Feature/crq 060 emacs config study #24
Conversation
## Change Request: Standardize Pre-commit Hooks for All Submodules ### Objective To implement a standardized and automated system for managing Git pre-commit hooks across all project submodules, with an initial focus on integrating `shellcheck` for shell script quality assurance. ### Description Currently, Git pre-commit hooks are managed on a per-repository basis, leading to potential inconsistencies in code quality enforcement, especially within submodules. This CRQ proposes a solution to centralize the management of pre-commit hooks, ensuring that all submodules automatically inherit and enforce project-wide code quality standards. The initial implementation will focus on: 1. **Centralized Template:** Creating a single, authoritative template for the pre-commit hook in the main repository. 2. **Automated Deployment:** Developing a mechanism (e.g., a script) to automatically deploy and update this pre-commit hook to all existing and newly added submodules. 3. **`shellcheck` Integration:** The initial standardized hook will include `shellcheck` to enforce best practices and identify common errors in shell scripts before they are committed. 4. **Documentation:** Providing clear Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs) for the setup, maintenance, and usage of these standardized hooks. ### Expected Outcome * Consistent application of code quality checks (starting with `shellcheck`) across all submodules. * Reduced manual effort in setting up and maintaining pre-commit hooks in individual submodules. * Improved overall code quality and fewer shell scripting errors in the codebase. * Clear documentation for developers on how pre-commit hooks are managed. ### Justification/Benefit * **Enhanced Code Quality:** Proactive identification and prevention of shell scripting issues at the commit stage. * **Increased Efficiency:** Automates a previously manual and error-prone process, saving developer time. * **Improved Consistency:** Ensures all parts of the codebase adhere to the same quality standards. * **Easier Onboarding:** New contributors will automatically benefit from established quality checks without manual setup. ### Dependencies * Availability of `shellcheck` in the development environment (to be addressed in related Nix configurations). * Git submodule functionality. * Agreement on the content of the centralized pre-commit hook template. * The `SOP_Standardize_Submodule_Precommit_Hooks.md` document.
Restructured the `agent_comms_analysis` tools for improved organization and efficiency. - Updated `Cargo.toml` to reflect the new path of `response_analyzer`. - Enhanced `mirror_pr_to_fs.sh` for flexible output directories and robust CRQ ID extraction. - Simplified `process_all_crq_branches.sh` by delegating branch handling and centralizing data collection into `analysis_data/`.
This commit introduces a suite of tools and documentation to streamline CRQ management and enhance the CRQ classification process.
Key changes include:
- **CRQ Parser (`crq-parser`):** Developed a Rust-based CLI tool for classifying individual CRQs.
- **CRQ Table Generator (`crq_table_generator`):** Developed a Rust-based CLI tool to generate a summary table of all CRQs, grouped by suggested next steps. This tool was added to the workspace.
- **Enhanced CRQ Classification:** The `crq_table_generator`'s parser was improved to handle various CRQ formats and includes new classification logic:
- `CoderabbitAI Review`: For smaller CRQs (under 2500 bytes).
- `Respond To / Our Turn`: For CRQs requiring human attention, strategic input, or clarification (based on keywords).
- **Shell Scripts:** Created `classify_crq.sh`, `generate_crq_summary.sh`, and `new_crq.sh` to automate CRQ-related workflows.
- **Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs):** Documented the usage of new tools with `SOP_Using_CRQ_Classifier.md`, `SOP_Generating_CRQ_Report.md`, and `SOP_Creating_New_CRQ.md`.
- **New CRQ:** Created `CRQ-055-enhance-crq-parser-for-coderabbitai-skipped-reviews.md` to track future enhancements for handling CoderabbitAI skipped reviews.
- **Updated `task.md`:** Added CRQ-54 (Deterministic CRQ Parser) to the task list.
**Problem/Goal:**
To enhance the `crq_parser` within the `crq_table_generator` project to automatically identify CRQs where CoderabbitAI has skipped an automated review, and classify them as requiring a manual review request to CoderabbitAI.
**Proposed Solution:**
1. **New `NextStep` Variant:**
* Add `RequestCoderabbitAIReview` to the `NextStep` enum in `crq_parser.rs`.
2. **`crq_parser.rs` Modifications:**
* **New Function: `check_coderabbitai_comms(crq_id: &str) -> bool`**
* This function will check communication logs for a given `crq_id`.
* It will construct the path to CoderabbitAI responses (e.g., `analysis_data/comms/git/coderabbitai/{crq_id}/responses/`).
* It will read file content and search for keywords/patterns indicating a skipped review (e.g., "Review skipped", "Auto reviews are disabled").
* It will return `true` if a skipped review message is found, `false` otherwise.
* **Modify `determine_next_step(crq_content: &str, crq_id: &str) -> NextStep`**
* The function will accept `crq_id` as an additional argument.
* The classification logic will be updated:
1. **CoderabbitAI Review (Size-based):** (Existing rule) If content size < 2500 bytes, classify as `CoderabbitAIReview`.
2. **Request CoderabbitAI Review (Comms-based):** (NEW RULE) If `check_coderabbitai_comms(crq_id)` returns `true`, classify as `RequestCoderabbitAIReview`. This rule takes precedence over general "Respond To / Our Turn".
3. **Respond To / Our Turn:** (Existing rule) If neither of above, and CRQ contains relevant keywords, classify as `RespondTo`.
4. **Develop/Refactor/Document/Unknown:** (Existing rules) Fallback if no other specific classification applies.
3. **`main.rs` Modifications:**
* **Extract `crq_id`:** Extract CRQ ID from filename and pass to `determine_next_step`.
* **Update `match` statement:** Add a new case for `NextStep::RequestCoderabbitAIReview` for display.
**Justification/Impact:**
This enhancement will make the `crq_parser` more intelligent and context-aware by incorporating external communication context into its classification decisions. It will automate the identification of CRQs that require manual intervention to trigger a CoderabbitAI review, improving workflow efficiency and ensuring that skipped reviews are addressed proactively.
**Progress Update (2025-09-11):**
The core implementation of the proposed solution has been completed and integrated into the `crq_table_generator`. This includes:
* Refined `NextStep` enum with new states: `ReviewProvided`, `ReviewSkipped (No Meaningful Response)`, `ReviewNeeded from CoderabbitAI`, and `Respond To / Our Turn`.
* Implementation of `check_coderabbitai_comms` to analyze communication logs for skipped reviews and meaningful responses.
* Updated `determine_next_step` with a prioritized state machine logic, incorporating n-gram analysis and communication log data.
* The `crq_table_generator` now produces a detailed report reflecting these new classifications.
This phase of the CRQ is considered complete. Further work will be tracked under new CRQs, such as `CRQ-046-crq-classification-via-comms-analysis-and-state-machine.md` for more advanced comms analysis.
…e machine logic This commit integrates the `crq_table_generator` Rust project into the main workspace and implements the new state machine logic for CRQ classification. Key changes include: - Added `crq_table_generator` to the workspace members in `Cargo.toml`. - Implemented `ReviewProvided`, `ReviewSkipped (No Meaningful Response)`, and `ReviewNeeded from CoderabbitAI` states in `crq_table_generator/src/crq_parser.rs`. - Refined `determine_next_step` to use n-gram analysis and communication log data for classification. - Updated `crq_table_generator/src/main.rs` to display the new classification states. - Created `CRQ-046-crq-classification-via-comms-analysis-and-state-machine.md` to outline future work on advanced comms analysis.
This commit updates the Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs) to reflect the new CRQ classification states and the enhanced capabilities of the `crq_table_generator`. Key updates include: - **`SOP_Generating_CRQ_Report.md`:** Updated to describe the detailed CRQ report format, new classification states (Review Provided, Review Skipped, Review Needed from CoderabbitAI, Respond To / Our Turn), and the command generation options. - **`SOP_Using_CRQ_Classifier.md`:** Updated to clarify its purpose as a basic classifier and to point to `SOP_Generating_CRQ_Report.md` for comprehensive analysis. - **`SOP_CRQ_State_Classification.md`:** (Already created in a previous step) Explains the new CRQ classification states in detail.
This commit introduces a new CRQ (Code Review Quality) parser and a state word reporter. - Added `regex` dependency. - Defined new binary targets for `crq-parser-cli` and `state-word-reporter`. - Expanded `ontology.json` with new emoji mappings for better semantic representation. - Implemented `crq_parser` module for parsing CRQ data. - Added CLI tools for CRQ parsing and state word reporting. - Updated `lattice_model.rs` and `lib.rs` to support the new modules and functionalities. - Added initial UML sketch documentation.
…to append-only rule)
Updated the "CRQ Documents" section in task.md to include all currently available CRQ markdown files, ensuring the document reflects the latest state of CRQs in the project.
This commit introduces the initial implementation of a web spider and corpus builder for project analysis. This includes: - New Rust crates for URL extraction, hashing, and web crawling. - Updates to Cargo.toml and Cargo.lock to reflect new dependencies. - Generation of various reports (domain, extracted URLs, file types, etc.). - Creation of CRQ-056 to document this feature. This work lays the foundation for expanding project analysis to external web resources.
This commit introduces two new CRQ documents: - CRQ-057: Addresses the removal of the stabilized `edition2024` feature from Cargo.toml files. - CRQ-058: Focuses on removing unused imports in the `hash_extractor_rust` crate. Additionally, `task.md` has been updated to reflect these new CRQs in the list of open pull requests.
**Problem/Goal:** The `cargo test` command was emitting warnings related to the `edition2024` feature being stabilized and unused imports in several Rust crates. These warnings clutter the test output and indicate unnecessary code/configuration. The goal is to eliminate these warnings to maintain a clean build and test environment. **Proposed Solution:** 1. Remove the `cargo-features = ["edition2024"]` line from `Cargo.toml` files where it was present, as the feature is now stable. 2. Ensure `edition = "2024"` is correctly set in the `[package]` section of these `Cargo.toml` files. 3. Remove unused `use` statements from Rust source files as identified by `cargo test`. Specifically, `crq_parser::CRQ` and `WordPredicate` from `submodules/src/lib.rs`, and `NGramDecomposition` from `src/bin/ngram_reporter.rs`. **Justification/Impact:** Removing these warnings improves code quality and developer experience by reducing noise in the build and test output. It ensures that the project adheres to best practices for Rust development and avoids deprecated or unnecessary configurations. This also makes it easier to spot genuine warnings or errors in the future.
This commit refactors the management of Nix-provided Emacs packages. Instead of attempting to set EMACS_NIX_PACKAGES via flake.nix's shellHook, package paths are now hardcoded directly into ~/.emacs.d/init.el. This change simplifies the Nix configuration and provides direct control over Emacs package loading within Emacs Lisp, aligning with user preference. A Change Request (CRQ) and Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) have been created to document this change and provide guidance on updating the hardcoded paths when Nix store paths change due to package updates. Files modified: - flake.nix: Reverted shellHook changes related to EMACS_NIX_PACKAGES. - .emacs.d/init.el: Updated to hardcode Nix store paths for Emacs packages and require them. - docs/crq_standardized/hardcoded_emacs_paths.md: New CRQ document. - docs/sops/update_emacs_hardcoded_paths.md: New SOP document.
This commit introduces the `terlar/emacs-config` repository as a git submodule. Initial steps include: - Adding the submodule entry to `.gitmodules`. - Initializing the submodule. - Making preliminary modifications to `.emacs.d/init.el` to integrate the new configuration. - Updating `flake.nix` to reflect potential new dependencies or configurations related to Emacs. - Adding `launch_emacs_pane.sh` for easier access to the Emacs environment. Further work is required to fully study and adapt this configuration.
Introduces `launch_nix_emacs.sh` to provide a dedicated Emacs environment within a new tmux pane. This script leverages `nix develop` for proper Nix environment integration and launches Emacs without the `-nw` flag. `shell.nix` has been updated to include `pkgs.emacs` and `pkgs.emacsPackages.magit` in the `buildInputs` to ensure Emacs and Magit are available from the Nix environment.
Refines the Emacs launch process to leverage the `terlar-emacs-config`'s Nix environment, ensuring proper package loading. - `launch_nix_emacs.sh`: Modified to `cd` into `terlar-emacs-config` before running `nix develop`, and removed the unused `EMACS_WINDOW_NAME` variable. - `shell.nix`: Updated with a `shellHook` to dynamically set `EMACSLOADPATH` for Nix-provided Emacs packages. - `.emacs.d/init.el`: Cleaned up by removing outdated hardcoded Nix store paths. Introduces a headless batch test to verify the Emacs configuration: - `run_emacs_batch_test.sh`: Shell script to execute the headless test. - `docs/qa/emacs_batch_test.el`: Emacs Lisp script containing tests for Magit, use-package, and Corfu loading. Documents the Emacs launch and testing procedures: - `docs/qa/emacs_nix_launch_test_procedure.md`: Details steps for manual verification of the Emacs setup. - `docs/sops/SOP_Launch_Emacs_Nix.md`: Standard Operating Procedure for launching Emacs with the Nix-managed configuration.
Updates the `run_emacs_batch_test.sh` script to use `nix run .#` for launching Emacs, and updates the `terlar-emacs-config` submodule reference to reflect the change in its `flake.nix` (adding `aarch64-linux` to supported systems). Note: The submodule commit for `terlar-emacs-config` was not GPG signed due to limitations of this environment.
- Updates `docs/sops/SOP_Launch_Emacs_Nix.md` to include instructions for automated verification using the headless batch test. - Adds `docs/crq_standardized/CRQ-060-emacs-nix-integration.md`, documenting the problem, solution, impact, and verification of the enhanced Emacs Nix integration. - Creates `docs/tutorials/emacs-nix-noob.md`, a blog post detailing the journey of setting up Emacs with Nix for beginners.
WalkthroughAdds a comprehensive Emacs init file, registers an Emacs config submodule in .gitmodules, expands Cargo workspace members and binaries with a new regex dependency, and introduces numerous CRQ-related documentation artifacts under analysis_data, including PR descriptions and reviewer guides. Changes
Sequence Diagram(s)sequenceDiagram
autonumber
participant Dev as Developer
participant FS as Repo (docs/crq/*)
participant Script as gh_create_crq_branches_prs.sh
participant Git as Git Remote
participant GH as GitHub
Dev->>FS: Add CRQ file (CRQ-XXX-Description.md)
Dev->>Script: Run script
Script->>Git: Create branch feature/crq-XXX-description
Script->>Git: Commit CRQ (if needed) and push
Script->>GH: Create PR to main with CRQ content
GH-->>Dev: PR link/status
note over Script,GH: Idempotent checks for existing branch/PR
sequenceDiagram
autonumber
participant Emacs as Emacs
participant Init as init.el
participant GC as Garbage Collector
participant UI as UI/Frames
Emacs->>Init: Early init
Init->>GC: Raise thresholds during startup
Init->>UI: Disable splash, tool/menu bars, set frame opts
Init->>Init: Configure packages (use-package, no-littering, gcmh)
Init->>GC: Restore thresholds post-init
Estimated code review effort🎯 3 (Moderate) | ⏱️ ~25 minutes Poem
Pre-merge checks and finishing touches✅ Passed checks (3 passed)
✨ Finishing touches🧪 Generate unit tests
Tip 👮 Agentic pre-merge checks are now available in preview!Pro plan users can now enable pre-merge checks in their settings to enforce checklists before merging PRs.
Please see the documentation for more information. Example: reviews:
pre_merge_checks:
custom_checks:
- name: "Undocumented Breaking Changes"
mode: "warning"
instructions: |
Pass/fail criteria: All breaking changes to public APIs, CLI flags, environment variables, configuration keys, database schemas, or HTTP/GraphQL endpoints must be documented in the "Breaking Change" section of the PR description and in CHANGELOG.md. Exclude purely internal or private changes (e.g., code not exported from package entry points or explicitly marked as internal).Please share your feedback with us on this Discord post. Thanks for using CodeRabbit! It's free for OSS, and your support helps us grow. If you like it, consider giving us a shout-out. Comment |
PR Reviewer Guide 🔍Here are some key observations to aid the review process:
|
|
Skipped: Cannot respond to another bot. |
PR Code Suggestions ✨Explore these optional code suggestions:
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||
![coderabbitai[bot]](https://avatars.githubusercontent.com/in/347564?s=60&v=4){kind=small}
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 16
♻️ Duplicate comments (1)
analysis_data/comms/git/CRQ-34/coderabbitai/responses/001_coderabbitai.md (1)
1-6: Mirror of 001.md — avoid duplicate artifacts.Prefer a single source (keep this one and remove 001.md, or vice versa) to prevent divergence.
If both must remain, change one messageId (e.g., to "001a") and add a distinct type (e.g., “system-status” vs “skip-banner”).
| (aset buffer-display-table ?^M [? | ||
| ])) |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Broken Lisp vector literal causes init failure.
display-ctrl-M-as-newline builds an invalid display-table entry; the vector is malformed.
Apply:
- (aset buffer-display-table ?^M [?
-]))
+ (aset buffer-display-table ?^M [?\n]))📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.
| (aset buffer-display-table ?^M [? | |
| ])) | |
| (aset buffer-display-table ?^M [?\n])) |
🤖 Prompt for AI Agents
In .emacs.d/init.el around lines 146-147, the display-table vector literal is
malformed causing init failure; replace the broken vector with a well-formed
vector that maps ^M to a newline character (use a vector containing the newline
character as its single element) and ensure parentheses are balanced so the aset
call is syntactically valid.
| (define-minor-mode hide-fringes-mode | ||
| "Toggle hiding of fringes." | ||
| :group 'fringe | ||
| (if hide-fringes-mode | ||
| (set-window-fringes nil 0 0 nil) | ||
| (set-window-fringes nil left-fringe-width right-fringe-width t))) | ||
|
|
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Avoid void variables in hide-fringes-mode.
left-fringe-width/right-fringe-width are undefined. Reset to defaults instead.
(define-minor-mode hide-fringes-mode
"Toggle hiding of fringes."
:group 'fringe
(if hide-fringes-mode
(set-window-fringes nil 0 0 nil)
- (set-window-fringes nil left-fringe-width right-fringe-width t)))
+ (set-window-fringes nil nil nil t)))📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.
| (define-minor-mode hide-fringes-mode | |
| "Toggle hiding of fringes." | |
| :group 'fringe | |
| (if hide-fringes-mode | |
| (set-window-fringes nil 0 0 nil) | |
| (set-window-fringes nil left-fringe-width right-fringe-width t))) | |
| (define-minor-mode hide-fringes-mode | |
| "Toggle hiding of fringes." | |
| :group 'fringe | |
| (if hide-fringes-mode | |
| (set-window-fringes nil 0 0 nil) | |
| (set-window-fringes nil nil nil t))) |
🤖 Prompt for AI Agents
In .emacs.d/init.el around lines 185-191, hide-fringes-mode references undefined
variables left-fringe-width/right-fringe-width when turning the mode off; change
the off-branch to reset fringes to defaults by passing nil for the left and
right fringe widths (i.e., call set-window-fringes with nil for left and right
so Emacs restores default fringe widths) and keep the outer arg true as before.
| "P" 'list-processes | ||
| "s" 'screenshot-svg | ||
| "S" 'screenshot-png | ||
| "x" 'regexp-builder |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Use the correct regexp UI: re-builder not regexp-builder.
The current binding points to a non-existent command.
- "x" 'regexp-builder
+ "x" 're-builder📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.
| "x" 'regexp-builder | |
| "x" 're-builder |
🤖 Prompt for AI Agents
.emacs.d/init.el around line 302: the keybinding currently references a
non-existent command 'regexp-builder'; replace it with the correct Emacs regexp
UI command 're-builder' by updating the binding target to 're-builder' so the
keybind invokes the proper function.
.emacs.d/terlar-emacs-config
Outdated
| @@ -0,0 +1 @@ | |||
| Subproject commit 3c166088ea16e2a39db49830282558a4bee105f7 | |||
There was a problem hiding this comment.
💡 Verification agent
🧩 Analysis chain
Verify submodule wiring and CI initialization.
Ensure .gitmodules matches this path/URL and CI clones with submodules initialized.
Run:
🏁 Script executed:
#!/bin/bash
set -euo pipefail
echo "Show .gitmodules:"
cat .gitmodules || true
echo -e "\nValidate submodule path and gitlink file:"
test -f ".emacs.d/terlar-emacs-config" && sed -n '1p' .emacs.d/terlar-emacs-config || echo "gitlink file missing"
echo -e "\nCheck commit exists on remote:"
git ls-remote https://github.com/terlar/emacs-config 3c166088ea16e2a39db49830282558a4bee105f7
echo -e "\nSearch CI for submodule init steps:"
fd -a .github | xargs -I{} bash -lc 'echo "--- {} ---"; rg -n "submodule|--recurse-submodules|gitmodules" -n {} || true'Length of output: 1082
Add submodule gitlink and ensure CI initializes submodules.
- .gitmodules already contains: .emacs.d/terlar-emacs-config -> https://github.com/terlar/emacs-config (OK).
- The repo is missing the gitlink at .emacs.d/terlar-emacs-config — commit the submodule reference (add/commit the gitlink or populated submodule).
- No CI steps found to initialize submodules; update CI configs (e.g. .github/workflows/*) to run git submodule update --init --recursive or clone with --recurse-submodules.
🤖 Prompt for AI Agents
In .emacs.d/terlar-emacs-config around lines 1-1, the repository is missing the
gitlink for the submodule referenced in .gitmodules and CI does not initialize
submodules; add and commit the submodule pointer by running git submodule add
https://github.com/terlar/emacs-config .emacs.d/terlar-emacs-config (or if
already populated, run git add .emacs.d/terlar-emacs-config && git commit to
record the gitlink), and update CI workflow files (e.g. .github/workflows/*) to
ensure submodules are initialized by adding a step that runs git submodule
update --init --recursive or clone with --recurse-submodules before build/test
steps.
| <details><summary><a href='https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/1/files#diff-fb696df3b164dbf27d0675f9ebdc9ca92581470d9196df21253e038c20ee71e0R64-R75'><strong>Commit Detection Bug</strong></a> | ||
|
|
||
| Using 'git diff --quiet "$CRQ_PATH"' misses untracked files, so the CRQ file may not be committed on the new branch. Prefer checking status (e.g., 'git status --porcelain -- "$CRQ_PATH"') or explicitly staging and committing when needed. | ||
| </summary> | ||
|
|
||
| ```shell | ||
| # Ensure the CRQ file is committed on this branch | ||
| if ! git diff --quiet "$CRQ_PATH"; then | ||
| echo "Staging and committing CRQ file '$CRQ_PATH'…" | ||
| git add "$CRQ_PATH" | ||
| git commit -F "$CRQ_PATH" | ||
| if [ $? -ne 0 ]; then | ||
| echo "Error: Failed to commit CRQ file '$CRQ_PATH'. Aborting." | ||
| exit 1 | ||
| fi | ||
| else | ||
| echo "CRQ file '$CRQ_PATH' is already committed on this branch." | ||
| fi | ||
| ``` |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Snippet still misses untracked files; fix commit detection.
Using only ‘git diff --quiet’ won’t catch untracked CRQ docs. Switch to porcelain status (or ls-files) and commit when needed.
-# Ensure the CRQ file is committed on this branch
-if ! git diff --quiet "$CRQ_PATH"; then
- echo "Staging and committing CRQ file '$CRQ_PATH'…"
- git add "$CRQ_PATH"
- git commit -F "$CRQ_PATH"
+ # Ensure the CRQ file is committed on this branch (handles untracked/modified)
+ if git status --porcelain -- "$CRQ_PATH" | grep -qE '^\?\?|^ M|^M '; then
+ echo "Staging and committing CRQ file '$CRQ_PATH'…"
+ git add -- "$CRQ_PATH"
+ git commit -F "$CRQ_PATH"
if [ $? -ne 0 ]; then
echo "Error: Failed to commit CRQ file '$CRQ_PATH'. Aborting."
exit 1
fi
else
echo "CRQ file '$CRQ_PATH' is already committed on this branch."
fi📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.
| <details><summary><a href='https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/1/files#diff-fb696df3b164dbf27d0675f9ebdc9ca92581470d9196df21253e038c20ee71e0R64-R75'><strong>Commit Detection Bug</strong></a> | |
| Using 'git diff --quiet "$CRQ_PATH"' misses untracked files, so the CRQ file may not be committed on the new branch. Prefer checking status (e.g., 'git status --porcelain -- "$CRQ_PATH"') or explicitly staging and committing when needed. | |
| </summary> | |
| ```shell | |
| # Ensure the CRQ file is committed on this branch | |
| if ! git diff --quiet "$CRQ_PATH"; then | |
| echo "Staging and committing CRQ file '$CRQ_PATH'…" | |
| git add "$CRQ_PATH" | |
| git commit -F "$CRQ_PATH" | |
| if [ $? -ne 0 ]; then | |
| echo "Error: Failed to commit CRQ file '$CRQ_PATH'. Aborting." | |
| exit 1 | |
| fi | |
| else | |
| echo "CRQ file '$CRQ_PATH' is already committed on this branch." | |
| fi | |
| ``` | |
| # Ensure the CRQ file is committed on this branch (handles untracked/modified) | |
| if git status --porcelain -- "$CRQ_PATH" | grep -qE '^\?\?|^ M|^M '; then | |
| echo "Staging and committing CRQ file '$CRQ_PATH'…" | |
| git add -- "$CRQ_PATH" | |
| git commit -F "$CRQ_PATH" | |
| if [ $? -ne 0 ]; then | |
| echo "Error: Failed to commit CRQ file '$CRQ_PATH'. Aborting." | |
| exit 1 | |
| fi | |
| else | |
| echo "CRQ file '$CRQ_PATH' is already committed on this branch." | |
| fi |
🤖 Prompt for AI Agents
In analysis_data/comms/git/CRQ-021/coderabbitai/responses/002.md around lines 35
to 53, the commit-detection snippet relies on "git diff --quiet" which misses
untracked CRQ files; replace that check with a porcelain status or ls-files
check (for example, use "git status --porcelain -- <path>" or "git ls-files
--others --exclude-standard -- <path>") to detect untracked/modified state, and
when the file is untracked or changed, explicitly git add the CRQ file and git
commit it (handling non-zero exit codes) so the CRQ is guaranteed committed on
the branch.
| <details><summary><a href='https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/20/files#diff-d4b10dc90da2ebd2e54c216c08faf398915f797cc4bf2e94185cd40832762c62R208-R209'><strong>Compile Error</strong></a> | ||
|
|
||
| The `main` function returns `Ok(())` but is declared to return `()`. Change the signature to return `Result<(), Box<dyn std::error::Error>>` or remove the `Ok(())` to avoid a type mismatch at compile time. | ||
| </summary> | ||
|
|
||
| ```rust | ||
| Ok(()) | ||
| } | ||
|
|
||
| ``` |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
💡 Verification agent
🧩 Analysis chain
Links point to PR #20; verify/update for PR #24 or make them repository-relative
These anchors reference a different PR and will confuse reviewers of PR #24. Replace with stable permalinks for the relevant commit in this repo or adjust to this PR’s file paths.
-<details><summary><a href='https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/20/files#diff-d4b10d...R208-R209'><strong>Compile Error</strong></a>
+<details><summary><a href='../../../../../../pull/24/files#diff-d4b10d...R208-R209'><strong>Compile Error</strong></a>
@@
-<details><summary><a href='https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/20/files#diff-d4b10d...R182-R187'><strong>Possible Panic</strong></a>
+<details><summary><a href='../../../../../../pull/24/files#diff-d4b10d...R182-R187'><strong>Possible Panic</strong></a>
@@
-<details><summary><a href='https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/20/files#diff-243854...R119-R124'><strong>API Misuse</strong></a>
+<details><summary><a href='../../../../../../pull/24/files#diff-243854...R119-R124'><strong>API Misuse</strong></a>Scan for hardcoded “pull/20” links:
Also applies to: 31-46, 48-66
🏁 Script executed:
#!/bin/bash
rg -n "pull/20" analysis_data/comms/git/CRQ-37Length of output: 32839
Update hardcoded "pull/20" links to point at PR #24 or use repository-relative/commit permalinks
rg found multiple "pull/20" occurrences in analysis_data/comms/git/CRQ-37/pr_description.md and analysis_data/comms/git/CRQ-37/coderabbitai/responses/*.md — replace those links so reviewers of PR #24 aren’t misdirected.
🤖 Prompt for AI Agents
In analysis_data/comms/git/CRQ-37/coderabbitai/responses/002.md around lines 18
to 27, the review text contains hardcoded "pull/20" links that misdirect
reviewers of PR #24; search the repo for all occurrences of "pull/20" (notably
in analysis_data/comms/git/CRQ-37/pr_description.md and
analysis_data/comms/git/CRQ-37/coderabbitai/responses/*.md) and update them to
the correct PR number (pull/24) or, better, replace with repository-relative or
commit-permalink URLs that won't break for future PR renumbers; verify each
modified link resolves correctly and run a quick grep to ensure no remaining
"pull/20" instances.
| <details><summary><a href='https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/19/files#diff-b8a48c02f53b75052bc23d20df7488207a5b86d7815d3fb29ef0b8b985553ab1R1-R148'><strong>Build Break</strong></a> | ||
|
|
||
| File content is wrapped in triple quotes, making it an invalid Rust source file and preventing compilation. Remove the quotes and convert it to valid Rust code. | ||
| </summary> | ||
|
|
||
| ```rust |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Update links to point to this PR (#24), not PR #19.
Current anchors lead reviewers to a different PR, causing confusion.
-<details><summary><a href='https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/19/files#diff-b8a48c02f53b75052bc23d20df7488207a5b86d7815d3fb29ef0b8b985553ab1R1-R148'><strong>Build Break</strong></a>
+<details><summary><a href='https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/24/files#diff-b8a48c02f53b75052bc23d20df7488207a5b86d7815d3fb29ef0b8b985553ab1R1-R148'><strong>Build Break</strong></a>
@@
-<details><summary><a href='https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/19/files#diff-243854d89636db85a935fa955ee16fa44ea3ca7092902bc29701c3a825b0ba0aR108-R133'><strong>Possible Issue</strong></a>
+<details><summary><a href='https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/24/files#diff-243854d89636db85a935fa955ee16fa44ea3ca7092902bc29701c3a825b0ba0aR108-R133'><strong>Possible Issue</strong></a>
@@
-<details><summary><a href='https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/19/files#diff-d4b10dc90da2ebd2e54c216c08faf398915f797cc4bf2e94185cd40832762c62R136-R209'><strong>Build Break</strong></a>
+<details><summary><a href='https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/24/files#diff-d4b10dc90da2ebd2e54c216c08faf398915f797cc4bf2e94185cd40832762c62R136-R209'><strong>Build Break</strong></a>Also applies to: 179-184, 216-220
🤖 Prompt for AI Agents
In analysis_data/comms/git/CRQ-38/coderabbitai/responses/001.md around lines
20-25 (and also update occurrences at 179-184 and 216-220), the anchor URLs and
PR references incorrectly point to PR #19; edit the markdown so those links
reference PR #24 instead (replace “#19” with “#24” in the hrefs and visible
anchors), and ensure the referenced anchor paths match the intended PR number
consistently across the file.
| [lattice_code_generator/src/lib.rs [110-133]](https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/19/files#diff-243854d89636db85a935fa955ee16fa44ea3ca7092902bc29701c3a825b0ba0aR110-R133) | ||
|
|
||
| ```diff | ||
| pub struct LatticeLayer<T: HasValueCount + std::fmt::Debug> { |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Point links at this PR (#24) instead of PR #19.
Multiple anchors reference a different PR, breaking reviewer navigation.
-[lattice_code_generator/src/lib.rs ...](https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/19/files#diff-243854d89636db85a935fa955ee16fa44ea3ca7092902bc29701c3a825b0ba0aR110-R133)
+[lattice_code_generator/src/lib.rs ...](https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/24/files#diff-243854d89636db85a935fa955ee16fa44ea3ca7092902bc29701c3a825b0ba0aR110-R133)
@@
-[src/lib.rs ...](https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/19/files#diff-b1a35a68f14e696205874893c07fd24fdb88882b47c23cc0e0c80a30c7d53759R27-R29)
+[src/lib.rs ...](https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/24/files#diff-b1a35a68f14e696205874893c07fd24fdb88882b47c23cc0e0c80a30c7d53759R27-R29)
@@
-[src/grand_unified_search.rs ...](https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/19/files#diff-b8a48c02f53b75052bc23d20df7488207a5b86d7815d3fb29ef0b8b985553ab1R1-R148)
+[src/grand_unified_search.rs ...](https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/24/files#diff-b8a48c02f53b75052bc23d20df7488207a5b86d7815d3fb29ef0b8b985553ab1R1-R148)
@@
-[generated_lattice_code/value_type.rs ...](https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/19/files#diff-4534ce506bbc5e0a512da2a9f61948dc44575940029777e3be9fa6f1ce706735R1-R1)
+[generated_lattice_code/value_type.rs ...](https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/24/files#diff-4534ce506bbc5e0a512da2a9f61948dc44575940029777e3be9fa6f1ce706735R1-R1)
@@
-[generated_lattice_code/lattice_layer_struct.rs ...](https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/19/files#diff-0aacd04a7a621f806b54ffa94092f874682700841e03474720504945ec824126R1-R1)
+[generated_lattice_code/lattice_layer_struct.rs ...](https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/24/files#diff-0aacd04a7a621f806b54ffa94092f874682700841e03474720504945ec824126R1-R1)
@@
-[submodule-collector/tests/main_execution_test.rs ...](https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/19/files#diff-f0ca198a718b31ebcb98cfb1b258adf263175cf536d8c8883def9223df093fdbR6-R6)
+[submodule-collector/tests/main_execution_test.rs ...](https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/24/files#diff-f0ca198a718b31ebcb98cfb1b258adf263175cf536d8c8883def9223df093fdbR6-R6)Also applies to: 175-184, 210-218, 244-289, 314-322, 379-384
| messageId: "001" | ||
| timestamp: "2025-09-11T19:02:01Z" | ||
| author: "coderabbitai" |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
💡 Verification agent
🧩 Analysis chain
Consolidate with analysis_data/.../responses/001.md
Two near-identical “001” documents exist. Keep a single canonical record or differentiate purpose via messageId and title.
🏁 Script executed:
#!/bin/bash
set -euo pipefail
echo "Searching for response files named '*001*' under analysis_data..."
find analysis_data -type f -path '*/responses/*' -iname '*001*' -print || true
echo
echo "Searching for any 'responses/001.md' files..."
find analysis_data -type f -path '*/responses/001.md' -print || true
echo
echo "Searching for files containing messageId: \"001\" ..."
rg -n --hidden --no-ignore 'messageId:\s*"001"' || true
A="analysis_data/comms/git/CRQ-39/coderabbitai/responses/001_coderabbitai.md"
B="analysis_data/comms/git/CRQ-39/coderabbitai/responses/001.md"
echo
for f in "$A" "$B"; do
if [ -f "$f" ]; then
echo "----- SHOW: $f -----"
sed -n '1,80p' "$f" || true
echo "MD5:" $(md5sum "$f" | awk '{print $1}') || true
echo
else
echo "MISSING: $f"
echo
fi
done
if [ -f "$A" ] && [ -f "$B" ]; then
echo "Comparing files..."
if cmp -s "$A" "$B"; then
echo "RESULT: files are IDENTICAL"
else
echo "RESULT: files differ — unified diff:"
diff -u "$A" "$B" || true
fi
fi
echo
echo "Count of '*001*' files under responses:"
find analysis_data -type f -path '*/responses/*' -iname '*001*' | wc -l || trueLength of output: 19791
Consolidate duplicate response files (responses/001.md vs responses/001_coderabbitai.md)
Multiple CRQ folders contain both responses/001.md and responses/001_coderabbitai.md (69 matches). Keep one canonical record per CRQ or differentiate purpose by assigning unique messageId/title (e.g. analysis_data/comms/git/CRQ-39/coderabbitai/responses/001.md ↔ .../001_coderabbitai.md).
🤖 Prompt for AI Agents
In analysis_data/comms/git/CRQ-39/coderabbitai/responses/001_coderabbitai.md
around lines 3 to 5, there is a duplicate response file corresponding to
responses/001.md; remove the duplication by consolidating into a single
canonical file or rename to a clearly distinct messageId/title (e.g., move
contents into responses/001.md and delete this file, or update messageId and
filename to a unique value and update any references), then run a
repository-wide check to ensure there are no remaining conflicting duplicates
and update any links or indexes that referenced the old filename.
| messageId: "001" | ||
| timestamp: "2025-09-11T19:02:01Z" | ||
| author: "coderabbitai" |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
💡 Verification agent
🧩 Analysis chain
Duplicate messageId “001” across files
This file and 001_coderabbitai.md both use messageId "001". If tooling relies on uniqueness, collisions will occur. Rename one or adjust IDs.
🏁 Script executed:
#!/bin/bash
set -euo pipefail
echo "Searching for messageId occurrences under analysis_data..."
python - <<'PY'
import os,re,sys
pat = re.compile(r'messageId\s*:\s*["\']([^"\']+)["\']')
matches={}
for root,dirs,files in os.walk('.'):
# skip common heavy dirs
if '.git' in root or 'node_modules' in root:
continue
for f in files:
path = os.path.join(root,f)
if not path.startswith('./analysis_data') and not path.startswith('analysis_data'):
continue
try:
with open(path,'r',encoding='utf-8') as fh:
text = fh.read()
except Exception:
continue
for m in pat.finditer(text):
id = m.group(1)
matches.setdefault(id,[]).append(path.lstrip('./'))
if not matches:
print("No messageId occurrences found under analysis_data.")
sys.exit(0)
for id, paths in sorted(matches.items()):
print(f"messageId: {id} -> {len(paths)} file(s)")
for p in paths:
print(" -", p)
PYLength of output: 23574
Duplicate messageId "001" across many response files — action required
messageId "001" is present in 69 files under analysis_data (e.g. analysis_data/comms/git/CRQ-39/coderabbitai/responses/001.md and analysis_data/comms/git/CRQ-39/coderabbitai/responses/001_coderabbitai.md). Tooling that requires unique IDs will collide — make IDs globally unique (include CRQ number/author or a UUID) or deduplicate/rename the files.
🤖 Prompt for AI Agents
In analysis_data/comms/git/CRQ-39/coderabbitai/responses/001.md around lines 3
to 5, the messageId "001" is duplicated across many response files which will
cause collisions in tooling; update the ID to be globally unique (for example by
appending the CRQ number and author or replacing with a UUID) or rename the file
to a unique name, then update any references that consume this messageId
accordingly; apply the same deterministic renaming to all other duplicate files
(e.g., include CRQ-39_coderabbitai_001 or a generated UUID) and run a quick
validation script to ensure no duplicate IDs remain.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 9
♻️ Duplicate comments (20)
analysis_data/comms/git/CRQ-024/pr_description.md (2)
5-6: Scope mismatch—retitle or split (matches an earlier review).Title says “New SOPs…”, yet the body enumerates a large lattice framework, tools, generated artifacts, and docs. Either (A) keep this CRQ strictly to the two SOPs and move the rest to dedicated PR(s), or (B) retitle to reflect the full enhancement scope and adjust PR type.
Apply if choosing (B):
-title: "CRQ-024: New SOPs for CRQ-Driven Development" +title: "CRQ-024: Lattice framework, tools, and SOPs" ### **PR Type** -Enhancement, Documentation +Feature, Enhancement, DocumentationAlso applies to: 55-67
1178-1194: Do not commit generated code, massive JSONs, or 34k‑line DOT graphs (matches an earlier review).Move generated_lattice_/, submodule_report*.json, and devshell_graph.dot to CI artifacts or releases; add ignores. Keeps repo lean and avoids churn.
Add ignores:
+# .gitignore +# Generated lattice artifacts +generated_lattice_code/ +generated_lattice_structure/ + +# Large reports/graphs +submodule_report*.json +devshell_graph.dot +**/*.dotOptional: publish via CI artifact
# .github/workflows/build.yml (excerpt) - name: Upload reports uses: actions/upload-artifact@v4 with: name: crq-024-artifacts path: | submodule_report*.json devshell_graph.dot generated_lattice_*/Also applies to: 1815-1817, 1833-1835, 880-910
analysis_data/comms/git/CRQ-37/coderabbitai/responses/002.md (1)
18-66: Hardcoded PR #20 links — update to PR #24 or use repository-relative/commit permalinks.This mirrors a prior comment; still applicable here. Replace “pull/20” in these anchors to avoid misdirecting reviewers.
Quick check to find remaining occurrences:
#!/bin/bash rg -n "pull/20" analysis_data/comms/git/CRQ-37Interim diff for this file:
-<a href='https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/20/files#diff-d4b10d...'> +<a href='../../../../../../pull/24/files#diff-d4b10d...'>.emacs.d/terlar-emacs-config (1)
1-1: Ensure CI initializes submodules and verify remote commit presenceAdd/verify CI steps to fetch submodules recursively and confirm the pinned commit exists on the remote. Includes a quick verification script.
#!/bin/bash set -euo pipefail echo "Show .gitmodules:" cat .gitmodules || true echo -e "\nVerify submodule entries:" git config -f .gitmodules --get-regexp '^submodule\..*\.(path|url)' || true echo -e "\nConfirm gitlink in tree (expects mode 160000):" git ls-tree -d HEAD .emacs.d/terlar-emacs-config || true echo -e "\nCheck commit exists on remote:" git ls-remote https://github.com/terlar/emacs-config 397c1e795e4a84458609e4f42ef4b1f4e02f4afb || true echo -e "\nSearch CI for submodule init:" fd -a .github | xargs -I{} bash -lc 'echo "--- {} ---"; rg -n "submodule|--recurse-submodules|gitmodules" {} || true'Example (GitHub Actions) step if missing:
- uses: actions/checkout@v4 with: submodules: recursive fetch-depth: 0 # or, if not using checkout’s built-in: - run: git submodule update --init --recursiveanalysis_data/comms/git/CRQ-021/coderabbitai/responses/002.md (1)
41-53: Commit detection must handle untracked files.Replace diff-only check with porcelain status so untracked CRQ docs are committed.
-# Ensure the CRQ file is committed on this branch -if ! git diff --quiet "$CRQ_PATH"; then - echo "Staging and committing CRQ file '$CRQ_PATH'…" - git add "$CRQ_PATH" - git commit -F "$CRQ_PATH" +# Ensure the CRQ file is committed on this branch (handles untracked/modified) +if git status --porcelain -- "$CRQ_PATH" | grep -qE '^\?\?|^ M|^M '; then + echo "Staging and committing CRQ file '$CRQ_PATH'…" + git add -- "$CRQ_PATH" + git commit -F "$CRQ_PATH" if [ $? -ne 0 ]; then echo "Error: Failed to commit CRQ file '$CRQ_PATH'. Aborting." exit 1 fi else echo "CRQ file '$CRQ_PATH' is already committed on this branch." fi.emacs.d/init.el (3)
142-147: Fix malformed display-table vector for ^M.Broken vector causes init failure; map to newline.
(defun display-ctrl-M-as-newline () "Display `^M' as newline." (interactive) (setq buffer-display-table (make-display-table)) - (aset buffer-display-table ?^M [? -])) + (aset buffer-display-table ?^M [?\n]))
185-191: Reset fringes to defaults when disabling.Avoid void variables; let Emacs restore defaults.
(define-minor-mode hide-fringes-mode "Toggle hiding of fringes." :group 'fringe (if hide-fringes-mode (set-window-fringes nil 0 0 nil) - (set-window-fringes nil left-fringe-width right-fringe-width t))) + (set-window-fringes nil nil nil t)))
294-304: Use the correct regexp UI command.Bind to re-builder; current symbol doesn’t exist.
"S" 'screenshot-png - "x" 'regexp-builder + "x" 're-builder "w" 'eww)analysis_data/comms/git/CRQ-39/coderabbitai/responses/001_coderabbitai.md (1)
3-6: Consolidate duplicate “001” artifacts.There’s already guidance to merge 001 vs 001_coderabbitai variants; keep one canonical record or differentiate via messageId/title.
analysis_data/comms/git/CRQ-36/coderabbitai/responses/002.md (1)
18-21: Fix hard-coded PR #21 anchors; use repo-relative links or PR #24.Current links misdirect reviewers.
-<details><summary><a href='https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/21/files#diff-e53dfbfffe62ae3c0b411b3938ccffa9fb6a2ecc565f55785ef8daa756631a6bR1-R1'><strong>Formatting Issue</strong></a> +<details><summary><a href='files#diff-e53dfbfffe62ae3c0b411b3938ccffa9fb6a2ecc565f55785ef8daa756631a6bR1-R1'><strong>Formatting Issue</strong></a> -<details><summary><a href='https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/21/files#diff-b8a48c02f53b75052bc23d20df7488207a5b86d7815d3fb29ef0b8b985553ab1R1-R1'><strong>Syntax Error</strong></a> +<details><summary><a href='files#diff-b8a48c02f53b75052bc23d20df7488207a5b86d7815d3fb29ef0b8b985553ab1R1-R1'><strong>Syntax Error</strong></a> -<details><summary><a href='https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/21/files#diff-206b9ce276ab5971a2489d75eb1b12999d4bf3843b7988cbe8d687cfde61dea0R115-R125'><strong>Missing Dependencies</strong></a> +<details><summary><a href='files#diff-206b9ce276ab5971a2489d75eb1b12999d4bf3843b7988cbe8d687cfde61dea0R115-R125'><strong>Missing Dependencies</strong></a>Also applies to: 30-33, 42-46
analysis_data/comms/git/CRQ-34/coderabbitai/responses/001.md (1)
3-3: De-duplicate messageId across CRQ-34 response filesThis file and 001_coderabbitai.md both use “001”; make it unique.
-messageId: "001" +messageId: "CRQ-34_coderabbitai_001"Run to find any remaining duplicate messageIds under analysis_data:
#!/bin/bash set -euo pipefail python - <<'PY' import os,re,collections pat=re.compile(r'^\s*messageId\s*:\s*["\']([^"\']+)["\']\s*$',re.M) hits=collections.defaultdict(list) for root,_,files in os.walk('analysis_data'): for f in files: p=os.path.join(root,f) try: t=open(p,'r',encoding='utf-8',errors='ignore').read() except Exception: continue for m in pat.finditer(t): hits[m.group(1)].append(p) dups={k:v for k,v in hits.items() if len(v)>1} print("OK: no duplicates" if not dups else "\n".join([f"{k} -> {len(v)}\n "+"\n ".join(v) for k,v in sorted(dups.items())])) PYanalysis_data/comms/git/CRQ-34/coderabbitai/responses/001_coderabbitai.md (1)
3-3: Ensure messageId uniquenessAvoid collisions with 001.md by namespacing the ID.
-messageId: "001" +messageId: "CRQ-34_coderabbitai_001_alt"analysis_data/comms/git/CRQ-39/coderabbitai/responses/001.md (1)
3-3: Duplicate messageId with 001_coderabbitai.mdStandardize on a CRQ-scoped ID.
-messageId: "001" +messageId: "CRQ-39_coderabbitai_001"analysis_data/comms/git/CRQ-38/coderabbitai/responses/001.md (1)
20-25: Update PR links to point to this PR (#24)Anchors currently reference PR #19; switch to #24.
-<details><summary><a href='https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/19/files#diff-b8a48c02f53b75052bc23d20df7488207a5b86d7815d3fb29ef0b8b985553ab1R1-R148'><strong>Build Break</strong></a> +<details><summary><a href='https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/24/files#diff-b8a48c02f53b75052bc23d20df7488207a5b86d7815d3fb29ef0b8b985553ab1R1-R148'><strong>Build Break</strong></a> @@ -<details><summary><a href='https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/19/files#diff-243854d89636db85a935fa955ee16fa44ea3ca7092902bc29701c3a825b0ba0aR108-R133'><strong>Possible Issue</strong></a> +<details><summary><a href='https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/24/files#diff-243854d89636db85a935fa955ee16fa44ea3ca7092902bc29701c3a825b0ba0aR108-R133'><strong>Possible Issue</strong></a> @@ -<details><summary><a href='https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/19/files#diff-d4b10dc90da2ebd2e54c216c08faf398915f797cc4bf2e94185cd40832762c62R136-R209'><strong>Build Break</strong></a> +<details><summary><a href='https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/24/files#diff-d4b10dc90da2ebd2e54c216c08faf398915f797cc4bf2e94185cd40832762c62R136-R209'><strong>Build Break</strong></a>Also applies to: 179-184, 216-220
analysis_data/comms/git/CRQ-34/coderabbitai/responses/003.md (1)
31-41: Replace external PR #21 diff anchors with stable references.Same issue as prior reviews; use repo-relative paths or textual file/line refs.
Apply:
-https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/21/files#diff-... +src/<path>/<file>.rs [start-end]Also applies to: 121-136, 160-173, 198-228, 249-263
analysis_data/comms/git/CRQ-36/coderabbitai/responses/003.md (1)
31-41: Fix broken anchors to PR #21.Update to repo-relative references or this PR’s context. Prior feedback already flagged this.
Also applies to: 121-136, 157-173, 193-228, 249-263
analysis_data/comms/git/CRQ-38/coderabbitai/responses/002.md (1)
31-41: Point links at PR #24 or make them repo-relative.Current anchors target PR #19; navigation breaks.
Apply:
-/pull/19/files#diff- +/pull/24/files#diff-Or replace with repo-relative file/line text.
Also applies to: 38-41, 121-124, 175-184, 210-218, 244-289, 314-322, 379-384
analysis_data/comms/git/CRQ-36/pr_description.md (1)
1-9: Front matter points to PR #21; retarget to this PR (#24).Mirror earlier suggestion; keeps metadata accurate.
crq: "CRQ-36" -messageId: "21" +messageId: "24" timestamp: "2025-09-11T19:02:41Z" -title: "CRQ-36: crq 005 strategic alignment" +title: "CRQ-36: Strategic alignment (crq 005)" author: "jmikedupont2" -url: "https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/21" +url: "https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/24" baseBranch: "main"analysis_data/comms/git/CRQ-34/pr_description.md (1)
1-9: Metadata references PR #23; update to PR #24 or add provenance.Choose either retarget or explicit “imported from PR 23” fields.
Option A:
-messageId: "23" -url: "https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/23" +messageId: "24" +url: "https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/24"Option B:
+sourcePrNumber: 23 +importedInPrNumber: 24 +importedInPrUrl: "https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/24"analysis_data/comms/git/CRQ-34/coderabbitai/responses/002.md (1)
1-58: Same as earlier for this file: replace PR-anchored links and verify generator/test alignment.See prior comments for this path.
| ;; Assuming init-file-debug is not set, so verbose is nil and expand-minimally is t | ||
| (setq use-package-verbose nil | ||
| use-package-expand-minimally t) |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Define init-file-debug to avoid void-variable errors.
It’s referenced in quiet! and gcmh settings but never defined.
;; Assuming init-file-debug is not set, so verbose is nil and expand-minimally is t
+(defvar init-file-debug nil
+ "Enable verbose init logging and messages during startup.")
(setq use-package-verbose nil
use-package-expand-minimally t)Also applies to: 117-123, 103-106
🤖 Prompt for AI Agents
.emacs.d/init.el around lines 14-16 (also apply same change at 103-106 and
117-123): define the variable init-file-debug before it is referenced to avoid
void-variable errors by adding a top-level declaration like (defvar
init-file-debug nil "Non-nil to enable init-file debug messages.") or wrap uses
with (boundp) checks; ensure the defvar appears early in the init file so quiet!
and gcmh settings can safely reference it.
| (push '(undecorated . t) default-frame-alist) | ||
| (push '(menu-bar-lines . 0) default-frame-alist) | ||
| (push '(tool-bar-lines . 0) default-frame-alist) | ||
| (push '(vertical-scroll-bars) default-frame-alist) | ||
|
|
There was a problem hiding this comment.
🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Fix default-frame-alist entry for vertical scroll bars.
Alist entries must be cons cells.
-(push '(vertical-scroll-bars) default-frame-alist)
+(push '(vertical-scroll-bars . nil) default-frame-alist)📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.
| (push '(undecorated . t) default-frame-alist) | |
| (push '(menu-bar-lines . 0) default-frame-alist) | |
| (push '(tool-bar-lines . 0) default-frame-alist) | |
| (push '(vertical-scroll-bars) default-frame-alist) | |
| (push '(undecorated . t) default-frame-alist) | |
| (push '(menu-bar-lines . 0) default-frame-alist) | |
| (push '(tool-bar-lines . 0) default-frame-alist) | |
| (push '(vertical-scroll-bars . nil) default-frame-alist) | |
🤖 Prompt for AI Agents
In .emacs.d/init.el around lines 49 to 53, the default-frame-alist entry for
vertical scroll bars is currently a list rather than a cons cell; replace that
push with one that adds a cons cell pairing vertical-scroll-bars with the
desired value (e.g. nil to disable) so it matches the alist format used by the
other entries.
| (defun send-buffer-to-ssh () | ||
| "Send the whole buffer to the *ssh* process." | ||
| (interactive) | ||
| (process-send-region "*ssh*" (point-min) (point-max))) | ||
|
|
||
| (defun send-to-ssh () | ||
| "Send selected region or current line to the *ssh* process." | ||
| (interactive) | ||
| (let ((procbuf "*ssh*")) | ||
| (if (use-region-p) | ||
| (process-send-region procbuf (region-beginning) (region-end)) | ||
| (process-send-string procbuf (thing-at-point 'line t))))) | ||
|
|
There was a problem hiding this comment.
🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Check ssh process exists before sending.
Avoid errors when ssh isn’t running.
(defun send-buffer-to-ssh ()
"Send the whole buffer to the *ssh* process."
(interactive)
- (process-send-region "*ssh*" (point-min) (point-max)))
+ (let ((proc (get-process "ssh")))
+ (unless (and proc (process-live-p proc))
+ (user-error "Process *ssh* not running"))
+ (process-send-region proc (point-min) (point-max))))
(defun send-to-ssh ()
"Send selected region or current line to the *ssh* process."
(interactive)
- (let ((procbuf "*ssh*"))
- (if (use-region-p)
- (process-send-region procbuf (region-beginning) (region-end))
- (process-send-string procbuf (thing-at-point 'line t)))))
+ (let ((proc (get-process "ssh")))
+ (unless (and proc (process-live-p proc))
+ (user-error "Process *ssh* not running"))
+ (if (use-region-p)
+ (process-send-region proc (region-beginning) (region-end))
+ (process-send-string proc (thing-at-point 'line t)))))📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.
| (defun send-buffer-to-ssh () | |
| "Send the whole buffer to the *ssh* process." | |
| (interactive) | |
| (process-send-region "*ssh*" (point-min) (point-max))) | |
| (defun send-to-ssh () | |
| "Send selected region or current line to the *ssh* process." | |
| (interactive) | |
| (let ((procbuf "*ssh*")) | |
| (if (use-region-p) | |
| (process-send-region procbuf (region-beginning) (region-end)) | |
| (process-send-string procbuf (thing-at-point 'line t))))) | |
| (defun send-buffer-to-ssh () | |
| "Send the whole buffer to the *ssh* process." | |
| (interactive) | |
| (let ((proc (get-process "ssh"))) | |
| (unless (and proc (process-live-p proc)) | |
| (user-error "Process *ssh* not running")) | |
| (process-send-region proc (point-min) (point-max)))) | |
| (defun send-to-ssh () | |
| "Send selected region or current line to the *ssh* process." | |
| (interactive) | |
| (let ((proc (get-process "ssh"))) | |
| (unless (and proc (process-live-p proc)) | |
| (user-error "Process *ssh* not running")) | |
| (if (use-region-p) | |
| (process-send-region proc (region-beginning) (region-end)) | |
| (process-send-string proc (thing-at-point 'line t))))) |
🤖 Prompt for AI Agents
In .emacs.d/init.el around lines 172 to 184, the functions send-buffer-to-ssh
and send-to-ssh assume the *ssh* process exists and will error if it does not;
update both functions to check for the process first (use get-process with the
process name or get-buffer-process on (get-buffer "*ssh*")), and if the process
is nil call message (or display a user-facing warning) and return early; only
call process-send-region or process-send-string when the process is non-nil so
the functions fail gracefully when *ssh* isn’t running.
| (defvar-keymap toggle-map | ||
| :doc "Keymap for toggle key sequences." | ||
| :prefix 'toggle-map-prefix | ||
| "*" '("Light/Dark theme" . toggle-theme-mode) | ||
| "c" '("Changes" . highlight-changes-mode) | ||
| "d" '("Debug on error" . toggle-debug-on-error) | ||
| "f" '("Code folding" . hs-minor-mode) | ||
| "F" '("Follow" . follow-mode) | ||
| ;; Group together as one mode? | ||
| "g" '("Sub-word" . subword-mode) | ||
| "G" '("Readable camelCase" . glasses-mode) | ||
| "h" '("Line highlight" . hl-line-mode) | ||
| "l" '("Line numbers" . global-display-line-numbers-mode) | ||
| "t" '("Truncate lines" . toggle-truncate-lines) | ||
| "V" '("Variable-pitch" . variable-pitch-mode) | ||
| "w" '("White-space" . whitespace-mode) | ||
| "x" '("Syntax checker" . flymake-mode)) | ||
|
|
There was a problem hiding this comment.
💡 Verification agent
🧩 Analysis chain
Verify toggle-theme-mode exists or bind to a known toggle.
Prevent dead keybinding.
Would you like me to wire this to modus-themes-toggle (if you use Modus) or provide a simple wrapper around load-theme?
🏁 Script executed:
#!/bin/bash
# Search for a definition or alias of toggle-theme-mode outside init.el
rg -nP '^\s*(def(un|alias)\s+toggle-theme-mode\b' -g '!**/.emacs.d/init.el'Length of output: 72
🏁 Script executed:
#!/bin/bash
set -euo pipefail
echo "cwd: $(pwd)"
if ! command -v rg >/dev/null 2>&1; then
echo "rg not found in environment; aborting search."
exit 0
fi
echo
echo "=== occurrences of 'toggle-theme-mode' ==="
rg -n --hidden -S "toggle-theme-mode" || true
echo
echo "=== literal defun/defalias for toggle-theme-mode ==="
rg -n --hidden -F "(defun toggle-theme-mode" || true
rg -n --hidden -F "(defalias 'toggle-theme-mode" || true
echo
echo "=== occurrences of 'toggle-theme' (broader search) ==="
rg -n --hidden -S "toggle-theme" || true
echo
echo "=== occurrences of 'modus-themes-toggle' ==="
rg -n --hidden -S "modus-themes-toggle" || true
echo
echo "=== occurrences of 'load-theme' ==="
rg -n --hidden -S "load-theme" || true
echo
echo "=== Show .emacs.d/init.el around the keymap if present ==="
if [ -f ".emacs.d/init.el" ]; then
echo "----- .emacs.d/init.el (lines 250-320) -----"
sed -n '250,320p' .emacs.d/init.el || true
else
echo ".emacs.d/init.el not found in repo root"
fiLength of output: 2713
Define or replace toggle-theme-mode
toggle-theme-mode is referenced only at .emacs.d/init.el:279 (the "*" binding in toggle-map) and has no definition elsewhere — this creates a dead keybinding. Either define toggle-theme-mode (wrap load-theme to toggle your chosen light/dark themes) or rebind the key to a known command (e.g., modus-themes-toggle if you use Modus).
🤖 Prompt for AI Agents
.emacs.d/init.el around lines 276 to 293: the toggle-map binds "*" to
toggle-theme-mode but that function is not defined, leaving a dead keybinding;
either implement a small interactive toggle-theme-mode that remembers or detects
the current theme and switches between your chosen light and dark themes by
disabling the current theme(s) and loading the alternate theme, or change the
binding to an existing toggle command you already use (e.g.,
modus-themes-toggle); update the file to add the interactive function (with
clear names for your light/dark theme variables) or replace the "*" mapping to
the known command so the key actually toggles themes.
| CRQ_NUMBER=$(echo "$FILENAME" | sed -n 's/CRQ-\\([0-9]*\\)-.*\\.md/\\1/p') | ||
| CRQ_DESCRIPTION=$(echo "$FILENAME" | sed -n 's/CRQ-[0-9]*-(\\ా.*\\)\\.md/\\1/p' | tr '_' '-') | ||
|
|
||
| # Construct branch name | ||
| BRANCH_NAME="feature/crq-${CRQ_NUMBER}-${CRQ_DESCRIPTION}" | ||
|
|
||
| ``` |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Fix CRQ filename parsing (over-escaped regex and stray char).
Current sed patterns will fail; use extended regex, remove stray non-ASCII, and normalize the description.
-CRQ_NUMBER=$(echo "$FILENAME" | sed -n 's/CRQ-\\([0-9]*\\)-.*\\.md/\\1/p')
-CRQ_DESCRIPTION=$(echo "$FILENAME" | sed -n 's/CRQ-[0-9]*-(\\ా.*\\)\\.md/\\1/p' | tr '_' '-')
+CRQ_NUMBER=$(sed -nE 's/^CRQ-([0-9]+)-.*\.md$/\1/p' <<<"$FILENAME")
+CRQ_DESCRIPTION=$(sed -nE 's/^CRQ-[0-9]+-(.*)\.md$/\1/p' <<<"$FILENAME" \
+ | tr '_' '-' | tr '[:upper:]' '[:lower:]')
+
+# Optional: sanitize to VCS-safe branch segment
+# CRQ_DESCRIPTION=${CRQ_DESCRIPTION//[^a-z0-9-]/-}📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.
| CRQ_NUMBER=$(echo "$FILENAME" | sed -n 's/CRQ-\\([0-9]*\\)-.*\\.md/\\1/p') | |
| CRQ_DESCRIPTION=$(echo "$FILENAME" | sed -n 's/CRQ-[0-9]*-(\\ా.*\\)\\.md/\\1/p' | tr '_' '-') | |
| # Construct branch name | |
| BRANCH_NAME="feature/crq-${CRQ_NUMBER}-${CRQ_DESCRIPTION}" | |
| ``` | |
| CRQ_NUMBER=$(sed -nE 's/^CRQ-([0-9]+)-.*\.md$/\1/p' <<<"$FILENAME") | |
| CRQ_DESCRIPTION=$(sed -nE 's/^CRQ-[0-9]+-(.*)\.md$/\1/p' <<<"$FILENAME" \ | |
| | tr '_' '-' | tr '[:upper:]' '[:lower:]') | |
| # Optional: sanitize to VCS-safe branch segment | |
| # CRQ_DESCRIPTION=${CRQ_DESCRIPTION//[^a-z0-9-]/-} | |
| # Construct branch name | |
| BRANCH_NAME="feature/crq-${CRQ_NUMBER}-${CRQ_DESCRIPTION}" |
🤖 Prompt for AI Agents
In analysis_data/comms/git/CRQ-021/coderabbitai/responses/002.md around lines
25-31, the sed regexes are over-escaped and contain a stray non-ASCII character,
causing CRQ number and description extraction to fail; update the CRQ_NUMBER and
CRQ_DESCRIPTION extraction to use a single, correct extended-regex pattern (or
sed -r / -E) that captures digits after "CRQ-" and the description part after
the second dash, remove the stray non-ASCII char from the pattern, and normalize
the description by replacing underscores with hyphens and lowercasing (and add a
fallback if description is empty) so BRANCH_NAME becomes
feature/crq-<number>-<normalized-description>.
| timestamp: "2025-09-11T18:48:31Z" | ||
| title: "CRQ-024: New SOPs for CRQ-Driven Development" | ||
| author: "jmikedupont2" | ||
| url: "https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/3" |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Fix incorrect PR URL (points to PR #3).
This artifact should reference the current PR #24 to avoid reviewer confusion.
-url: "https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/3"
+url: "https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/24"📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.
| url: "https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/3" | |
| url: "https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/24" |
🤖 Prompt for AI Agents
In analysis_data/comms/git/CRQ-024/pr_description.md around line 7, the PR URL
incorrectly points to pull request #3; update the URL to reference the current
PR #24 (https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/24) so
the artifact correctly links to the intended review.
| <tr> | ||
| <td> | ||
| <details> | ||
| <summary><strong>submodule_report.json</strong><dd><code>Complete submodule ecosystem documentation and mapping</code> </dd></summary> | ||
| <hr> | ||
|
|
||
| submodule_report.json | ||
|
|
||
| • Added comprehensive JSON report containing 2021 lines documenting <br>all Git repositories and their submodules<br> • Includes repository URLs, <br>local paths, and nested submodule structures for the entire project <br>ecosystem<br> • Maps out complex dependency relationships across multiple <br>meta-introspector projects and external repositories | ||
|
|
||
|
|
||
| </details> | ||
|
|
||
|
|
||
| </td> | ||
| <td><a href="https://github.com/meta-introspector/git-submodules-rs-nix/pull/3/files#diff-cf55860203aefdb6b0dd57e87aa0929dd59f5d9ef2f3e88568b54dc25898e3a7">+2021/-0</a></td> | ||
|
|
There was a problem hiding this comment.
💡 Verification agent
🧩 Analysis chain
Quick repo check for large/unignored artifacts.
Automates verifying presence and ignore status.
Also applies to: 1815-1817, 1833-1835
🏁 Script executed:
#!/bin/bash
set -euo pipefail
echo "Large files (>1MB):"
fd --hidden --no-ignore --type f -S +1M | sed 's/^/ /'
echo "Generated lattice dirs:"
fd --hidden --no-ignore -t d 'generated_lattice_(code|structure)'
echo ".gitignore coverage for known patterns:"
pat='generated_lattice_code|generated_lattice_structure|submodule_report.*\.json|\.dot$'
if [ -f .gitignore ]; then
rg -n "$pat" .gitignore || echo " Missing one or more ignore patterns."
else
echo " .gitignore not found."
fi
echo "DOT size/lines (if present):"
if [ -f devshell_graph.dot ]; then
du -h devshell_graph.dot
wc -l devshell_graph.dot
fiLength of output: 343
Remove/untrack large or generated artifacts and add .gitignore entries
- Tracked large files found: extracted_urls.txt and self/reflection/directory/devshell_graph.dot — untrack (git rm --cached) or remove from history.
- Generated dirs present: generated_lattice_code/ and generated_lattice_structure/ — add to .gitignore and remove from commits if currently tracked.
- .gitignore missing patterns: add generated_lattice_code, generated_lattice_structure, submodule_report.*.json and *.dot.
- If submodule_report.json is intentionally tracked, document why; otherwise remove and ignore.
| @@ -0,0 +1,87 @@ | |||
| --- | |||
| crq: "CRQ-36" | |||
| messageId: "001" | |||
There was a problem hiding this comment.
🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Make messageId globally unique to avoid collisions
Use a deterministic, CRQ-scoped ID to prevent tooling clashes with other “001.md” files.
-messageId: "001"
+messageId: "CRQ-36_coderabbitai_001"📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.
| messageId: "001" | |
| messageId: "CRQ-36_coderabbitai_001" |
🤖 Prompt for AI Agents
In analysis_data/comms/git/CRQ-36/coderabbitai/responses/001.md around line 3,
the messageId value "001" is not globally unique; replace it with a
deterministic CRQ-scoped identifier (for example prefixing with the CRQ number
and a stable suffix like "CRQ-36-001" or use a hash of the file path/CRQ) so the
ID is unique across the repo and repeatable; update the messageId to that new
deterministic value and ensure any tooling or references that read this file use
the new format.
| @@ -0,0 +1,87 @@ | |||
| --- | |||
| crq: "CRQ-38" | |||
| messageId: "001" | |||
There was a problem hiding this comment.
🛠️ Refactor suggestion
messageId also duplicates 001.md in this CRQ
Namespace it to avoid collisions.
-messageId: "001"
+messageId: "CRQ-38_coderabbitai_001"📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.
| messageId: "001" | |
| messageId: "CRQ-38_coderabbitai_001" |
🤖 Prompt for AI Agents
In analysis_data/comms/git/CRQ-38/coderabbitai/responses/001_coderabbitai.md
around line 3, the messageId "001" collides with 001.md in this CRQ; change it
to a namespaced value (e.g., "coderabbitai/001" or "CRQ-38/coderabbitai/001") to
ensure uniqueness, update any code or references that consume this messageId
accordingly, and keep the naming convention consistent across other response
files to avoid future collisions.
1 participant
PR Type
Enhancement
Description
• Major CRQ Analysis Framework: Comprehensive implementation of CRQ (Change Request) parsing, analysis, and reporting tools with state classification and communication analysis
• Wikipedia/Wikidata Integration: Full-featured Wikipedia data extraction system with caching, entity fetching, and article parsing capabilities
• Template Processing System: WikiProject template introspection, parsing, and Rust code generation with procedural macros
• Analysis Tools Suite: Multiple specialized tools including n-gram analysis, word classification, web spider corpus builder, and hash extraction utilities
• Development Environment: Enhanced Nix-based development setup with Emacs configuration integration and tmux automation scripts
• Agent Communication Analysis: Tools for analyzing CodeRabbitAI responses and PR communication patterns with automated review request capabilities
• Lattice Framework Extensions: Updates to lattice model with improved error messages and test coverage
• Comprehensive Testing: Integration tests for Wikipedia extractor, web spider, and CRQ state recognition functionality
Diagram Walkthrough
File Walkthrough
49 files
crq_parser.rs
CRQ Parser with State Classification and Communication Analysistools/crq_table_generator/src/crq_parser.rs
• Added comprehensive CRQ parsing and analysis functionality with
state classification
• Implemented
NextStepenum with various statesincluding review status and action types
• Added communication
analysis to check CoderabbitAI responses and determine next steps
•
Included n-gram analysis and token extraction for content
classification
main.rs
CRQ Word Analyzer Tool with Multiple Analysis Modestools/crq_word_analyzer/src/main.rs
• Created word analysis tool for CRQ documents with multiple analysis
modes
• Added sequential response analysis and individual response
classification
• Implemented categorized word counting by
NextStepclassification
• Integrated with CRQ parser for comprehensive document
analysis
crq_parser.rs
Extended CRQ Parser with Enhanced N-gram Analysistools/crq_word_analyzer/src/crq_parser.rs
• Duplicated CRQ parser functionality with extended n-gram lengths
•
Added communication analysis and state classification logic
• Removed
ReviewSkippedDueToSizeLimitstate from phase classification• Updated
n-gram lengths to include larger values (11, 13, 17, 19)
main.rs
CRQ Table Generator with Command Generationtools/crq_table_generator/src/main.rs
• Built CRQ table generator with command generation capabilities
•
Added PR number mapping from task.md file parsing
• Implemented
detailed reporting and script generation for review commands
•
Integrated with CRQ parser for comprehensive analysis reporting
main.rs
Agent Communication Response Analyzer Tooltools/agent_comms_analysis/response_analyzer/src/main.rs
• Created response analyzer for agent communication analysis
• Added
file organization by author and CRQ ID
• Implemented comment
classification and repeated phrase analysis
• Added metadata parsing
for communication tracking
lib.rs
Wikimedia Template Introspector Core Librarywikimedia-template-introspector-core/src/lib.rs
• Added WikiProject template parsing and code generation functionality
• Implemented template invocation parsing with parameter handling
•
Added WikiProject crate content generation with template functions
•
Included comprehensive test coverage for template parsing
wikidata_client.rs
Wikidata Client with Caching and Entity Fetchingwikipedia_extractor/src/wikidata_client.rs
• Implemented Wikidata entity fetching with caching support
• Added
comprehensive data type handling for Wikidata claims
• Implemented
entity caching and retrieval functionality
• Added support for
multiple query methods (title or ID)
parser_codegen.rs
Template Parser and Code Generatorwikimedia-template-introspector/src/parser_codegen.rs
• Added template parsing and Rust code generation functionality
•
Implemented parameter handling for both named and positional
parameters
• Added comprehensive test coverage with regex-based
assertions
• Fixed format string generation for template parameters
main.rs
Web Spider Corpus Builder Tooltools/web_spider_corpus_builder/src/main.rs
• Created web spider tool for corpus building from URLs
• Added URL
extraction from markdown files and plain text files
• Implemented
content type handling for HTML and PDF files
• Added sanitized
filename generation and polite crawling delays
ngram_reporter.rs
N-gram Analysis Reporter Binarysrc/bin/ngram_reporter.rs
• Created n-gram analysis reporter with hierarchical decomposition
•
Implemented categorized output generation based on count thresholds
•
Added file writing functionality for categorized reports
• Integrated
with hierarchical n-gram analysis module
state-word-reporter.rs
State-based Word Reporter Binarysrc/bin/state-word-reporter.rs
• Built state-based word reporter for CRQ and SOP documents
• Added
predicate-based word classification functionality
• Implemented
document processing for multiple file types
• Added comprehensive word
matching and reporting
crq_parser.rs
Core CRQ Parser Implementationsrc/crq_parser.rs
• Implemented CRQ structure definition and parsing functionality
•
Added markdown section parsing with regex-based heading detection
•
Implemented comprehensive field extraction and validation
• Added
error handling for missing required sections
ngram_analyzer.rs
N-gram Analysis Module with Hierarchical Decompositionsrc/ngram_analyzer.rs
• Added hierarchical n-gram analysis with decomposition functionality
• Implemented n-gram generation and classification capabilities
•
Added tokenization and text processing utilities
• Created n-gram
presence detection for classification
main.rs
Wikipedia Data Extractor Tooltools/wiki_data_extractor/src/main.rs
• Created Wikipedia data extraction tool with Wikidata integration
•
Added link processing and entity fetching for Wikipedia articles
•
Implemented comprehensive URL filtering and validation
• Added caching
support for extracted data
cache.rs
Wikipedia and Wikidata Caching Systemwikipedia_extractor/src/cache.rs
• Implemented caching functionality for Wikipedia articles and
Wikidata entities
• Added file-based cache with sanitized filename
generation
• Implemented cache loading and saving with JSON
serialization
• Added proper error handling for cache operations
crq_parser.rs
Basic CRQ Parser Implementationtools/crq-parser/src/crq_parser.rs
• Implemented basic CRQ parsing with simple state determination
•
Added
NextStepenum with basic action classification• Implemented
content-based next step determination logic
• Added basic CRQ
structure parsing functionality
main.rs
Hash Extractor with URL Analysis Pipelinehash_extractor_rust/src/main.rs
• Created hash extraction tool with URL deduplication functionality
•
Added integration with GitHub counter, domain reporter, and file type
reporter
• Implemented regex-based hash replacement and unique URL
tracking
• Added comprehensive reporting and analysis pipeline
github_counter.rs
GitHub Repository Counter with JSON-LD Outputhash_extractor_rust/src/github_counter.rs
• Implemented GitHub repository counting with JSON-LD output
• Added
repository URL parsing and owner/repo extraction
• Created structured
data output with schema.org context
• Added comprehensive repository
statistics generation
wikipedia_parser.rs
Wikipedia Article Parser with Cachingwikipedia_extractor/src/wikipedia_parser.rs
• Implemented Wikipedia article parsing with caching support
• Added
HTML content extraction and link processing
• Integrated with
Wikipedia crate for article fetching
• Added comprehensive article
data structure population
main.rs
MediaWiki Template Function Generatortemplate_function_generator/src/main.rs
• Created template function generator for MediaWiki templates
• Added
command-line interface for template string processing
• Implemented
parameter handling and Rust code generation
• Added template name
sanitization and function generation
main.rs
Command-line CRQ Parser Tooltools/crq-parser/src/main.rs
• Created command-line CRQ parser tool with file input support
• Added
CRQ content parsing and next step determination
• Implemented
formatted output for parsed CRQ components
• Added error handling for
file operations and parsing
template_code_generator.rs
WikiProject Template Code Generatorwikimedia-template-introspector-core/src/template_code_generator.rs
• Implemented WikiProject-specific template function generation
•
Added parameter handling for template invocations
• Created formatted
function names with WikiProject prefixes
• Added debug output
generation for template execution
data_structures.rs
Wikipedia Extractor Data Structureswikipedia_extractor/src/data_structures.rs
• Defined core data structures for Wikipedia and Wikidata entities
•
Added serialization support with serde for caching
• Implemented
comprehensive structure definitions for articles and facts
• Added
proper field definitions for all entity types
build.rs
Build script for wiki template code generationgenerated_wiki_templates/build.rs
• New build script that generates Rust code from wiki template strings
• Uses external
template_function_generatorto process templateinvocations
• Creates module files for each generated template
function
• Handles template name normalization and file organization
file_type_reporter.rs
File type analysis and reporting from URLshash_extractor_rust/src/file_type_reporter.rs
• New module for generating file type reports from URL lists
•
Extracts file extensions from URL path segments
• Validates extensions
and counts occurrences
• Outputs JSON report with file type statistics
crq-parser-cli.rs
Command-line CRQ markdown parser toolsrc/bin/crq-parser-cli.rs
• New CLI tool for parsing CRQ markdown files
• Extracts CRQ ID from
filename and parses structured content
• Displays parsed CRQ
information including title, objective, and dependencies
• Uses
clapfor command-line argument parsing
domain_reporter.rs
Domain extraction and reporting from URLshash_extractor_rust/src/domain_reporter.rs
• New module for domain analysis from URL lists
• Extracts and counts
domain occurrences from parsed URLs
• Implements simple heuristic for
base domain extraction
• Generates JSON report with domain statistics
word_classifier.rs
Word predicate classification frameworksrc/word_classifier.rs
• New predicate-based word classification system
• Implements
WordPredicatetype andPredicateClassifierstruct• Extracts word
predicates from text based on target predicates
• Provides
case-insensitive text matching functionality
main.rs
WikiProject crate generator binarytemplate_generator_bin/src/main.rs
• New binary for generating WikiProject crate content
• Creates
directory structure and lib.rs files for generated crates
• Uses
wikimedia_template_introspector_corefor content generation• Handles
file system operations for crate creation
main.rs
Git hash extraction from URL filesurl_hash_extractor/src/main.rs
• New tool for extracting 40-character hexadecimal hashes from URLs
•
Reads from file and applies regex pattern matching
• Specifically
targets Git commit hash patterns
• Outputs found hashes to stdout
main.rs
Recursive URL extraction from file contentsurl_extractor/src/main.rs
• New utility for extracting URLs from files recursively
• Walks
directory tree and searches file contents
• Uses regex to match
HTTP/HTTPS URL patterns
• Outputs all found URLs to stdout
crq_state_recognizer.rs
CodeRabbitAI review state recognitionsrc/crq_state_recognizer.rs
• New module for recognizing CodeRabbitAI review states
• Detects when
reviews are skipped due to size limits
• Uses keyword matching to
identify review status
• Provides boolean function for state detection
lib.rs
Library expansion with new modules and functionalitysrc/lib.rs
• Added multiple new module exports and imports
• Integrated
word_classifiermodule into lattice building• Enhanced ZOS lattice
construction with predicate classification
• Made several modules
public for external use
lib.rs
Wikipedia data processing library interfacewikipedia_extractor/src/lib.rs
• New library module exports for Wikipedia data processing
• Exposes
data structures, parser, client, and cache modules
• Provides unified
interface for Wikipedia and Wikidata operations
• Re-exports key types
and functions for external use
lib.rs
Wikimedia template introspection proc macro setupwikimedia-template-introspector/src/lib.rs
• New procedural macro library for template introspection
• Imports
core template parsing functionality
• Sets up proc_macro
infrastructure with quote and syn
• Duplicate import indicates work in
progress
lib.rs
Generated wiki templates library interfacegenerated_wiki_templates/src/lib.rs
• New library that includes generated template modules
• Uses
build-time generated code from OUT_DIR
• Provides entry point for
generated template functionality
• Allows for additional public
functions and modules
main.rs
Template generation CLI triggertemplate_generator_cli/src/main.rs
• Minimal CLI binary that triggers build script execution
• Serves as
entry point for template generation process
• Prints confirmation
message when build script runs
• Acts as build system integration
point
lib.rs
Generated WikiProject crate placeholdergenerated_wikiproject_crates/solfunmeme/src/lib.rs
• Placeholder library file for generated WikiProject crate
• Contains
comment indicating future generated functions
• Part of the solfunmeme
WikiProject crate structure
• Represents generated crate template
mirror_pr_to_fs.sh
PR data mirroring script for analysistools/agent_comms_analysis/mirror_pr_to_fs.sh
• New shell script for mirroring PR data to filesystem
• Extracts PR
details and comments using GitHub CLI
• Creates structured directory
layout for CRQ analysis
• Processes CodeRabbitAI comments with
metadata headers
process_all_crq_branches.sh
Batch PR processing for CRQ analysistools/agent_comms_analysis/process_all_crq_branches.sh
• Script to process all open PRs and collect data
• Iterates through
PR list and extracts CRQ information
• Calls mirror_pr_to_fs.sh for
each PR
• Creates centralized analysis data directory
new_crq.sh
New CRQ file creation scripttools/new_crq.sh
• Script for creating new CRQ files with standard template
•
Automatically determines next CRQ number
• Sanitizes title for
filename generation
• Creates structured CRQ document with template
sections
ping_coderabbitai.sh
Automated CodeRabbitAI review request scripttools/agent_comms_analysis/ping_coderabbitai.sh
• Script to ping CodeRabbitAI on PRs without responses
• Checks for
existing CodeRabbitAI comments
• Automatically posts review requests
where needed
• Processes all open pull requests
nextstep.sh
Batch CodeRabbitAI review request scriptnextstep.sh
• Script containing multiple GitHub CLI commands
• Posts CodeRabbitAI
review requests to specific PRs
• Hardcoded PR numbers for batch
processing
• Simple automation for review requests
classify_crq.sh
CRQ classification script using parsertools/classify_crq.sh
• Script for classifying CRQ files using crq-parser
• Validates file
existence and parser availability
• Executes crq-parser with file
argument
• Provides error handling for missing dependencies
launch_emacs_pane.sh
Tmux Emacs pane launcher scriptlaunch_emacs_pane.sh
• Script for launching Emacs in tmux split pane
• Sets up EMACS_HOME
environment variable
• Creates vertical split in existing tmux session
• Provides tmux-based development environment setup
update_pr_bases.sh
PR base branch update automation scripttools/agent_comms_analysis/update_pr_bases.sh
• Script to update all open PR base branches to main
• Uses GitHub CLI
to modify PR base branches
• Processes all open PRs systematically
•
Provides error handling and status reporting
generate_crq_summary.sh
CRQ summary report generation scripttools/generate_crq_summary.sh
• Script for generating CRQ summary reports
• Uses crq_table_generator
executable
• Validates executable availability
• Provides build
instructions for missing dependencies
launch_nix_emacs.sh
Nix-based Emacs launcher for tmuxlaunch_nix_emacs.sh
• Script for launching Emacs in Nix development environment
• Creates
new tmux window with Nix develop command
• Checks for existing tmux
session
• Integrates Emacs with terlar-emacs-config
Q107451751.json
Add Wikidata cache entry for monomorphization conceptwikipedia_extractor/cache/wikidata/Q107451751.json
• Created new Wikidata cache entry for "Monomorphization" concept
•
Added JSON structure with ID
Q107451751and empty facts array5 files
integration_test.rs
Wikipedia Extractor Integration Testswikipedia_extractor/tests/integration_test.rs
• Added comprehensive integration tests for Wikipedia and Wikidata
functionality
• Implemented tests for article extraction and entity
fetching
• Added caching functionality testing
• Included proper error
handling and assertions
test_crq_state_recognizer.rs
CRQ State Recognizer Test Suitetests/test_crq_state_recognizer.rs
• Added comprehensive tests for CRQ state recognition functionality
•
Implemented tests for review skip detection due to size limits
• Added
positive and negative test cases for various scenarios
• Included rate
limit and normal review detection tests
integration_test.rs
Web Spider Corpus Builder Integration Testtools/web_spider_corpus_builder/tests/integration_test.rs
• Added integration test for web spider corpus builder functionality
•
Implemented test for markdown URL extraction and HTML fetching
• Added
build verification and executable testing
• Included cleanup and
assertion logic for test validation
lib.rs
Lattice Code Generator Test Updateslattice_code_generator/src/lib.rs
• Updated test assertions to match generated code format changes
•
Fixed spacing and formatting expectations in test cases
• Updated enum
variant and method call formatting assertions
• Adjusted prime value
type test expectations
run_emacs_batch_test.sh
Emacs configuration batch testing scriptrun_emacs_batch_test.sh
• Script for running headless Emacs configuration tests
• Uses Nix
development environment for Emacs testing
• Loads test file in batch
mode
• Provides exit code handling for test results
1 files
lattice_model.rs
Lattice Model Error Message Fixsrc/lattice_model.rs
• Fixed assertion error message for value count validation
• Updated
error message to be more descriptive and accurate
• Changed from
"layer's value type" to "layer's value count"
3 files
flake.nix
Nix flake structure simplification and dependency updateflake.nix
• Simplified flake structure by removing nested function
• Added
pinentryto development shell dependencies• Removed shellHook as per
user instruction
• Maintained all existing functionality with cleaner
structure
shell.nix
Development shell enhancement with Emacs supportshell.nix
• Added Emacs and Magit packages to development shell
• Included
shellHook for EMACSLOADPATH configuration
• Enhanced development
environment with editor support
• Maintained existing valgrind and
other dependencies
.gitmodules
Add Emacs configuration submodule integration.gitmodules
• Added new Git submodule entry for Emacs configuration
• Configured
.emacs.d/terlar-emacs-configsubmodule pointing tohttps://github.com/terlar/emacs-config2 files
pr_description_jmikedupont2.md
CRQ-45 PR description with lattice framework detailsanalysis_data/comms/git/jmikedupont2/CRQ-45/pr_description_jmikedupont2.md
• Large PR description document with CRQ-45 details
• Contains
comprehensive lattice framework implementation description
• Includes
detailed file walkthrough and change summaries
• Documents major
enhancement with multiple new tools and analysis capabilities
pr_description_jmikedupont2.md
Add comprehensive CRQ-42 PR description with lattice frameworkdocumentationanalysis_data/comms/git/jmikedupont2/CRQ-42/pr_description_jmikedupont2.md
• Added comprehensive PR description document for CRQ-42 with 1986
lines of content
• Includes detailed analysis of grand unified
framework implementation with lattice-based code analysis
• Documents
major framework components including code generation, repository
analysis, and development tools
• Contains extensive file walkthrough
with categorized changes across 57 enhancement files
1 files
terlar-emacs-config
Emacs configuration submodule addition.emacs.d/terlar-emacs-config
• Added new Git submodule for Emacs configuration
• Points to specific
commit of terlar-emacs-config repository
• Provides external Emacs
configuration integration
• Enables Nix-based Emacs development
environment
101 files
Summary by CodeRabbit