feat: cometbft to rollkit how-to guide #477
Conversation
WalkthroughThe pull request introduces enhancements to the VitePress site configuration by adding two new guides to the sidebar: "CometBFT into a Rollkit app" and "Use Ignite to create a Rollkit app." Additionally, it updates the Changes
Assessment against linked issues
Possibly related PRs
Suggested labels
Suggested reviewers
Poem
Thank you for using CodeRabbit. We offer it for free to the OSS community and would appreciate your support in helping us grow. If you find it useful, would you consider giving us a shout-out on your favorite social media? 🪧 TipsChatThere are 3 ways to chat with CodeRabbit:
Note: Be mindful of the bot's finite context window. It's strongly recommended to break down tasks such as reading entire modules into smaller chunks. For a focused discussion, use review comments to chat about specific files and their changes, instead of using the PR comments. CodeRabbit Commands (Invoked using PR comments)
Other keywords and placeholders
CodeRabbit Configuration File (
|
|
yarikbratashchuk
force-pushed
the
yarik/cometbft-to-rollkit
branch
from
4927f4c to
95ca7b0
Compare
|
Addressing #444 |
|
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Noting my other comment. @yarikbratashchuk needs to either close the issue manually or update the keyword per the documentation.
yarikbratashchuk
changed the title
yarikbratashchuk
dismissed
MSevey’s stale review
The merge-base changed after approval.
![coderabbitai[bot]](https://avatars.githubusercontent.com/in/347564?s=60&v=4){kind=small}
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 3
🧹 Outside diff range and nitpick comments (15)
guides/overview.md (1)
22-23: LGTM! Consider reordering for better organization.The new guide entries are well-formatted, consistent with existing entries, and directly address the objectives outlined in issue #444. They provide valuable information for users working with Rollkit, CometBFT, and Ignite.
Consider reordering the list to group related topics together. For example, you could move these new entries next to other app creation or integration guides:
* [Create genesis for your rollup](/guides/create-genesis) * [Restart your rollup](/guides/restart-rollup) * [Run a rollup full node](/guides/full-node) * [Turn your CometBFT app into a Rollkit app](/guides/cometbft-to-rollkit) * [Use Ignite to create a Rollkit app](/guides/ignite-rollkit)This grouping could improve the overall organization and make it easier for users to find related guides.
guides/cometbft-to-rollkit.md (8)
1-11: Enhance the prerequisites section for clarity.The introduction provides a good overview of the guide's purpose. However, the prerequisites section could be more detailed to ensure users are fully prepared before starting.
Consider expanding the prerequisites section to include:
- A link to CometBFT documentation for setting up a CometBFT app.
- The minimum required version of Ignite CLI.
- Any other system requirements or dependencies.
This will help users ensure they have everything needed before proceeding with the guide.
13-19: LGTM! Consider adding a version check step.The installation instructions are clear and use a specific version of Rollkit, which is good practice.
Consider adding a step to verify the successful installation of Rollkit. For example:
ignite versionThis would help users confirm that Rollkit was installed correctly and show them the installed version.
21-27: Provide more details on Rollkit feature integration.While the command to add Rollkit features is clear, this section could benefit from more explanation.
Consider enhancing this section by:
- Briefly explaining what features are being added.
- Mentioning any potential impacts on the existing app structure or functionality.
- Providing guidance on what users should expect to see after running the command.
This additional information would give users a better understanding of the changes being made to their app.
29-37: Expand on Local DA initialization and alternatives.The section provides a good introduction to initializing Rollkit with Local DA. However, it could be more comprehensive.
Consider enhancing this section by:
- Explaining the benefits and limitations of using Local DA.
- Mentioning any alternative DA options, if available.
- Providing guidance on when to use Local DA versus other options in different scenarios.
This additional context would help users make informed decisions about their Rollkit configuration.
39-49: Provide more details on rollkit.toml configuration.The section explains the purpose of the
rollkit.tomlfile and how to generate it. However, it could be more informative.Consider enhancing this section by:
- Listing some key parameters that can be customized in the
rollkit.tomlfile.- Providing an example of a basic
rollkit.tomlconfiguration.- Adding a link to more detailed documentation on
rollkit.tomlconfiguration options, if available.This additional information would help users understand how to customize their Rollkit configuration effectively.
51-57: Explain command flags and expected output.The section provides the command to start the Rollkit app, but it lacks explanation of the command flags and what to expect after starting.
Consider enhancing this section by:
- Explaining the purpose of the
--rollkit.aggregatorand--rollkit.da_addressflags.- Mentioning what users should expect to see in the console output when the app starts successfully.
- Providing troubleshooting tips for common startup issues.
This additional information would help users understand the startup process and troubleshoot any issues they might encounter.
59-61: Enhance the summary with next steps and resources.The summary concisely wraps up the guide, but it could provide more value to the users.
Consider enhancing the summary by:
- Suggesting next steps for users to explore or test their newly converted Rollkit app.
- Providing links to additional resources, such as Rollkit documentation, community forums, or related guides.
- Encouraging users to provide feedback or contribute to the Rollkit project.
These additions would give users a clear path forward after completing the guide and help foster community engagement.
1-61: Overall, a well-structured guide that meets the PR objectives.This guide successfully addresses the first objective of issue #444 by providing step-by-step instructions for turning a CometBFT app into a Rollkit app. The content is clear, concise, and follows a logical progression.
To further improve the guide and align it more closely with the PR objectives:
- Consider adding a section on best practices for migrating CometBFT apps to Rollkit.
- Include information on how this conversion process enhances modularity and improves data availability, as mentioned in the introduction.
- Add a troubleshooting section to address common issues developers might face during the conversion process.
These enhancements would make the guide more comprehensive and valuable to developers, further supporting the adoption of Rollkit technology.
guides/ignite-rollkit.md (5)
23-25: Consider adding explanations for the command flags.The blockchain scaffolding command includes several flags (
--address-prefix gm --minimal --skip-proto) that might not be immediately clear to all users. Consider adding brief explanations for each flag to improve user understanding.
33-41: Add an explanation of Data Availability (DA) and its importance.While the instructions for setting up a local DA node are clear, the guide would benefit from a brief explanation of what Data Availability is and why it's necessary for a Rollkit app. This context would help users understand the purpose of this step in the overall process.
55-61: Provide more details about the Rollkit features being added.While the command to add Rollkit features is clear, the guide would benefit from a brief explanation of what specific features are being added and how they enhance the blockchain. This information would give users a better understanding of the modifications being made to their project.
75-79: Provide more information about therollkit.tomlfile.While the guide mentions that the
rollkit.tomlfile is used for managing and running the blockchain, it would be helpful to provide more details about its contents and how it affects the blockchain's configuration. Consider adding a brief explanation or linking to further documentation about this configuration file.
91-93: Consider adding next steps or additional resources.The summary effectively recaps the main points of the guide. To further assist users, consider adding a section on next steps (e.g., how to interact with the newly created Rollkit app) or providing links to additional resources (such as Rollkit documentation or community forums) for users who want to learn more.
.vitepress/config.ts (1)
289-296: LGTM! Consider adding collapsed sub-items for consistency.The new entries for CometBFT and Ignite guides are correctly placed within the "How To Guides" section and align with the PR objectives. Great job on addressing the requirements from issue #444.
For consistency with other sections like "Rollkit" and "EVM" under Tutorials, consider adding these new guides as collapsed sub-items under a new "Integrations" or "Migrations" category. This would improve the sidebar's organization as the number of guides grows.
Example structure:
{ text: "Integrations", collapsed: true, items: [ { text: "CometBFT into a Rollkit app", link: "/guides/cometbft-to-rollkit", }, { text: "Use Ignite to create a Rollkit app", link: "/guides/ignite-rollkit", }, ], },
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
📒 Files selected for processing (5)
- .vitepress/config.ts (1 hunks)
- .vitepress/constants/constants.js (1 hunks)
- guides/cometbft-to-rollkit.md (1 hunks)
- guides/ignite-rollkit.md (1 hunks)
- guides/overview.md (1 hunks)
🧰 Additional context used
🔇 Additional comments (3)
guides/ignite-rollkit.md (2)
1-93: Add a prerequisites section and overall approval.The guide provides a comprehensive walkthrough for creating a Rollkit app using Ignite. To further improve it, consider adding a "Prerequisites" section at the beginning, outlining any necessary system requirements, software versions, or prior knowledge needed.
Overall, the guide is well-structured, easy to follow, and covers the essential steps. With the suggested improvements, it will be an excellent resource for developers looking to create Rollkit apps using Ignite.
81-89: Explain the "aggregator" concept and verify the DA address.The command to start the rollup introduces the concept of an "aggregator" without explanation. Consider adding a brief description of what an aggregator is in the context of Rollkit.
Also, ensure that the DA address (http://localhost:7980) matches the address set up in the earlier "Run a local Data Availability (DA) node" section.
To verify the DA address consistency:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Check if the DA address is consistent throughout the guide. # Test: Search for all occurrences of the DA address rg -i 'localhost:7980' guides/ignite-rollkit.md.vitepress/config.ts (1)
Line range hint
1-496: File changes enhance documentation structure.The modifications to
.vitepress/config.tssuccessfully add new entries for CometBFT and Ignite guides to the sidebar configuration. These additions align with the PR objectives and improve the documentation structure for users. The changes are isolated to the sidebar configuration and don't introduce any potential issues to the overall VitePress setup.
Closes #444
Summary by CodeRabbit
igniteVersionTagto the latest version for improved compatibility and features.