validation

[odanoburu]

subsumes https://github.com/own-pt/own-en/issues/38

references

• targets exist
• pointers exist
• frames exist (and only verbs specify them)
• synset relations exist
• word relations exist
• no duplicate references (two different things with the same name -- if the lexical ids are correct does this ever happen?)
• check symmetric relations? (I think it's good to have the redundancy)
  • probably best left to RDF schema validation
• check there's a head synset to adjective satellites (similarTo relation)

select ?as
where {
  ?as rdf:type ns1:AdjectiveSatelliteSynset .
  FILTER NOT EXISTS {?as ns1:similarTo ?hs .}
  } LIMIT 10

• check if relation is used in the proper place (word relations aren't used in synset positions and vice-versa)

sorting

• check if words senses are sorted
• check if synsets are sorted
• check if word relations are sorted
• check if synset relations are sorted
• check if frames are sorted
• check if examples are sorted

other

• lexical indexing is correct
  • word sense that comes first has lower lexical id
  • no two words with the same lexical id

please add more suggestions.

[odanoburu]

to check reflexivity we can use the following queries, which uncovered a few problems (although most of them are related to own-pt/openWordnet-PT#151)

### problems here
select ?s1 ?s2 # problems
where {
  ?s1 ns1:antonymOf ?s2 .
  FILTER NOT EXISTS {?s2 ns1:antonymOf ?s1}
} LIMIT 10
#

#
select ?s1 ?s2
where {
  ?s1 ns1:hyponymOf ?s2 .
  FILTER NOT EXISTS {?s2 ns1:hypernymOf ?s1}
} LIMIT 10

select ?s1 ?s2
where {
  ?s1 ns1:hypernymOf ?s2 .
  FILTER NOT EXISTS {?s2 ns1:hyponymOf ?s1}
} LIMIT 10
#

#
select ?s1 ?s2
where {
  ?s1 ns1:hasInstance ?s2 .
  FILTER NOT EXISTS {?s2 ns1:instanceOf ?s1}
} LIMIT 10

select ?s1 ?s2
where {
  ?s1 ns1:instanceOf ?s2 .
  FILTER NOT EXISTS {?s2 ns1:hasInstance ?s1}
} LIMIT 10
#

#
select ?s1 ?s2
where {
  ?s1 ns1:memberHolonymOf ?s2 .
  FILTER NOT EXISTS {?s2 ns1:memberMeronymOf ?s1}
} LIMIT 10

select ?s1 ?s2
where {
  ?s1 ns1:memberMeronymOf ?s2 .
  FILTER NOT EXISTS {?s2 ns1:memberHolonymOf ?s1}
} LIMIT 10
#

#
select ?s1 ?s2
where {
  ?s1 ns1:partHolonymOf ?s2 .
  FILTER NOT EXISTS {?s2 ns1:partMeronymOf ?s1}
} LIMIT 10

select ?s1 ?s2
where {
  ?s1 ns1:partMeronymOf ?s2 .
  FILTER NOT EXISTS {?s2 ns1:partHolonymOf ?s1}
} LIMIT 10
#

#
select ?s1 ?s2
where {
  ?s1 ns1:substanceHolonymOf ?s2 .
  FILTER NOT EXISTS {?s2 ns1:substanceMeronymOf ?s1}
} LIMIT 10

select ?s1 ?s2
where {
  ?s1 ns1:substanceMeronymOf ?s2 .
  FILTER NOT EXISTS {?s2 ns1:substanceHolonymOf ?s1}
} LIMIT 10
#

#
select ?s1 ?s2
where {
  ?s1 ns1:similarTo ?s2 .
  FILTER NOT EXISTS {?s2 ns1:similarTo ?s1}
} LIMIT 10
#

#
select ?s1 ?s2
where {
  ?s1 ns1:attribute ?s2 .
  FILTER NOT EXISTS {?s2 ns1:attribute ?s1}
} LIMIT 10
#

#
select ?s1 ?s2
where {
  ?s1 ns1:sameVerbGroupAs ?s2 .
  FILTER NOT EXISTS {?s2 ns1:sameVerbGroupAs ?s1}
} LIMIT 10
#

### problems here
select ?s1 ?s2
where {
  ?s1 ns1:derivationallyRelated ?s2 .
  FILTER NOT EXISTS {?s2 ns1:derivationallyRelated ?s1}
} LIMIT 10
#

## no problems here, actually, just wrong URI see
## https://github.com/own-pt/openWordnet-PT/issues/151
select ?s1 ?s2
where {
  ?s1 ns1:classifiedByTopic ?s2 .
  FILTER NOT EXISTS {?s2 ns1:classifiesByTopic ?s1}
} LIMIT 10

select ?s1 ?s2
where {
  ?s1 ns1:classifiesByTopic ?s2 .
  FILTER NOT EXISTS {?s2 ns1:classifiedByTopic ?s1}
} LIMIT 10
#

## no problems here, actually, just wrong URI see
## https://github.com/own-pt/openWordnet-PT/issues/151
select ?s1 ?s2
where {
  ?s1 ns1:classifiedByRegion ?s2 .
  FILTER NOT EXISTS {?s2 ns1:classifiesByRegion ?s1}
} LIMIT 10

select ?s1 ?s2
where {
  ?s1 ns1:classifiesByRegion ?s2 .
  FILTER NOT EXISTS {?s2 ns1:classifiedByRegion ?s1}
} LIMIT 10
#

## no problems here, actually, just wrong URI see
## https://github.com/own-pt/openWordnet-PT/issues/151
select ?s1 ?s2
where {
  ?s1 ns1:classifiedByUsage ?s2 .
  FILTER NOT EXISTS {?s2 ns1:classifiesByUsage ?s1}
} LIMIT 10

select ?s1 ?s2
where {
  ?s1 ns1:classifiesByUsage ?s2 .
  FILTER NOT EXISTS {?s2 ns1:classifiedByUsage ?s1}
} LIMIT 10
#