Update first/second/non-creative roles

[dltj]

1. Sorted secondAuthorRoles codes and nonCreativeRoles codes
2. Diff'd a combined list of first-, second-, and noncreative-roles with the RelatorSynonyms list (which were updated as part of #4214)
3. Added the missing relator codes into the secondAuthorRoles and nonCreativeRoles

There were many arbitrary decisions make in the third step. For instance, is a medium ("A person held to be a channel of communication between the earthly world and a world of spirits.") a secondAuthorRole or a nonCreativeRole? I picked non-creative. You might make different decisions.

[demiankatz]

Thanks, @dltj! Since @lahmann created the initial defaults here, I'd be interested in his opinion on these changes... but as you say, we can expect opinions to vary in some cases, and fortunately, it's easy enough to reconfigure as needed. I'll leave this open for a while to collect feedback.

If it's not too much trouble, I wonder if it would make sense to open a separate PR to simply alphabetize the lists, so it's easier to look at the diffs and see what's added where in this PR. I don't want to put you to a lot of trouble, though, if you'd have to do all the work over again to accomplish that!

[dltj]

Oh, good! A second opinion would be helpful.

Unfortunately, only kept the last artifact of the process — the diff between the combined list of codes. These codes were missing from three lists plus where I ended up putting them:

Code	Label	Position
abr	Abridger	Second
adi	Art director	Second
ape	Appellee	Second
apl	Applicant	Second
ato	Autographer	Second
brd	Broadcaster	Non-creative
brl	Braille embosser	Non-creative
cas	Caster	Non-creative
cor	Collection registrar	Non-creative
cou	Court governed	Non-creative
crt	Court reporter	Non-creative
dgs	Degree supervisor	Non-creative
dir	Conductor	Second
edc	Editor of compilation	Second
enj	Enacting jurisdiction	Non-creative
fds	Film distributor	Non-creative*
fmk	Filmmaker	Non-creative
grt	Graphic technician	Second
his	Host institution	Non-creative
isb	Issuing body	Non-creative
jud	Judge	Non-creative
jug	Juristiction goverened	Non-creative
kad	Cadential author	Second
med	Medium	Non-creative
mtk	Minute taker	Non-creative
osp	Onscreen preseter	Second
pan	Panelist	Second
pra	Praeses	Second
prv	Provider	Non-creative
rcd	Recordist	Second
rdd	Radio director	Second
rpc	Radio producer	Second
rsr	Restorationalist	Second
sdg	Stage director	Second
sll	Seller	Non-creative
stg	Setting	Non-creative
tld	Television director	Second
tlp	Television producer	Second
wac	Writer of added commentary	Second
wal	Writer of added lyrics	Second
wat	Writer of added text	Second
win	Writer of introduction	Second
wpr	Writer of preface	Second
wst	Writer of supplementary textual content	Second

• Good thing I went back and checked my work — I missed Film Distributor

[demiankatz]

@dltj, most of these make sense to me. Just a couple that might be worth reconsidering:

• Filmmaker is defined in the term list as "A person, family or organization responsible for creating an independent or personal film. A filmmaker is individually responsible for the conception and execution of all aspects of the film." -- this sounds like a creative role to me.
• I'm not sure I'd consider "autographer" a creative role, though I can see arguments either way. (Not asking you to change this one, but curious if anyone has strong feelings about it one way or the other).
• I'm not really sure how these legal relators are used in practice, but it seems inconsistent that we'd call an appellee a creative role and a judge a non-creative role. Shouldn't the legal roles be treated consistently?

[dltj]

Ah, yes, Filmmaker does sound like a creative role — I'll make that change in the final update on the pull request. Autographer, like Medium and others, seemed very much a judgment call — happy to be convinced either way if other commenters have thoughts.

The grouping of legal roles is an interesting question. I guess I was thinking of the platonic ideal of the legal system where the judge is not creative and is just an officer of the court. But making them all the same might make sense.

[demiankatz]

Ah, yes, Filmmaker does sound like a creative role — I'll make that change in the final update on the pull request. Autographer, like Medium and others, seemed very much a judgment call — happy to be convinced either way if other commenters have thoughts.

Thanks!

The grouping of legal roles is an interesting question. I guess I was thinking of the platonic ideal of the legal system where the judge is not creative and is just an officer of the court. But making them all the same might make sense.

I've never seen a record using these relators, so I'm really not sure how they are applied. But if, for example, this is used on a record for a written court ruling that the judge wrote, I would think treating that as a creative role definitely makes sense. If it's used on a transcript of a trial, I would think that would not be significantly different from recording a participant in a documentary (which I believe is handled equivalently to an actor in a fictional film). But maybe there's some other application I'm not thinking of.