Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

rewriting rule 5: PROP&PROP as conj_VERB #35

Open
vcvpaiva opened this issue Jan 21, 2017 · 3 comments
Open

rewriting rule 5: PROP&PROP as conj_VERB #35

vcvpaiva opened this issue Jan 21, 2017 · 3 comments

Comments

@vcvpaiva
Copy link
Member

vcvpaiva commented Jan 21, 2017

_ <conj VERB.

some examples that seem correct:

  1. A man is wearing a straw hat and smoking a cigarette
  2. A bearded man is standing by a shopping cart and is holding a cardboard sign
  3. Two girls are laughing and other girls are watching them
  4. Two spectators are kickboxing and some people are watching
  5. Two large persons are sitting on a park bench and they have a bottle of soda between them
  6. The man is wearing a wetsuit and is riding a surfboard
  7. Women are holding each other and dancing together
  8. A girl is wearing jeans and a pink shirt and is running .
  9. A man is standing on a roof top and playing a violin
  10. a baby sneezed and scared another baby
  11. A baby is sneezing and frightening another baby
  12. Adults and children standing and playing in front of steps near a wooded area
  13. There is no young child wearing a white coat and playing a game
  14. The women are singing and dancing
  15. A costumed performer is singing and people are dancing
  16. There is no boy playing outdoors and there is no man smiling

see the props-de result of 14, 15

difficult:
1.A large tennis ball is being used to teach a dog to run in the grass and catch it with its mouth
2. The man is playing the guitar and has the guitar case open for donations

some sentences don't make sense:

  1. Nobody is on a motorcycle and is standing on the seat
  2. There is no woman driving a car and talking to the man seated beside her
  3. Three young men run , jump , and kick off of a Coke machine
  4. There is no man standing in the middle of a gym and is wearing a jersey .

moved to #44

@vcvpaiva vcvpaiva changed the title PROP&PROP as result of query rewritng #4: PROP&PROP as conj_VERB Mar 15, 2017
@vcvpaiva
Copy link
Member Author

whenever we have a conjunction between verbs, we should annotate it in the dep label, as we will have to rewrite it.

e.g The women are singing and dancing

1 The the DET DT _ 2 det _ DT|?|?
2 women woman NOUN NNS _ 4 nsubj _ NNS|10787470-n|Woman=
3 are be VERB VBP _ 4 aux _ VBP|02604760-v|Entity+
4 singing sing VERB VBG _ 0 ROOT _ VBG|01731031-v|MakingVocalMusic=
5 and and CONJ CC _ 4 cc _ CC|?|?
6 dancing dance NOUN NN _ 4 conj _ VBG|01708676-v|Dancing+

should produce something like
cc_verb (dancing is not noun, but verb!), which needs to give us
The women are singing
and
The women are dancing

@vcvpaiva vcvpaiva changed the title rewritng #4: PROP&PROP as conj_VERB rewriting rule#4: PROP&PROP as conj_VERB Mar 15, 2017
@vcvpaiva vcvpaiva changed the title rewriting rule#4: PROP&PROP as conj_VERB rewriting rule 5: PROP&PROP as conj_VERB Mar 16, 2017
This was referenced Mar 16, 2017
@kkalouli
Copy link

It seems that such issues of conjunctions are dealt with in the enhanced Dependencies of Stanford. All three problematic sentences referenced above, seem to be treated correctly:

  1. A large tennis ball is being used to teach a dog to run in the grass and catch it with its mouth
  2. The man is playing the guitar and has the guitar case open for donations
  3. The women are singing and dancing

@vcvpaiva
Copy link
Member Author

vcvpaiva commented Mar 17, 2017

Thanks for the info @kkalouli !

have you seen stats in
https://github.com/own-pt/rte-sick/blob/master/expanded/conllu/all.conllu.stats.xml ?
they use the scripts for Dan Zeman in http://universaldependencies.org/tools.html#ud-maintained-tools
can you produce similar ones for enhanced dependencies?

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

2 participants