watchers

Forks

Releases

No releases published

Packages

No packages published