UPnP IGD: Improve wording and UI

[Self-Hosting-Group]

• Remove Enabled table column as only enabled are shown and rearrange columns

Fixed in 8df0f4a eff5989 02eb8ff 3409e87

• Remove Clear Port Forwards at Startup as it is always cleared

Fixed in 64d27e6 2d430f0

• Left-align table headings to match the rest of the port forwarding tables and content, and describe it more clearly as Active Port Forwards rather than just Forwards
• Use same wording (Port From/Port To) as in Port Forwarding
• Use UPnP IGD to describe the protocol in more detail, as UPnP is also used for many services, e.g. media servers, and this newer/shorter wording is used in other router projects
• Remove unused strings in lang_pack

Screenshot 2024-10 beta release

The Port Control Protocol (PCP) is the successor to NAT-PMP, has similar protocol concepts and packet formats, but adds support for IPv6 port maps and options/extensions. For more information, see:
Port Mapping Protocols Overview and Comparison 2024: About UPnP IGD & PCP/NAT-PMP
https://github.com/Self-Hosting-Group/wiki/wiki/Port-Mapping-Protocols-Overview

[Self-Hosting-Group]

This CSS would need to be inserted to align the table cells correctly:

#upnp_table tr td:not(:last-child) {
  padding-left: 0.543em;
}

[BrainSlayer]

what do you mean with alignment. i made it different and have no alignment issues. i centered the table header names. but i see no issue and no reason for a css change in the gui. please explain

[Self-Hosting-Group]

what do you mean with alignment. i made it different and have no alignment issues. i centered the table header names. but i see no issue and no reason for a css change in the gui. please explain

Currently:

Compare this to the screenshot above, in my eyes the cells need the padding to look good.

[BrainSlayer]

what do you mean with alignment. i made it different and have no alignment issues. i centered the table header names. but i see no issue and no reason for a css change in the gui. please explain

Currently: Compare this to the screenshot above, in my eyes the cells need the padding to look good.

that would only make sense if you change all tables in dd-wrt, just upnp makes no sense of port forwarding etc. are still using the old padding.

[BrainSlayer]

i will not put IGD behind all upnp words. its waste of space, uncommon and not neccessary. check all other router ui's of all vendors you will nowhere find this.

[BrainSlayer]

and yes i checked it. nobody uses it

[Self-Hosting-Group]

and yes i checked it. nobody uses it

Some router UI screenshots that use UPnP IGD:

• OpenWrt
• OPNsense
• pfSense
• FreshTomato
• Asuswrt-Merlin

i will not put IGD behind all upnp words. its waste of space, uncommon and not neccessary.

What solid arguments, even if you consider that the title (H2) is massively shortened.

[BrainSlayer]

the argument is common use.

i checked current asus firmware source. upnp igd is nowhere mentioned. i also checked dlink and tp link firmwares.
but please do not present me screenshots you fucked up by yourself. i checked the merlin-ng sourcecode. you have done this modification. dont fool me. if i check the other projects i'm sure i will find out the same. very bad proof. try better

[BrainSlayer]

you should reflect your actions. your screenshot posts are simply not valid as any argument since you made them up by modifying the projects you presented. i said nobody is using the term you wanted in the ui but you instead try to fool me with screeshots you made up by injecting your own modifications into these projects. but these modifications are far from common use or wording. it reflects just your own oppinion and no standard or valid argument. this is no honest handling or discussion if you go that way